Critics' Corner # 11

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

tvrasika

@tvrasika

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

#21

Why didn't Sunil take Khanak into confidence? He and Khanak have a good relationship. Why could he not trust her? She has faith in Shaan. Why not Sunil?

Quote

karishma

@shanakyasharan

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#22

he has faith in her gaayu but sunil wants shaan to join business wich is nt wat shaan wants to do as a career wich is y sunil is doing all this...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

tvrasika

@tvrasika

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

#23

I am not sure of that. Is Sunil doing all this, in order to get Shaan to abandon the music dream, and return to their business?

Or is he doing it to make Shaan understand the reality of life?

Btw, I also would lke Shaan to do business than music. That blue guitar brings back some memories which are not very easy on mind...

Edited by tvrasika - 14 years ago

Quote

karishma

@shanakyasharan

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#24

i feel gradually shaan will leave music n return to office job wen they be gin their new life... cause 2day as v aw he aint getting anything in d music world

Quote

tvrasika

@tvrasika

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

#25

LOL... Karish, u also making fun of Shaan? Bechaara... he has just begun to try. it wll take him time to break thru...

Somehow Shaan taking up business seems to have more drama than this music thing.

Quote

karishma

@shanakyasharan

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 14 years ago

#26

gaayu i love him more we in business form n not to frget kt looks yummy in suits n shirts so im all for tht...if music world nt a bad idea but i feel its d business way cause cvs know they went wrong last time so they have learnt...

Quote

dr.dsr

@dr.dsr

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#27

Episode Analysis 3rd June 2011

A thumbs up for...

The first thing that captured my attention...Khanak prodding Shaan to 'face the world' himself! Loved the moment! 👏 The reason for the same could have been more solid though...the preparations for the surprise, coupled with the fact that although Khanak will always be beside Shaan, it's he who finally has to take the plunge!

Shaan's confidence has definitely taken a beating...the unsurity plaguing Shaan's mind despite the awareness of his superlative talent...beautifully captured, that!! 👏

The first encounter in the 'real world' stood out the most for me...newbies having to 'fend' for themselves in the entertainment world...an open secret, really!! Nicely woven into the script, this!!

Loved the sense of calm that has seeped into Shaan...could have to do with the current turn of events in his life, but would like to think it is a natural progression from the Shaan, who the other day, returned to Khanak, as she tried to 'reach out' to him...

A complete thumbs up for Khanak's rendezvous with her Thakurji...earnest, heartfelt, and sooo Khanak...very nicely done, that! 👏

The little tete-a-tete with Madhavi that followed...loved the 'surpised' touch by Madhavi! 👏

Sunil's disiniterested demanour as Shaan expressed his passion for music...brilliantly done, that! 👏

A thumbs down for...

The outburst by Shaan when he is told off by Mr. Mehra...found the moment OTT...something that definitely does not gel with Shaan's persona!

This aspect has to be looked into, as Shaan was shown to react in exactly the same manner in the flashback sequence in the 'Rock On' track, when he was slapped by Rahul!

A reassured, composed response by Shaan in such 'high voltage' moments are more 'Shantanu Khandelwal', IMO!!

Precap...the 'Waqt' track being played out!

As was the case in 'Waqt', hope to see two parallel tracks running...

One, with the Khandelwals' coming to terms with their new found lack of affluence, and the other with ShaNak and their tryst with the world outside K mansion!!

Edited by dr.dsr - 14 years ago

Quote

tvrasika

@tvrasika

Rocker

Posted: 14 years ago

#28

Doc D,

What 'Waqt' track? I only know the old Waqt film. Is that what u r referring to?

Wish I can stay longer but got to go... c u all tmrw.

Krishna, just saw u click 'like'. Do write when u hav time...

Good neend😊

Quote

dr.dsr

@dr.dsr

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#29

Originally posted by: tvrasika
Doc D,

What 'Waqt' track? I only know the old Waqt film. Is that what u r referring to?

Wish I can stay longer but got to go... c u all tmrw.

Krishna, just saw u click 'like'. Do write when u hav time...

Good neend😊

Nahin re, Gaayu...not the old 'Waqt'...the new one that features Amitabh and Akshay Kumar...talks about an irresponsible wayward son, who is thrown out of the house and pushed to face the real world by the father in a similar manner, when the father realises his days are numbered!

Chalo, see ya guys tomorrow after the maha epi...

Good Neend and Sweet Dreams! :)

Edited by dr.dsr - 14 years ago

Quote

-mesmerised-

@-mesmerised-

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#30

Yay the CC is back! 😊

Another good episode today.

The moment that stood out for me the most was the Shanak scene where Shaan wants Khanak to go with him to talk to Sunil. He once again shows his dependence on her and how much he needs her support, but her refusal to accompany him was almost like saying 'this is something you need to do for yourself' - would have liked better reasoning on her part but it did the trick nonetheless! 😃

The Shaan-Sunil convo was very well done. Shaan's hurt and hesitance both evident in his demeanour, Sunil's disinterest in Shaan's passion for music equally seen in his. 👏

Really liked the Khanak-Madhavi conversation. How far they have come! Especially liked the line by Madhavi about how two people who stay together begin to pick up each others habits over time... very true that! ⭐️

My only gripe with the episode... Khanak mispronouncing 'surprise' and 'please.' If the girl can pronounce 'loser' without any trouble (which isn't even a word that's a part of her usual vocabulary), then why is she still saying pleej?! Especially when she has said 'please' on a couple of occasions before this! 🤔 Can't work out the reason for this regression...

All-in-all, a good couple of episodes that have built-up to the confrontation we are about to see tomorrow nicely. Not long to go now... 😊