Taashu better than ShaNak? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

42

Views

2.4k

Users

15

Likes

265

Frequent Posters

_sana.Magic_ thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#21
Natasa is actually very different from any other girl in any of the other serial who would have turned negative after she lost her love to some other lady.....Natasa not only different from any other girl but is also different from her own family members....She is sober sauve and practical and deals wit every problem categorically and she even helped Shanak [especially Shaan]realize his feelings for Khanak and voluntarily moved out of the relationship Shanak on the other hand has a very sacrificial nature....They can sacrifice for others and even sacrifice themselves....Shaan from the beginning was always confused even after Khanka gave so many hints he longed to hear from the horse's mouth [Khanak]that she loved him Khanak even after knowing that Shaan loves her didnt let out her feelings as she didnt want to put him in"dharamsankat"....They are all different in their own way but yes this was natasha's week and she created magic Hats off to CV's for such an enigmatic show ,couple and Natasha
shockalot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#22
I do think Natasha is the better person out of all three - especially the way she stepped back with so much dignity and still played the role of a best friend by encouraging Shaan to go after Khanak - not many people would do something like that - i don't think I would have been able to do something so self-less like that.

Of course, i adore adore ADORE Shaan-Khanak together, no questions asked, but realistically speaking...they're the budthals here...
-Leah- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#23
Personally i feel that Shan could have only been played by KT.Any other actor would have sucked.😆.I cannot imagie KT playing a hero like Om,Mihir( i hope you'll know these guys)😆.Infact if KT had to enact these roles it would have been a nightmare to watch him😆.I mean we can call Shan immature ,selfish and upteen number of things.We can call Khanak gutless,confused and lacking selfconfidence.Both of them have given enough reasons to justify this.But that is the beauty of their characters.They draw you in so much,that we cant help but hate them,love them and curse them at times.I think for viewers like me i have had kind of a love-hate relationship with Shanak,and even though at times i have been like why should i even watch this?,it doesn't work coz with all their flaws they till are very addicting and keep you wanting for more.Shanak is a bad drug.If you stay away from it for too long i can gurantee you will get withdrawal symptoms.😆


PS: I Love Shanak even though at times i hate them.They can be so stupid.Par main kya karoon they are just too hard to ignore.😆
hirakhatri thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#24
bang on gaayu..

the CVs made natasha exit in the most positive manner..which in exchange made shan and khanak both look like fools..
i wanted them to do something for themselves..but they were shown as losers there...

so much that they didnt even understand the seriousness of it later...fights, jokes, nok jhok is ok, but there shud have been some serious talk before that..

i wonder if they even realised they were at the end of their relationship in case taashu wouldnt have acted..

better or not i cant say but she definitely did act smarter than the burthals...




Edited by hirakhatri - 14 years ago
-Amrita2010 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: shockalot

I do think Natasha is the better person out of all three - especially the way she stepped back with so much dignity and still played the role of a best friend by encouraging Shaan to go after Khanak - not many people would do something like that - i don't think I would have been able to do something so self-less like that.


Of course, i adore adore ADORE Shaan-Khanak together, no questions asked, but realistically speaking...they're the budthals here...

Wow! I loved the way you have expressed it.....Yes, apart of being Shanak fans, we should not forget about others too....If any one does a great thing we should definetly point it out like we do with their mistakes.... Accepting and knowing these are fictious, such situations arise in real life too....no body will be mahan and like you I too would never let my self to lose my fiance to someone else....
I'm proud to say that I'm a Shanak fan and love to watch their nok-jhok in RBO .....but still I can point out their good things as well as the things they are not good at it....
@Bold, I could only say you have let out the exact feelings I have as well
I know that most of you would feel I sound harsh here, but no offence to any one.....I'm simply stating my POV here😊
shanakforever thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#26
every1s post is right on their own place..... yes v surely love r shanak very very much but surely they do act stupid many a times. but still i ignore all of that n love them fr being the budthals that they r...........just think if shaan n khanak werent stupid to not say anything n if natasha wouldnt have done such a gr8 thing would v get 2 c shanak like this the whole week.i know im being biased but i would rather not think of them being stupid n all n enjoy their cuteness
gals u acrry on wid your points im stuck wid my point😆
-Amrita2010 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: shanakforever

every1s post is right on their own place..... yes v surely love r shanak very very much but surely they do act stupid many a times. but still i ignore all of that n love them fr being the budthals that they r...........just think if shaan n khanak werent stupid to not say anything n if natasha wouldnt have done such a gr8 thing would v get 2 c shanak like this the whole week.i know im being biased but i would rather not think of them being stupid n all n enjoy their cuteness
gals u acrry on wid your points im stuck wid my point😆

