dadisa's refusal to take the right decision - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

3.3k

Users

13

Likes

101

Frequent Posters

angel3 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
exactly when the most sensible person DS failed to see the real sanchi ofcourse anandi would be confused to distinguish between the real and fake side of sanchi
anandi has seen sanchi's inputs and transitions from the arrogant sanchi to very much in love with jagya and ready to change from a city girl to a would be village bindni ( though sanchi managed to fool the shekhar's , singh's very well ) then why blame anandi for this
it would hav been better if J would have ignored sanchi's over friendliness prior only or rather talked with anandi for once before saying yes to marry Sa
its high time that DS to be back in action n solve this chaos
goofyCat thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#12
Each and every character getting butchered up in Sanchi's track in some way.. thats the only thing I can figure out here 😲
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
dadisa is not at fault because she is not sure about how jagya and ganga feels about each other and not sure if supporting ganga over saanchi would get any fruitful results...plus saanchi is anandi's SIL...dadisa can just not say ''i have experience so i know saanchi is faking things''...she needs to think about anandi too...i feel in this saanchi drama only jagya and anandi (to some extent) have power to put a stop to this nonsense...let's not even think of shekhars as they are big hungry jokers and nothing else...there brain can never work for good things
leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: libsrocks

dadisa is not at fault because she is not sure about how jagya and ganga feels about each other and not sure if supporting ganga over saanchi would get any fruitful results...plus saanchi is anandi's SIL...dadisa can just not say ''i have experience so i know saanchi is faking things''...she needs to think about anandi too...i feel in this saanchi drama only jagya and anandi (to some extent) have power to put a stop to this nonsense...let's not even think of shekhars as they are big hungry jokers and nothing else...there brain can never work for good things



But dadisa asked ganga about the suitability of sanchi but did not take ganga's reply as seriously. And dadisa is not talking to Jagya like she used to do previously and instead tries to ignore him. Nowadays, dadisa only listens to sumitra and she agrees to whatever sumitra suggests. This is rather strange and inexplicable. She knows that Jagya is capable of breaking the rishtas and she did not even think that Jagya may do the same with sanchi if he finds her not suitable which will ultimately harm anandi more.And dadisa using anandi excuse for everything under the sun!
smittu thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#15
yes DS shd take a stand...tht will def help JaGan...otherwise, thse days, Sumitra is acting too weird
jaya.s thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: Missesha

I have a different perspective here and I find DS commendable for balancing out her family.

Sumitra is her family and so is Jagya, but Ganga is not. The way the events unfolded, she chose to maintain peace in her family first over giving priority to a sheltered woman.

After RAT incident Ds could not deny the fact that there was lapse on her part for security, that Sumitra is not wrong if she no longer wants to put with G, that G also has her pride so leaving BH is a fair decision. So she did not blindly support Sumi, but she knew it is best interest for both Sumi & G. Ds also knows that J likes to help G, but she also knows that Sumi is not wrong if she expects J to spend some more time with Sa rather than G, so she can't find faults with Sumi there.

Ds likes G but not more than her own family's security, lives or personal lives. Hence she did not stop G from leaving BH nor has insisted that G should come back to Jaitser, but she is happy to support her financially through J and wishes well, so shows sympathy to G in whatever way she can (but she is not doing anything over & above for G).

Ds also knows that J finds solace in helping G, that's why she told Sumi, to give him time to forget G and asked Sumi not to tear G's pic. However, I don't think Ds realises that J loves G or that there is anything further between J-G besides give and take.

She likes Saanchi, and like others she has also been fooled by Sa, and belives that is her true nature. So why would she complain?

Why people have expectations from A to step up is because A knows a lot about the story, that DS does not.

A knows J-G love each other

A knew J found Sa a brat before engagement

A knew Sa's rude side

A knows about lapses made by Sa often in her pretence, but she neglected those, etc.

Ds does not know any of the above to take any call against Sa.

Ds is silent because according to her all are fine in their places: Sa, Sumi, Ganga, Jagya everyone.



Good analysis. Sound reasoning.
Picasso9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#17
I agree with Esha, here.
DS may be the most experienced and shrewd of the lot but no doubt about it, Jagya's betrayal jolted her. She has change from a dictator who overruled everyone in her household to a more understanding old lady.

Saanchi's misdemeanors were never in front of DS and neither have they been discussed with her by anyone else who observed Saanchi's behavior firsthand. Granted that instinctively she should be able to sense whether Saanchi is a right fit or not but bear in mind that she even though deep inside she may feel Saanchi is wrong, she is choosing to keep silent because she doesn't want a repeat of the past. She has given the reigns to Jagya's parents because she self admitted that she had played a huge role in the spoiling of Jagya. Of course she can't undo the past, but DS is doing typically what most f us would do, I.e. go from one extreme to another ( as in too much involvement to bare minimum). Note how she advised Gehna to give more attention to Nandu because it was a Nazuk period for him with a new sibling. The old DS would have shouted at her and dictated to her what to do.

Anandi is privy to the Jekyll and Hyde personas of Saanchi. Comparing Anandi's lack of action to DS's does not put Anandi off the hook.

