So Pratigya agreed to lie - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

58

Views

4k

Users

17

Likes

174

Frequent Posters

damon_biteme thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: lovanika

If today Pratigya had stood up to her father and said "No dad this is wrong and I will not lie to Krishna. He is my husband and I want him to know everything"



Lovanika, i don't even care abt her lying to her husband, I am intrested in why didn't she tell her dad 'irrespective of the fact that he is my husband as a human being the lies have affected his life too so he deserves to know the truth
'
Edited by krishna_chalbo - 15 years ago
lovanika thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: krishna_chalbo



Lovanika, i don't even care abt her lying to her husband, I am intrested in why did she tell her dad 'irrespective of the fact that he is my husband as a human being the lies have affected his life too so he deserves to know the truth
'

Yes but yet again it seems she made a wrong decision....and people are happy that she made SS come to her door....Just don't get it...
rightchoice thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#13
Tell you what, people will be rejoicing that Pratigya did not forget the past and she will continue giving cold shoulder to Krishna...

Let us see what is the difference between the lie she was asked to tell by Krsihna and now by her father...
1. Krishna asked to tell it to please his family...
2. Professor has asked keep the truth hidden to safeguard her marriage. What marriage? marriage based on the lie? Who is going to believe her later if she says nothing had happened...? People will ask, if nothing had happened then why it was hidden at first place?

So even if we have to think OK, the two scenarios are different, she created more havoc for a petty lie which could have been resolved in private....

She opposed to lie then and started hating Krishna even more
Now, she opposed her father feebly, but agreed to hide the truth.

She had nerve to tell in front of every one that Krishna made her to lie. Will she have the same audacity to declare her dad had asked to keep the matter secrete when this comes out?

I am totally disappointed in the way truth was revealed...this girl has no remorse for treating Krishna like that....
It is like her saying, "OK, he did not do what I thought was a crime, but he is still at fault. I am going to punish him for the smallest to smallest mistake he committed..."

This girl has no introspection for treating KRISHNA like a dog...