Girl, you have a point here....We love Shanak because of their stupid acts and we look forward for them to act stupid sometimes......I find it quite enjoyable and stress relieving while watching Shanak scenes.....To conclude I can say that we love Shanak because of their imperfections
shanakforever thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#28
totally agree wid u amrita.in many other serials ppl dont even look at the depth of the character all they look fr is the jodis chemistry n stuff...v all r being too critical but i respect every1s comments out here.........fr me its just shanak n thei scenes i dont take the stress of looking deep into wats wrong wid the way they r reacting 2 the situation.........they r human beings too n they make mistakes......n plus its a serial at the end so just chill meri pyaari shanak deewanis
kubare thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#29

Gaayu...lovely topic as usal dear..adn lovely answers by Manita, Jaya, Priya, Hira, Karishma, Amrita and all...

Agree with all of you...you all made great points dear...but just have to say one thing..the CV's disappointed Big time with the whole sequence...they all of a sudden made Nattie who was ...just as blind to Shaan and the changes in him to not talking to him when she wanted answers , by ignoring his calls him etc...and then...even the signs on the engagement day itself..and then on Dumboos call trying to find out where Shanak were, the look on her face was not a happy one was it, nor was it happy seeing the Mangal sutra still around Khanak etc, suddenly the day her father has the heart attack...we have her realise thats Shaan now loves Khanak and vice versa???? We have her making the sacrafice..her be the big person...but then the argument can also be that we had Shaan and Khanak doing the same...making similar and bigger sacrafices too..
Thus CV's messed up big time...as they missed out on so much in between that needed to be shown... and then when Nattie did the big thing....as they wanted to give Rucha a graceful exit for her wedding from the sow.......we had no serious talk...but nok-jhoks..which is unreal..but keeps to Shanak..way of handling ...things.....of communicating their feelings be it fear, anger, happiness...etc.....
Thus for me Nattie in no way was better then Khanak or even Shaan.
Vistaa thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#30
Wow man, is this forum good or what?😊😊 Whatever be the maturity levels of Shanak or Taasha, I can say this with full confidence that this forum's maturity level is very high😆 Great topic Gaayu, and wonderful discussion by all👏👏👏. In other places, it could have very easily turned into a catfight😉
I am so with you Gaayu, on the premise.....indubitably, Taasha did the right thing, the mature thing, as opposed to Shanak who were on another planet when they decided to do what they did. But methinks, Taasha was prompted by something other than simply altruism.....I think on-off nature of Shaan's affections have really turned her off.....I mean the engagement thing was so out of the blue...before that he had been showing all the signs of falling for Khanak....had even blurted out "I love you, Khanak" in the midst of consoling her (Taasha) and then all of a sudden he supposedly proposes to her and therefter he takes off to Pune with Khanak in tow, for a week's worth of honeymoon like conditions😆 (I know that was Sunil-Akshay's doing, but Taasha doesn't know that) and then he returns to marry her!!!! So, I think to Taasha, this whole marriage thing did ring hollow.....plus, from what I can make out of their initial relationship, Taasha may have been in love with Shaan, in no small part, because he depended on her. He was the quientessial rich brat who was helpless, in the office at least, without Taasha. She was the mature one, the competent one, who did his projects for him. Once he grew a spine (however fleeting😆) and managed on his own, as evidenced by the new textile project, she felt a bit, superfluous. She no longer had the upper hand in the relationship (I know this makes it sound like that she was a control freak, but that is not what I mean here) This may have played a part in her decision.
Or, if we want to be really hard-nosed cynics, it was just the fact that in real life she is getting married soon and will not be available for shooting for some time😉
Agree with all who said that Shaan was the "weakest link" here.....this entire mess was of his creation.....as for Khanak, yes she could have stayed and fought, but I can empathise with her and her insecurities some....she is from a small village, a relatively poor family as compared to the Khandelwals, has less of the urban polish (however misleading) than them, so for her to feel that Shaan and Taasha jodi is more suitable than hers and Shaan's, is understandable to a certain extent. But all these factors did not stop her from holding her own all these months, so why now?
@Hira: really see your point about the third marriage😡 and the fact that they did not have a serious discussion after they returned from the Pune trip.
Once again, hats off to this forum and all its members. Luv you all😃😃

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".