496295 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Hello guys....im Sayali. This is gonna be my ver first post here. Hope i'll get rocking replies to this!

Im actually quite surprised that no topics are made on this...but i wanna ask though:

Is the "Mount College", an actual College or a HIGH SCHOOL IN DISGUISE????

Everything thats shown in here...from the classes to the students to the way they talk, joke and laugh AND the way the fall in "love", it looks like Ekta is copying Twilight word-to-word as far as the Educational institute of Edward-Bella is concerned....Lol looks like she has literally forgotten that its supposed to be a college with mature adults, and not a 9th grade class with fifteen-year olds.

The way people talk and behave, especially the character of "T" or Tanushree, is soo immature and juvenile. From trying to bag new "boyfriends" to brag crudely about her looks and clothes, she's the typical "Popular bitch of the Ninth class". And Kabir and Abhay, they way they like making girls their "girlfirends" just because its "convenient". Adults dont behave this way, teenagers do.


Also, the way people go about making "girlfriends" and "boyfriends" with random people, like they are some props to show off your cool quotient. For example , take Kabir. He has known Piya for less than a month, he's even talked to her a countable number of times (10 or 12), and he's in LOVE with her??????? Are you for real or are you a joke? You dont fall in love so soon.😕

Love is a deep, mature relationship between two people who have known each other for a long time. Being in love, as we get to see in routine soaps too, is about Depth, commitment, compatibility and the Most Important -FRIENDSHIP. You fall in love with someone who you know as a close friend, someone with whom you share an emotional attachment.




But over here, in this show, we do not see the traces of anything called a "serious, mature, relationship" that adults have. (except for Danish and Panchi).😳
😳
Especially the way people like T go about asking people to be their "boyfriends", like it was in high-school where hormonal immature teenagers need a "Boyfriend" or a "girlfriend" to be "cool" among their peers. Same for Kabir....LOLOLOL he's got a crush on Pia and he drunkenly delcares his "lubbe" for her at a party, 70's love-at-first-sight Ishtyle. And piya too smartly tells him that "I'll be your girlfriend", like "i'll be your class monitor" or "i'll be your lab partner". Man, these guys live in outer space i tell ya -even a 16 year old nowadays knows the difference between a crush and a serious love.😆



And last but NOT THE LEAST -the "relationship" that Abhay-Pia share. Can someone exactly tell me what EXACTLY it is????? So far what we go to watch, Abhay shares a love-hate attraction to Piya's face for some chick he knew 100 years ago, and Piya too for some reason (why????😕) is attracted to him, like an iron bar to a magnet. Now the question is : WHAT EXACTLY (again) is their relationship going to be like? Even leaving aside the fact that you need to be close Friends with someone to LOVE him/her, the thing is that Abhay /Pia dont even know each other well enough to have a crush on each other. They're just attracted -thats it.😲

Normally, in most shows, they show that after the initial attraction, the hero and heroine get closer to each other, become FRIENDS, and then a couple , like it should be. Here, all we see is Unbridled attraction /sexual tension / chemistry..........and the story is continuing on in those lines. What are they going to show next? That the two become a ACTUAL COUPLE just because of this attraction? Here, its just going on...abhay and piya are virtually strangers to each other, but "coming closer and closer" because they are physically attracted. So here the Million-dollar question arises:


Will PKYEK be a lust-story like Twilight (where the characters liked each other coz one sparkled and the other tasted nice), OR a proper, normal, mature love-story? IM AFRAID IT'LL BE THE FORMER WAY.🤡

So Ekta, please, put things together, make the story a more adult one. Please remember that you've decided to make this story DIFFERENT from Twilight. And "different" includes the character natures.....dont copy the teenage characteristics of Twilight characters.

Now lets hear your take on this? What do you all say?


PS: Please no bashing of actors/characters. Also, refrain from lecturing me that "stop watching if u dont like " and all such stuff. Thank you.😃




Edited by sayali_babes - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

49

Views

2.7k

Users

7

Likes

54

Frequent Posters

leeseunggilove thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
hmm wat do u mean....colleges also have d same atmosphere..
n waise bhi its an ekta show....
bt even still sayali i think d plot has been played out nicely....
abt abhya relation ship..well its gonna be love at d end of d day..bt fr d time being they are on a hate each oder mode...
nice post!
496295 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: luv_wacko

hmm wat do u mean....colleges also have d same atmosphere..

n waise bhi its an ekta show....
bt even still sayali i think d plot has been played out nicely....
abt abhya relation ship..well its gonna be love at d end of d day..bt fr d time being they are on a hate each oder mode...
nice post!



