b4 indian idol started SRGMP did not have audience voting. then v had gud singers like shreya come out of it. even the winners were well deserving as the judges knew who sang well n who din. but wid audience voting introduced n judges juzz giving a completely senseless rating called hit superhit history etc can v ever get a deserving contestant win a reality shows.
while voting the viewers do not take into consideration how gud n consistent the singer is but which state he is from, how handsome he is (whether he has sexy curly hair etc) n other non-singing factors. this is another reason v don have galz winning bcoz most of the viewers who vote r galz n they vote 4 boyz. hence galz end up high n dry. an example is indian idol 4. v have had 3 gud singers who r galz eliminated.
wht is the use of judges scores n comments if people r not gonna listen 2 them. the chosen one believes tht either they shud scrap the audience voting which is unlikely as the producers will loose out on money or change the format. such tht the judges choose the bottom 4 n audience saves the best 3. this may 2 an extent produce desirable results.