Critics' Corner # 11 - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

139

Views

9.1k

Users

17

Likes

341

Frequent Posters

shanakyasharan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
gaayu preeti is d gal irritaing aadi fr who he made khanak his so called grlfrnd...lol
tvrasika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
@ Karish

Thanks re... so Preeti is that woman? LOL...


July 6, 2011:

Very good episode. Success doesn't come easily to anyone, in a city where millions come to chase their dreams. Khushi, Adi, Shaan, and GB, all find themselves in a 'slip between the cup and the lip' situation.

All actors did well. I thought Madhurima did well too... this Khushi character is interesting. They should explore more. Simran's character is so predictable.
SK is such a good actor. Loved GB-Pappi scene👏

Khanak was shown in the beginning and in the end- praying for Shaan and waitin for Shaan.

But those veggie bags in GB's room hints at a role for Khanak in the future.

Precap- amazing performance by both KT and Yashu. Especially KT👏
.Dilwale. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: tvrasika

@ Karish

Thanks re... so Preeti is that woman? LOL...


July 6, 2011:

Very good episode. Success doesn't come easily to anyone, in a city where millions come to chase their dreams. Khushi, Adi, Shaan, and GB, all find themselves in a 'slip between the cup and the lip' situation.

All actors did well. I thought Madhurima did well too... this Khushi character is interesting. They should explore more. Simran's character is so predictable.
SK is such a good actor. Loved GB-Pappi scene👏

Khanak was shown in the beginning and in the end- praying for Shaan and waitin for Shaan.

But those veggie bags in GB's room hints at a role for Khanak in the future.


Precap- amazing performance by both KT and Yashu. Especially KT👏



lol gaayu! dont know how to feel about this statement, should i be upset that everyone in the house has their own story and life (even simran with her aim for love) except khanak, who as always is seen waiting up for shaan and tomorrow will be seen being his emotional support. or should i be happy that GB's problem finally indicates and ensures a role for the 'female lead' in the future. either way it makes just leaves me sad. and more so because i am one of the rare few who feel this way.
Edited by zennnn - 14 years ago
destinylove thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
zen
I am with u on this I want Khanak to hve her own success and failure story too.😭
.
why should she always be the sacrificng types..I cant get it..
.really i felt so sad that they gave more space unwantedly to simran character today 😭
anyhow like gaayu said i also think khanak will help GB..soon..that is why i am keeping quiet 😊
but really i want more onscreen space for khanak seriously..as an individual too part from shanak (being shaans wife )...Just as they give for shaan 😭
please dont brand me as shaan hater 😭for saying this
I am a shanak lover with more attachment to khanaks character ..I really want her to grow as an indi vidual like other characters that is it 😊precap coming up part and realitic portrays were very good
Edited by sshriyaa84 - 14 years ago
tvrasika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: zennn



lol gaayu! dont know how to feel about this statement, should i be upset that everyone in the house has their own story and life (even simran with her aim for love) except khanak, who as always is seen waiting up for shaan and tomorrow will be seen being his emotional support. or should i be happy that GB's problem finally indicates and ensures a role for the 'female lead' in the future. either way it makes just leaves me sad. and more so because i am one of the rare few who feel this way.




@ Zennn

Good morning 😊

I don't think you are just one of the few who feels sad about Khanak having no role to play except waiting for Shaan. If you read comments on FB by members from this forum, to Swapna ji, Yash ji, on RBO fan page, to KT, to Yashu, then it is very clear that there are a lot of people who also wish to see Khanak in a very strong role.

No one here says Khanak should do nothing except wait for Shaan.

Everyone here wants Khanak to do something more in life, either study or do a catering business or something.

Why do you feel you are in a minority? No, you are not. This whole forum wants to see Khanak play a major role, and that means, not just be a supporting wife but more than that.

What can fans do? They can write to CVs wherever possible. They can vent here in the forum. Aur kar kya sakte hain? If you have some ideas on what can be done by fans to get CVs to give Khanak a strong role, share your ideas here. Am sure members will support you in this.

I totally understand your frustration with the way Khanak's role has been shown, after ShaNak left the K-house. But am not sure if that should be directed at fans and fellow members here bcos they are not at fault.


.Dilwale. thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
lol gaayu!

I am not directing my frustration at fellow members. I am merely stating a fact. you always make me feel like such a burthal with your comments lol.