Nah, my point was that the people on this show dont seem to be "adults". Thats why Kabir proposed to Piya and made he rhis girlfriend when he just "likes" her. Also, in college, u dont have immature people like T who has no business than to keep thinking of guys.🥱

And the most is.....that the essence of "love: isnt being portrayed here....people are becoming girlfriends/boyfriends without even knowing each other...LOL😛😉. Like in Highschool where u have "dating contests".😆 I hope u get my point.
Edited by sayali_babes - 14 years ago
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
Lol!! People don't do such stuff even in high school, dear😆
I don't find anything similar to twilight, no.1. No.2, I'm glad its not the 'usual' love stories shown. The way you're describing it to be a bit more 'adult', I doubt I really want that😕
About your P.S., so even you know that if you don't like it then you should stop watching it. Thats not a lecture thats common sense🤔
496295 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Chill_Out

Lol!! People don't do such stuff even in high school, dear😆

I don't find anything similar to twilight, no.1. No.2, I'm glad its not the 'usual' love stories shown. The way you're describing it to be a bit more 'adult', I doubt I really want that😕
About your P.S., so even you know that if you don't like it then you should stop watching it. Thats not a lecture thats common sense🤔



bold: except that its not "love" yet.😆 Also, have you read the whole post? People dont have "relationships" with people they just have a crush on, in High School? Also, the most important part was that the lack of maturity in the behaviour of the charaters. By "adult" i mean a real love story and not just lust. Here people who dont know each other are falling in love...is that possible?..😕
Edited by sayali_babes - 14 years ago
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sayali_babes



bold: except that its not "love" yet.😆 Also, have you read the other parts of my posts?

Of course I have!😕

P.S. Yes its not love yet😆
But can't wait for the love *sigh*😍
496295 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
ive edited my 3rd post above.
Ameres thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
they are behaving like teenagers becuase they are playing teenagers; 17 or 18 year old college going students!
and about becoming BF or GF...well Kabir really likes Piya and he is terming it as love...maybe he is being hasty but thats exactly what Piya told him in yesterdays epi that they need more time....
about Abhay-T well they are just pretending to be in a relationship....
and Abhay-Piya relation is complicated cuz its Not physical attraction...its more then that....the mystery about Maithli is yet to be revealed whcih i think will answer your qauestion about Abhay-Piya relation, why they try to run away from each other but still end up coming closer...
and above all its a youth oriented show so it will have a bit of immutare n fun scenes...lot of shows have that 🤔....its supposed to be a mystery love story n it will take some time to develop further...its only been a month....
and if u dont like it at all then u can always switch to another show...
just my opinion...😊
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sayali_babes



bold: except that its not "love" yet.😆 Also, have you read the whole post? People dont have "relationships" with people they just have a crush on, in High School? Also, the most important part was that the lack of maturity in the behaviour of the charaters. By "adult" i mean a real love story and not just lust. Here people who dont know each other are falling in love...is that possible?..😕

Right! In high school, people who want relationships have it with even people they despise (at least in my high school they did). And those who don't will not have with people they like also. As far as crush is concerned, crush is when you don't know the person well. I don't believe in love at first sight. Its rubbish, but there is infatuation at first sight. I totally have a crush on Shahid Kapoor but I can't say I'm in love with him because I don't know him personally (weird comparison but it comes down to something similar only). And as far as 'real love' goes, T and Abhay do not love each other. Piya wants to give herself and Kabir a chance and as far as Kabir goes, maybe he doesn't 'love' Pia but somewhere down the line, what he feels for her is more than what he feels for any other girl and he believes that love can happen if it hasn't already.
Lastly, they may be above high school but they are college kids after all! The kind of maturity you're talking about doesn't come before 24-25 (I've been told so by someone very knowledgeable so I'm assuming he's right), Thats actually the time one can truly judge 'love', etc.
Lastly, we cannot ignore the fact that this is fiction. We should not get into so many details. Just sit back, relax and enjoy (and for that, we also have to grunge down our 'maturity level' a bit😆

But *superlike* for raising some brainstorming points!😃
496295 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sugaryanu

they are behaving like teenagers becuase they are playing teenagers; 17 or 18 year old college going students!

and about becoming BF or GF...well Kabir really likes Piya and he is terming it as love...maybe he is being hasty but thats exactly what Piya told him in yesterdays epi that they need more time....
about Abhay-T well they are just pretending to be in a relationship....
and Abhay-Piya relation is complicated cuz its Not physical attraction...its more then that....the mystery about Maithli is yet to be revealed whcih i think will answer your qauestion about Abhay-Piya relation, why they try to run away from each other but still end up coming closer...
and above all its a youth oriented show so it will have a bit of immutare n fun scenes...lot of shows have that 🤔....its supposed to be a mystery love story n it will take some time to develop further...its only been a month....
and if u dont like it at all then u can always switch to another show...
just my opinion...😊



Exactly. He only "likes" Piya. thats my point. And grown-ups dont chase people they "like". They fall in love spontaenously through friendship. Kabir knows Piya for only a few weeks so how can he say this is love?😕😳

Yeah its not mere physical attraction on Abhay's part, but it definitely is so for PIYA.

I dont think anybody is really getting my exact point. 😆
And yes people in college are immature, but that immaturity of a 19 or 20-something is different from the immaturity of a 15-year old, which is how they are behaving.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".