DS will take the right decisions once she is aware of the true story. Of course, initially she will be angry at J until she hears the complete story. Remember how when he arrived late for the engagement, how angry she was with him. That's because her fears had surfaced. Her fears that he had run away. So too when she hear to the rishta breaking, they will all think J is back to his old tricks but will understand once they hear everything from him or Anandi (if she chooses to speak up). Only Sumitra will be stubborn and the most unsupportive mother.
leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#18
Mistakes are committed by everyone and the ultimate sufferer will be those who tried to cover up or encouraged blindly. In this case the coverup was done by anandi and encouragement to wrong people has been done by dadisa. They will bear the brunt more than others except of course sumitra.

It will be interesting to see how shiv reacts to the entire thing.

Rejection of sanchi will not become acceptance of ganga too soon. Unless some miracle happens.

Kahaani ab baaki hain.😆
Edited by leavesandwaves - 12 years ago
leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#19
One thing that is heartening is Jagya and his clear vision. And also taking timely action before it is too late. Ready to face the wrath of the entire world.
Angie12 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#20
Leaves,
They have shown changes in two characters - Dadisa and Anandi. One can say that they have changed their characterizations. But to me it seems as if the changes in both are gradual and can be considered logical.
Dadisa
Dadisa is a principled person and always had a lot of strength and guts. She ruled the family with her iron fist. She was a person who believed in old traditions and protected them with ferocity. Basant was her obedient son and Bhairav (the one who takes after her) the rebellious one. Sumitra of course is one of wishy washy personality and hence looked up to Dadisa while Gehna rebelled. Because of circumstances and events, eventually Dadisa realized her mistakes and evolved with time more than any other members of her family (except Bhairav who was always very open minded).
But the old age and return of Jagya and his redemption has mellowed her. Once Jagya started living up to her ideals and made up for his mistakes with Anandi happily married, she is free of all guilts and is happy to have this family. So she has actually retired and given the control to Sumitra (unworthy one as she doesn't have Dadisa's strengths or values).
Then Ganga comes in whom Dadisa sees signs of old Anandi and who too became Dadisa's favorite. But when it came to conflict between her and Sumitra, she chose Sumitra over her. Can we really blame her for that? She chose to preserve her family rather than fighting over her ideals because probably she is now too old and too mellowed.
She has doubts about Sanchi and she has expressed them to Anandi/Sumitra from time to time. She is choosing to believe in Sanchi because it is convenient for her. It preserves her family and her illusions that Jagya would be eventually happy.
Will she stand up for Ganga? I really believe that she would when it comes to crunch time. I feel that it would be Dadisa and Bhairav eventually who will stand up for Jagya because he is important to them. Will she stand up for Ganga now? No...not at the cost of upsetting the peace.
Does that make her bad? No, it makes her very human. Also she has not seen Sanchi's face the way Anandi has seen her from close up. So it is reasonable for her to assume that Sanchi has matured.
But...
Anandi
Anandi is a different matter. Why she should be expected to maintain standards? Because she was shown to stand up for right even if it cost her. Also she is a social worker who constantly talks about the rights of women. She is also a victim of a marriage that was imposed on her. She and Jagya too suffered because of that marriage. She is also shown as the one who considers Jagya's family her own and talks about the importance of their happiness.
Anandi in some sense has become selfish. Even though she knows that Shiv married her because he was in love with her, she in some sense has bought Ira's theory that he did a favor to her by marrying her and Shiv's family did a favor by accepting her as their DIL. So these obligations and preservation of marriage has silenced her.
Jagya was right that she could have easily told Sumitra/Dadisa in private about Sanchi's suitability. But she kept quiet about her doubts and about what she knew about Sanchi. She knows very well how Jagya's family suffered because of unsuitable marriages. That now Jagya and his family were looking for peace. Yet she kept quiet. She could have told both families that she would keep quiet because she doesn't want to get in middle of this. Then Jagya would have made an independent decision rather than also including her as a part of decision making.
Now when she found about the bribe to the priest, she blasted the priest so much and yet let Sanchi off the hook. Everyone's beliefs are their own and Sanchi's views about muhurat are not wrong. But...it was not beliefs that caused Sanchi to bribe the guy and Anandi knows about it. She went on with vengeance against the priest (lecturing him and what not) despite him confessing that he did it for his family. Yet totally let Sanchi off the hook and was defending Sanchi to Jagya. On top of that, she never shared this bribe stuff with Shiv - a most understanding person. Of course, he would be angry after he knows that she hid everything from him.
Even when she knows that Ganga/Jagya loves each other and has found Sanchi's true colors, she is still defending her. That is unexcusable. It is ok to wait to tell Shiv the truth before the family, but it was not ok to emotionally manipulate Jagya into marrying Sanchi because she was obsessed over her. Then why was Gauri not ok for the family? At least she was a dedicated doctor. Even if Sanchi was a great girl, it was better to stop the wedding because it would still make three people unhappy - two in loveless marriage and one pining for the lost love. On top of that, she was making excuses for her silence and putting everything on Jagya.
So it is Anandi whose conduct is questionable as she lectures those whom she can, but backs down in front of the "influential" ones because that may impact her image in the house.
It is ok to show her like this. But it would be good if they show her repentence and an apology to both Shiv and Jagya. Also they need to show her disclosing the truth about Sanchi rather than letting take Jagya/Ganga all the blame. She was always good, but right now she has become corrupt because her personal interests are conflicting with her sense of right/wrong.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".