.Reshama. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Oke guys i had to make a post abut this..i felt really bad what happend to him..because it looks like he was only made to do work..can someone tell me what reward did he get when he killed Tarakasur and helped the South by killing the demons. In my eyes he should have the oppertunity to get the Indra's singhansan./place. Honeslty he deserved it. On top op that Indra didn't stop to humiliate or put him down. I cant understand why shiv and parvati where mum about this...
When he went around the world he indeed won the game..but shiv had other plans. Instead of him Ganesh got the reward.. although i have to confess Ganesh is clever but Karteye isnt a fool too.
The way they let him go is shamefull..it looked like they dont need him anymore..is it because they have Ganesh now..
Shiv let him go and parvati didnt thought at the moment as well..if the handled this first then Kartekeya woulndnt leave khailash.
Is/Was he only made to clean other messes, defend weaker creations and work like a senapati..but what about his reward..he deserved a lot then this...
I know Ganesh and Kartekeya have diffrent qualities.. He didnt got the lad dulaar pyaar from his parents like Ganesh..i can understand his pain..and the deserved much more..than his pain reward!!
Edited by .Reshama. - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

45

Views

4.6k

Users

14

Likes

59

Frequent Posters

hemavidz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
he neither got love of their parents like his siblings does nor the reward as warrior(pls dont tell me tat warriors wont fight for rewards)im really fedup of Parvati n Kartikeyas characterisation
whenevere kartikey was in trouble Parvati was the last person to know about it its getting really irritating with each passing episodes
Thanks for the post Reshu 🤗
Edited by hemaDaganKhian - 12 years ago
.Reshama. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: hemaDaganKhian

he neither got love of their parents like his siblings does nor the reward as warrior(pls dont tell me tat warriors wont fight for rewards)im really fedup of Parvati n Kartikeyas characterisation
whenevere kartikey was in trouble Parvati was the last person to know about it its getting really irritating with each passing episodes
Thanks for the post Reshu 🤗

Hema🤗 i understand what u feel..its really annoying now.it looks like he was only made to work but and wasnt allowed forany reward...Everybody works hard to get an reward and thats a fact..be in study(paper),work(gud job) and pooja/tapasya|(to get love from God or something u asked for).It looks like he is the black sheep in the family and i hate it. Shiv Parvati knew that this was a delicate situation and should handle it better..
jayvenk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
why did mahadev not stop karthikeya is what I am wondering. the cv's better have a good explanation for this.
Karthikeya is shown more human than god ?/Why??
Ganesh even before became sarvasresht is looked upon as God by et all. Why?
If ganesh thought about the universel [lighting the lamp etc]
DID karthikeya not kill tarku to save the world?/ Did he not clear the south of all the asurs??
Even in the race did he not show that he was not there just to win?
So on what basis did mahadev declare ganesh as the supreme?
sia221 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Agree with u...Reshama..
They have really messed up with Parvati and Kartikeya's character...


Kartikeya did win the competition..fair and square.. he even helped other Devtas during the race.. instead of just thinking of winning it... Isn't that considerate of him..??😕
Why shouldn't he be angry...sad..when he played by the rules..won the competition..still didn't get acknowledged for it...??😕


Not happy with the way the whole Pratham Pujya track went...?? They should have stuck with it being as a family affair..rather than a public competition..that messed it up further??



jayvenk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
it should have shown as competition for FRUIT OF KNOWLEDGE.,
I would have made more sense.
Here ganesh used his brains to win the race by going around his parents.
hemavidz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
in the name of diff presentation CVS making things more melodramatic most of the time im end up confusing whether it is a Mytho or Saas Bahu serial😕very much disappointed wit Kartikeya n Parvati's potrayal
hemavidz thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: jayvenk

it should have shown as competition for FRUIT OF KNOWLEDGE.,
I would have made more sense.
Here ganesh used his brains to win the race by going around his parents.


i really expected them to show tat Jay but c wat they gave us😔
Edited by hemaDaganKhian - 12 years ago
.Reshama. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: jayvenk

why did mahadev not stop karthikeya is what I am wondering. the cv's better have a good explanation for this.

I also toughtwhy 🤓..he had pain in his eyes but still let him go..he shouldt handle it better...

