'You don't need to wear a patch on your arm to have honor.'

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

CravingKhana

@CravingKhana

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: madmaxine
Friends, IF-ians, RR-ians, lend me your ears
Semanti comes to bury Rudra, not to praise him
The BDS(M) that men do lives after them,
The rasiya-ve is oft interred with their bones
So let it be with Rudra.
The noble Paro had told you
Rudra was cruel and wrong
If it were so, it was a grievous fault.
And grievously had Rudra answered it.
Here, underwearing Paro and the rest.
For Paro, is an honorable woman.
And so are they all.
All (Laila tsk tsk) honorable women.

IMO, Rudra : Honorable :: Mohini : Polite 😆

Frenz i lent you my ear and you snatched ma brain well what i call a brain

now me no understand nothin...

Quote

Lipstickqueen

@Lipstickqueen

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: Semanti

Is Rudra 'honourable'? And if he is not, how important is 'honour'? Is it overrated? Is it paramount? Or is it something that all of us pay lip service to, while secretly disregarding?

Well written!

No, he isnt' honorable. He may be fierce, loyal to his country and dedicated to a cause but an honorable man doesn't do what he did today. A man who is cornered and afraid and is striking back - that's what Rudy boy is. He is full of bitterness and hate and no one I've ever had the privledge of knowing who had honor had any of those qualities.

I admire his determination but I'm not liking him right now. I know people will justify and say he is cornered, his job means everything etc but to me that's not a good enough reason for his behaviour.

I wish Paro was the type of woman who could kick his ass - quite literally.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

madmaxine

@madmaxine

Inactive

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: serialjunkie
serious kostins sem
Honor is subjective, i guess.

A village would order gang rape of a woman to save its honor

A panchayat would hang lovers of different castes for the sake of its honor

A jury will stone to death an adulterous woman in the name of honor.

A police force would violate human rights to get confession out of terrorists in honor of their country

Rudra thinks he is doing a service for his nation and his means justify the end.

Btw, where is the BSD handbook on How To Treat Your Witness? How about some thinking on How to Conduct a Raid on A Barath?
Or How To Offer Housing to Your Witness?

consumashuns ki love ishtory mein in kostins ki koi jagah nahi

Correct boli.

Honor is subjective. Paro is a revolving door of a subject. 😛

Quote

CravingKhana

@CravingKhana

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: serialjunkie
serious kostins sem
Honor is subjective, i guess.

A village would order gang rape of a woman to save its honor

A panchayat would hang lovers of different castes for the sake of its honor

A jury will stone to death an adulterous woman in the name of honor.

A police force would violate human rights to get confession out of terrorists in honor of their country

Rudra thinks he is doing a service for his nation and his means justify the end.

Btw, where is the BSD handbook on How To Treat Your Witness? How about some thinking on How to Conduct a Raid on A Barath?
Or How To Offer Housing to Your Witness?

consumashuns ki love ishtory mein in kostins ki koi jagah nahi

Dayum again cos she said what I was thinking ...

did we haf da consumashun in thoughts...

telepathy lau makings ?!😳

Quote

hagen

@hagen

Inactive

Posted: 11 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: habs

Well written!

No, he isnt' honorable. He may be fierce, loyal to his country and dedicated to a cause but an honorable man doesn't do what he did today. A man who is cornered and afraid and is striking back - that's what Rudy boy is. He is full of bitterness and hate and no one I've ever had the privledge of knowing who had honor had any of those qualities.

I admire his determination but I'm not liking him right now. I know people will justify and say he is cornered, his job means everything etc but to me that's not a good enough reason for his behaviour.

I wish Paro was the type of woman who could kick his ass - quite literally.

EVEN I WISH PARO TO GIVE IT BACK TO AND NOT SWING WITH HIS TUNE

Quote

Sunara

@princessunara

Trailblazer

+ 8

Posted: 11 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: Jaz1990
You see I can't judge that because what honour means to me may not mean to another person. I'm jus a regular working citizen, however for someone working for their country, honour and their badge might mean everything to them, but on the other if I was to have that same badge with my mentality it wouldn't mean much. I would never understand why people to so much for their badge or honour as I don't see from their view point.

This isn't making sense is it 😆

i think i would subscribe to the same thought process... i said 'think' cz i am not even that sure as to what to think!😆

Quote

Sunara

@princessunara

Trailblazer

+ 8

Posted: 11 years ago

#17

On a serious note, well i am actually confused. cz he TRULY believes she IS GUILTY! We know she is not, but imagine IF SHE WAS actually guilty, would we be asking this question?

example - if the situation was such that there were security cameras that recorded everything and Rudra had all the proof he needed to prove that the bharatis were terrorists. And if everything else happened the same way and Paro was taken in to custody then NOTHING she says will ever get her freedom. She CANNOT prove she is innocent in this situation.
No court or judge will believe her, hell she won't even get to see a court or judge as terrorism is dealt differently. She doesn't have any rights either.. This is not India specific, world over its the same treatment..

Do innocents get ill treated unfairly? = YES
But do real terrorists also get the deserving treatment = yes

So this is a subjective opnion. There is no correct answer as far as i see..

AND another thing. Rudra is NOT going to lose an uniform only. He is going to be court marshaled. Do u know what that entails? Sever physical punishment too along with military jail term. And for what? for doing his duty to the country.

And i honestly don't believe he is doing this to keep a job or an uniform., Its to prove that those soldiers who died did not die in vain..

Quote

DiyaS

@DiyaS

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

#18

THANK YOU for this post!!!

I was angry with Rudra today ... he used his power over a defenseless captive, on whose guilt he has not a shred of evidence, to get back at his scheming aunt, and also to get her to sign a paper to prove HIS innocence.

Neither are the actions of an honourable man.

Are they justified? In the real world, maybe, where grey is really grey. Here the only excuse he has for his actions today is that this is fiction.

Never mind HER innocence ... that doesn't matter. It's all to save his job, which is his life, so it is justified.

Quote

CheshireBilli

@CheshireBilli

Dazzler

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: ttt1
agree with you
the show makers have no idea what they are showing
this is a officer of Indian army , and they are showing it as his method of doing his duty
protection of civilians is of prime importance
they dare not show Indian army in bad light!!!!!
i find nothing romantic about this track

Let's not talk about the Indian Army ya.

Dangerous waters there-- all things honourable, AND dishonourable.

Par abhi ke liye, let's just talk about our personal opinion of Rudra. 😊

Quote

CheshireBilli

@CheshireBilli

Dazzler

+ 7

Posted: 11 years ago

#20

Originally posted by: Jaz1990
You see I can't judge that because what honour means to me may not mean to another person. I'm jus a regular working citizen, however for someone working for their country, honour and their badge might mean everything to them, but on the other if I was to have that same badge with my mentality it wouldn't mean much. I would never understand why people to so much for their badge or honour as I don't see from their view point.

This isn't making sense is it 😆

True story. There is no one definition of honour and that makes this harder to answer.