AqUaMaRiN thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: lovanika

Pratigya keeps on doing stuff that makes me think how strong a character she has.
Is she even strong or just a girl who takes an easy way out....
Hmmm.... EASY WAY OUT, u say?
So, marrying Krishna was the EASIER WAY than commiting suicide, I suppose!
Going along with Krishna's lies and trying to make him understand that lying is not right was the EASIER WAY than being choked or r***d?
Speaking up in front of the MCP Thakurs was the EASIER WAY than just going along with Krishna's lies and faking the pregnancy forever!
Interfering in Shakti's attempt to kill Kesar's baby and saving the baby was the EASIER WAY for Pratigya to adjust in the ZOO!
IF u really think that what Pratigya went through was the EASY WAY, then I really dont want her to take the HARDER WAY - strong or NOT!😉
Part I - Krishna asks her to behave like pregnant and keep quiet. Tell a lie.
Pratigya's reaction: I will not do it...but she did it...then finding the right time to hit the iron when the blame went all on Krishna, he also got ridiculed in front of his family and friends, she insulted the family and then bang the easy way out - I will not live here in this house......She was safe...people applauded her for not scumbing to SS or Krishna...
IF I remember correctly, the whole blame went on Pratigya and she was labelled as the liar, and Krishna was one of the Thakurs who called her a liar as well! Krishna was blamed and ridiculed coz he couldnt FORCE himself on his wife or control the clutches of his wife!
So, Pratigya being ridiculed and accused for a lie that Krishna said, would have been better to u than Krishna being ridiculed for the foolish lie he started? Pratigya being slapped and humiliated would have been better than Krishna and his family being insulted for insulting a woman?
Right, so u r saying Kesar is the STRONG one, since she never opposed to the Thakurs' MCP ways and never have thought of leaving the Zoo with the hope of change in Shakti, someday and at the cost of the lives of 4 unborn babies? U think its that easy for a girl in an unfair society and an MCP family to declare that she is leaving her sasural?
Well, if thats the EASY WAY, then I am PROUD of Pratigya for avoiding the DIFFICULT WAY and be another Kesar! And yup! I applaud her for not succumbing to SS or Krishna - strong or NOT! I dont think Krishna would have EVER realized that slapping or beating up one's wife is NOT NORMAL, IF Pratigya had just taken the HARD WAY and stayed in the Zoo!😕
Part 2: Shayam ji tell her to hide the truth about her kidnapping..he also took ehr promise..she said it is not correct..but she still went ahead and gave ehr promise....After knowing that this matter is very delicate and now her izzat is at risk that seh spent a night with another man or her kidnapper seh is going to hide it from Krishna...
I understand that Pratigya letting Krishna know about the kidnapping incident is the right way and so did Pratigya! BUT how exactly did u expect Pratigya to refuse her parents when they r assuring her saying that they have seen more of the world than her and she should promise them? Its not her fault IF her parents are bent on misleading her!
And Why is her izzat at risk? Nothing happened to her and no matter when the truth comes out, IF Krishna decides to believe in his enemy than believing in his beloved wife, its not Pratigya's fault that Krishna's love is not strong enough!
BTW, I dont think there is ny lie or truth about the kidnapping COZ Krishna doesnt even KNOW about it! So, they all r just not letting Krishna know about the kidnapping! Its not like they r making up something (lies) to hide the kidnapping incident - atleast not yet!
Pratigya: How convinient. Lolzzz. I think IF Pratigya had told Krishna about the kidnapping incident, it would've been the EASY WAY coz, she would have done wat she wanted to do b4 her parents made her promise otherwise! NOW, that she has made the promise to her parents, she would be in dilemma and at unease for not letting Krishna know about the kidnapping! How is that convenient for/of her?😕
My question is if Pratigya is SOOOOO Strong and balanced girl then:
A- Whay she didnot refuse to be a part of this. For one, her parents assured her that it was the right thing to do by saying that sometimes hiding the truth by thinking of it as a lie is for one's happiness,🤢! They even told her HOW Krishna might kill Angad off or break his marriage with her... And also, by saying that they have seen more of the world than her, ie. they r better thinkers than her - yeah right!😒 NOW, u wont say Pratigya trusts Krishna (that he wont do ny such thing!) more than her parents, would u? And Krishna dint really do nything that would make her trust him and not believe in her parents words!
B - Why she did not lecture her dad about it. Its mainly coz of the reasons mentioned above, ie. her dad started with his OWN lectures b4 Pratigya could start her own!😉 NOW, u dint really think she would stand a chance when the opposition party is her own Prof. DaD, did u?😆
C- Why now she thinks it is ok to lie. Ohk! So wat EXACTLY is her LIE? DO u consider Pratigya NOT letting Krishna know about the kidnapping incident as a LIE? I thought lying was twisting the truth and so far, Pratigya has not done ny such thing! I mean, Krishna does not even know about the existence of the kidnapping and he will have to interrogate Pratigya, b4 Pratigya even starts to lie and refuse the kidnapping, right? Well, if Pratigya can lie about the mantras of the marriage, then, yeh toh kuch bhi nahin, right?😆
D- Why now Krishna should not know the truth. Apparently, Pratigya believes that her parents know about the world more than her, and according to them Krishna might kill Angad and might not believe that nothing happened to Pratigya and break off their marriage... AND I really dont blame her if she cant trust Krishna (COZ, I cant either!😆) that he would NOT kill Angad or believe in her TRUTH!
E- Will she SLAP her father when the truth comes out in public.
Hmmmm.... Are we watching the same serial? 😕😆 Or, do u expect a daughter who cares soo much about her dad's self-respect to follow Krishna's way?
F- Will she creat teh same drama in front of public but this time humulating her dad for her "rights" .."My dad is the one who told me to lie"..
Knowing that Pratigya is totally opposite of Krishna, I think she herself would rather be humiliated and insulted by the MCP Thakurs than dragging her family or dad in it!!! Duh! She dint even bring up the Thakurs and their MCP ways when the Politicians came upon their door and started blaming the Thakurs... So, I dont see how u expected her to put the blames on her own dad,😕, unless, u just dont want to see her POV, ofcourse!😆
I am wondering how conviently Pratigya changes her attitude. She is not consistant with it..
Oh HOW I wish Pratigya would change her attitude conveniently just like u said!!! I am really tired of her consistency & high tolerance levels!😆

damon_biteme thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: rightchoice


I am totally disappointed in the way truth was revealed...this girl has no remorse for treating Krishna like that....
It is like her saying, "OK, he did not do what I thought was a crime, but he is still at fault. I am going to punish him for the smallest to smallest mistake he committed..."

This girl has no introspection for treating KRISHNA like a dog...



Now that is what annoyed me abt her today okay who i am lying to she always annoys me😆😆😆. On a serious note. Okay lets go back to the marraige proposal. SS went with a marriage proposal to her house which they rejected and Krishna left the house saying now this marriage will take place only after the proposal comes from your side. So Krishna had left them, then the kidnapping happened for which baba got framed and she decided to marry him to teach him a lesson. As a result of that Komal was forced to marry Aadarsh who treats her like a second class citizen.😡 Since the wedding she has treated him with comtempt and pushed him to limits where he has commited unacceptable acts.