Karthikeya is shown more human than god ?/Why??
What crap are they showin us..this is really an insult!

Ganesh even before became sarvasresht is looked upon as God by et all. Why?
I also want to know this answer too. Wasnt Kartikeye special too??

If ganesh thought about the universel [lighting the lamp etc]DID karthikeya not kill tarku to save the world?/ He saved us from a notorious asur Did he not clear the south of all the asurs??
He sure deserved a reward for this.

Even in the race did he not show that he was not there just to win?
He autually won the race..but shiv had other plans and changed the rules.

So on what basis did mahadev declare ganesh as the supreme?
Please dont tell that Ganesh is clever..we know he is ..but Kartikeya isnt a dumm god ..he is clever too.

Dear🤗, U know if am honest i had these things in my mind but couldnt write it down..u know ma english isnt all perfect..Am so glad u did it..are the cv's messing a little up?? yes is Karthikeya only a social worker??He deserved sum status and reward too.
mnx12 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
I had read this story as a child, it makes more sense.
Ganesh was declared Pratham pujya by Shivji when his head was replaced by an Elephant. So he was actually pratham pujya. Kartikeya was not involved here.
This is the story from here

The universal parents, Shiva and Parvati, thought of marriage for their two sons, Ganesha and Subrahmanya, as they had attained youth-the right time for marriage. When their parents revealed the decision for them to marry, the two boys began quarreling.,

One said, "marry me first!"

"No," the other rejoined, "marry me first!"

To pacify them, Shiva and Parvati devised a plan, called them near, and spoke to them thus, "O good sons, we love both of you equally. To settle your quarrel, we have made a decision. Between the two of you, whoever returns here first after going around the entire Mother Earth shall be married first !"

On hearing these words, Lord Subrahmanya immediately set off on His peacock with great speed to go around the earth quickly and return earlier than Ganesha. To their wonderment, Lord Ganesha just stood near Lord Shiva and Shakti Parvati without making any preparations to leave. Instead, He requested that His divine parents occupy the two seats He provided and prayed to them to accept His worship service. Shiva and Shakti readily agreed to this and sat on those seats.

Lord Ganesha worshipped both of them with great devotion, circumambulated seven times and made obeisance to them seven times. As He completed His seventh salutation, Lord Subrahmanya arrived, completing His journey around the entire earth. Now Subrahmanya demanded that His marriage be celebrated first because He had gone around the earth and returned to them first, as per their command. Lord Ganesha never went around the earth at all.

At this point, Lord Ganesha said, "O Divine Mother, O Universal Father, the Vedas declare that whoever goes around or circumnavigates his parents obtains the fruit of bhu-pradakshina or tones circling around the entire earth. When this blessing is applicable even by going around earthly parents, how much more it should be when the circumnavigation is done to you, O Divine Parents. By going around you seven times, I have gone around not only the earth, but the whole universe! Therefore, celebrate my marriage without any delay."

On hearing Ganesha's intelligent words, Shiva and Parvati were pleased and at once decided to celebrate His marriage first. Prajapati Vishwaroopa's two beautiful daughters, one called Riddhi and the other called Siddhi, were selected to marry Lord Ganesha. The divine sculptor Vishwakarma made all the arrangements for the marriage by constructing a beautiful marriage hall. Lord Shiva and Parvati celebrated the marriage of Ganesha to Riddhi and Siddhi, who bore Him two beautiful sons named Labha and Kshema respectively.

Ganesha is an eternal brahmachari (celibate). All the gods are, but they "marry" sometimes so that we people on mundane earth will understand. Thus, Ganesha married two beautiful daughters of Brahma the Creator, and they are called "Riddhi" and "Siddhi." The illumined mind and attainment. The energies or powers of God are His wives. And out of these two wives, Ganesha had two children. One is called Kshema. Another is called Labha. Labha means profit, gain of the highest wealth. And Kshema means complete protection of that highest wealth.

Lord Subrahmanya, who silently observed all this, bade farewell to His parents and brother and went to the Krauncha Mountain near Lake Manasa in Kailasa Mountain. (In Skanda Puraana, the story of Subrahmanya is narrated, where it is explained that after the marriage of Ganesha, Subrahmanya also was married to two beautiful wives named Valli and Devasena.)

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".