I have seen people asking for more shanak yes but very few for khanak. Both are not the same thing. very few had issues with khanak's no show in yesterday's episode. YM is being sidelined for almost a month now. It's not like it happened for the first time yesterday that we should ignore it. So is my feeling that i am in a minority totally wrong? I don't think so.


strong role tu door ki baat hai. simran, adi, khushi, GB and even pappi seem to have more to do than her.


And gaayu, my frustration is always directed at the CVs, whenever i feel the show is being messed up. I believe i already made a topic addressed to them a few days ago and also appreciated everyone's support on it very much.


Sorry to have caused you any offence 😳
tvrasika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
@ Zennn

Let me clarify.

You have not caused me any offence.

I have no intention to make you feel like a budthal. I don't think anyone here comments with the idea of making another person look budthalish. We all have our points of view that is all.

I disagree with you about your point that people ask for ShaNak but not enough ask for Khanak. That's why I refered to those forums, outside of IF, where fans have been bombarding the CVs about Khanak, Khanak, Khanak, Khanak, Khanak.

Regarding Khanak being sidelined, in terms of footage per episode, every time it happened, fans raised their voices and expressed it clearly.

As for ysterday's episode, if you are talking specifically about DT, members' attention was taken up more with the precap.

With the maha episode on in 2 days, it is possible that Yashu's presence was needed elsewhere, for another segment. This is just my guess.

One thing I can assure you, as a member of this forum. If ever members feel Khanak's (Yashu's) role in RBO is being compromised, they will rally around, just like how they did when it was felt Shaan's (KT's) role was being affected. I have never found fans in this forum biased either for or against Shaan or Khanak. They are both loved equally and the actors, equally as well. That much confidence one should have about this forum. And I do.

zarmyna thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
All smiles after today's episode (13th july) but must start my analysis from yesterday's episode.
Meray dukh ki mithai!
Loved the whole sequence. the way he said this was such a signature style. I really like the way he delivers dialogues, pronunciation bang on, and modulation awesome! Then khanak saying "batanay sai pehlai hi dukhi o gaye" was said very cutely, promptly and spontaneously! liked it a lot. Finally they realised that the lie they were living was causing problems for them and they have unknowingly put the lives of two people in a tight situation. Even though Adi is shown to be a flirt, but we can see how serious he is about Khanak and Simran is VERY OBVIOUSLY knee deep in love, although the way she is, she could have fallen in love with anyone!

As usual they fought, which is acceptable here as the first thing any one would do in such a situation will be to reprimand the other and not noticing.

rest of it was blah blah...

loved the precap as this was expected, they are a husband n wife deeply in love and being forced to live apart, i was surprised that Shaan didnt show any emotions when Khanak came to meet him under the blanket! but ofcourse, he was shown more concerned for his survival. (pretty natural)

So TODAY!!!!!!
The first 10 minutes or so, as stated by many, mindblowing!
they both do it quite convincingly. That is how a husband n wife in love are expected to behave, and they go beyond merely caressing the cheeks...very disturbingly near to reality, but breathtaking!

I do hope Adi n Simran realise the foolishness of their reaction coz Shaan put it very correctly when he said to Simran that if someone talks a few statements nicely to u it doesnt show love. Coz Simran literally has done that!

And as I have just found out that the show will end soon, although with the current story line they can do really well, it is quite an intelligent move that the CVs have taken to take the story further. they havent resorted to over the top situations that are silly n make a show unbearable!

They can really show the youth how life means struggle if u want to get somewhere, it is not a bed of roses. as youth today wishes for shortcuts and thru Shantanu they can actually be shown that if a person wants to be someone he has to fight his way thru life's struggles n get there.
I just hope they give it a logical and intelligent end, not a rushed up thing
they need to show Shaan's career starting atleast, if not success
they also need to show Khanak doing something as she said a few episodes ago. and yes she can start a nice catering business.

will miss the show especially since i got hooked on to it this june only!



shanakyasharan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
superb superb superb zarmiya:)

gaayu zenny ...loved yr takes:)
tvrasika thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
@zarmyna

Loved your post. Yes, KT and Yashu make ShaNak so believable. That has been their hallmark always!

RBO story even now has a lot of potential, though it has veered away from the original storyline. Looks like it's the channel's call, in order to fit in with their plans for revamp and what not.

We may see Shaan's career just beginning to take off, if not in full speed. May be this track will end with Shaan admitting how real life is tough and how lucky he was that his family took so mch care of him, even one year after his marriage.

I wish we would see Khanak also start a career or education, as people have repeatedly said here in this forum, but I have my doubts now, with the news of the show ending. Don't know if they will have time for that. If it is extended till September, may be they can show...


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".