Now when she realised that the kidnapping- based on which she decided to marry Krishna was not done by him she felt no remorse or guilt. I didn't see her once acknowledging that because of my decision which was based on a misunderstaning i have ruined other people's life. She was quick to tell that i don't hate krishna but then i don't love him as he forced his love on him. She still doesn't want to accept that he had left their family till she went and declared ' Bhaiya Yeh Wo Ladka Hai Jis Se Aap Ki Behan Shaadi Karna Chahati Hai' .
Seriously Pratigya Ji besides taking Pratigyas u need to also acknowledge your mistakes



dkmystery thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#16

Totally with u limits, very well written! 👏
actually, people who are against a self-respecting girl will always find faults with her actions! if Prats would have not slapped Angad or answered him back, they would have said, 'now where is the strong Pratigya?'
if she would have refused her dad's wishes to not tell Krishna about the kidnapping, then all the kids who hate schools would have started, 'is this how educated girls behave'
🤣

so at the end of the day, whatever she does is wroooooong, the only right thing will be that she accepts Krishna and his lub and his beatings and become 2nd Kesar 😃
...Binny... thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#17
Hi limits well I completely agree with you on this matter, by the way I find it hard to compare krishna's lie about the pregnancy to pratigya not letting krishna know about something because she fears his usual angry reaction to situations. Krishna completely lied to his parents about his wife being pregnant, which is a shame since he knew how badly they wanted a grandchild. but when he lied his parents knew about the situation and were waiting for him to confirm the news, he also had an opportunity to tell the truth yet he continued to lie and he forced prats to lie. She repeatedly told him and gave him many examples of how the lie could not go on forever and how much it would hurt his family members, and his reaction to her was attempt to rape. Even after tolerating physical and mental abuse because of krishna and his family members she had the guts to tell the truth in front of everyone while her husband stood their and let her take all of the blame since she refused to lie for him. Now even after all of this she did tell her dad she wanted to tell Krishna the truth but it's hard to go against her dad when she knows very well that Krishna is capable of killing angad, and she has seen how obsessive he is of her so i don't blame her if she can't trust someone like him to have faith in her. i have a question though during Krishna's lie it was prats that got slapped right so why would she slap her father. anyways prats has always respected her in laws as well as her family members and she has never humiliated them in public. Even during the pooja I think only the two families were their and they all deserved to know the truth, also creating scenes in front of the public seems to be krishna and his families pass time.
Edited by Binny1247 - 15 years ago
AqUaMaRiN thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: dkmystery


Totally with u limits, very well written! 👏
actually, people who are against a self-respecting girl will always find faults with her actions! if Prats would have not slapped Angad or answered him back, they would have said, 'now where is the strong Pratigya?'
if she would have refused her dad's wishes to not tell Krishna about the kidnapping, then all the kids who hate schools would have started, 'is this how educated girls behave'
🤣

so at the end of the day, whatever she does is wroooooong, the only right thing will be that she accepts Krishna and his lub and his beatings and become 2nd Kesar 😃

Hey Diva! Lolzzz... I am still confused about WHAT gave the topic starter even the vague idea that Pratigya could slap her own dad?
I am guessing she meant it sarcastically coz Pratigya is at the top when it comes to slapping in this serial!😆 BUT comparing Prof. Shyam, a father with the likes and levels of Krishna - first a stalker & then a husband who tried to force himself on his wife twice OR Angad - an eave-teaser and a kidnapper ... is wat shocked me!😲😆
And I agree with u and realize that wat u said is the case with MOST Krishna-lubbers... BUT I guess to each their own opinion!
shumi. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: lovanika

My question is if Pratigya is SOOOOO Strong and balanced girl then:
A- Whay she didnot refuse to be a part of this.
B - Why she did not lecture her dad about it.
C- Why now she tghinks it is ok to lie.
D- Why now Krishna should not know the truth.
E- Will she SLAP her father when the truth comes out in public.
F- Will she creat teh same drama in front of public but this time humulating her dad for her "rights" .."My dad is the one who told me to lie"..
I am wondering how conviently Pratigya changes her attitude. She is not consistant with it..

🤣...padi likhi pratigwa kay leyeh yeh sab chalega i can say one thouand one strong and valid reasons for her lie 🤣...par unpad krishna kay leyeh nahi.after all he is unpad...😆 any way don't worry ...all her sanskaar ,fighting for women's right blabh blah blah...gayeh tel lene...cuz she is going to fall for unpad gawar krishna who slaped her, try to rape her, physically absued her during honey moon, insulted her for shaking hand with a stranger/white man,married her by force etc etc etc....🤣...all his so called crime gayeh tel lene...🤣
it will be fun to watch those who all raised their voice against his crime...😆
Edited by shumi. - 15 years ago
damon_biteme thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: shumi.

🤣...padi likhi pratigwa kay leyeh yeh sab chalega i can say one thouand one strong and valid reasons for her lie 🤣...par unpad krishna kay leyeh nahi.after all he is unpad...😆 any way don't worry ...all her sanskaar ,fighting for women's right blabh blah blah...gayeh tel lene...cuz she is going to fall for unpad gawar krishna who slaped her, try to rape her, physically absued her during honey moon, insulted her for shaking hand with a stranger/white man,married her by force etc etc etc....🤣...all his so called crime gayeh tel lene...🤣

it will be fun to watch those who all raised their voice against his crime...😆



Shumi hats off to such positivity. 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".