Sanaya Irani in talks with 4 Lions TC Article - Page 3

Originally posted by: arti_17

ramya u shudnt hv brought Rati in dis topic...bt since evryone has dragged Rati n her show 4 no reason let me also comment on dis...thrs no point in comparing HD n Ipkknd...both d shows r poles apart...HD is a strong female-oriented show wid strong characterisation...whereas ipk was a pure romantic show...im glad Rati is nt doing dat type of show... bt has taken up a show like HD whr her acting skills r being explored n tested...its sad dat ppl r more interested in watching luv stories n nt realistic stuff hence d trps...bt its all personal choice...thrs no point bringing Rati here or demeaning her show in any way...

Everyone dragged Rati and her show here? Oh no...more like a RP fan had to 'demean'(as you put it) SI unnecessarily.Now you can't really blame us for answering back,can you?
Also since when does doing a bubbly role imply that your acting skills are not being tested...its funny you say this,because RP has done that kind of role too.Or is nupur that forgettable?😆

And there are many aspects about HD that aren't realistic either.Not even right...have you watched IPK?At all?
When khushi(the character SI played) gave her resignation letter to her boss WITHOUT trying to slap him or something...that IMO was more about feminism than Indira slapping a security guard when he was just doing his job.
At the same time I don't deny that IPK had many many many flaws too.And I don't even deny that HD and Indira touched my heart many times.I had tears in my eyes while watching the first episode of HD itself
Just because I like SI I am not going to 'demean' RP's acting and her show even when the show has some genuinely good scenes...but honestly I doubt you guys can do the same when it comes to SI.

BTW there was a time when sameer manhandled Indira in HER room,no?What exactly did she do then?I am genuinely asking.Did she act like a true feminist or like khushi(i.e. forgetting that it even happened)

Originally posted by: Ipepe

Everyone dragged Rati and her show here? Oh no...more like a RP fan had to 'demean'(as you put it) SI unnecessarily.Now you can't really blame us for answering back,can you?
Also since when does doing a bubbly role imply that your acting skills are not being tested...its funny you say this,because RP has done that kind of role too.Or is nupur that forgettable?😆

And there are many aspects about HD that aren't realistic either.Not even right...have you watched IPK?At all?
When khushi(the character SI played) gave her resignation letter to her boss WITHOUT trying to slap him or something...that IMO was more about feminism than Indira slapping a security guard when he was just doing his job.
At the same time I don't deny that IPK had many many many flaws too.And I don't even deny that HD and Indira touched my heart many times.I had tears in my eyes while watching the first episode of HD itself
Just because I like SI I am not going to 'demean' RP's acting and her show even when the show has some genuinely good scenes...but honestly I doubt you guys can do the same when it comes to SI.

BTW there was a time when sameer manhandled Indira in HER room,no?What exactly did she do then?I am genuinely asking.Did she act like a true feminist or like khushi(i.e. forgetting that it even happened)

Originally posted by: arti_17

dis post nvr abt comparison...evn ramya herself clarified dat she is nt evn comparing d 2...bt since u n others retaliated, we had 2 retaliate as well...i dnt evn want 2 go under d details of d 2 characters as i hv already mentioned dat both d characters r like poles apart...IMO i find Indira's character realistic n relatable...if u dnt dats ur choice...as i already said its all a personal choice as 2 who wants 2 watch wat...

plus u r no 1 2 question me abt who is forgettable or nt... any Rati fan can nvr forget Nupur...d history of bubbly characters on tv was started by nupur...

i nvr quoted u or evn uttered a word on SI or evn feminism...i just said dat ipk is a pure romantic show n im glad dat Rati is nt doing such kind of a show just like sum others said abt HD...evn khushi n nupur though bubbly characters r nt d same...evn mjht n ipk r different...n yes i havnt watched ipk at all nor i ll evr b able 2 watch it...

if u c d 1st page of dis topic, it was u who started comparing d 2 shows n d characters...ramya was saying something, bt u interpreted it in a completely different manner...

n regarding Indira's character n justification, u r always welcome at HD forum...we can discuss all dis there...😃

yeah ok I'll be honest,I have a hard time trusting RP's fans and their intentions,not that you guys would care, I know...just saying that when ramya says comparing or demeaning was NOT her intention its kinds hard to believe that.I have come across many RP fans who indirectly say many things and then when you quote them they just take their words back or deny saying anything bad...like in some other thread(when SI said something like popularity diminishes but talent remains forever) one of the RP fans indirectly said that may be this is true in SI's case but not others like RP...its like India's politicians and other religious babas,say all kinds of crap you want to and when questioned deny it.
May be that was not ramya's intention but many have had that intention in the past and continue to do so.As they say in hindi - doodh ka jala chaach bhi fuk fuk kar peeta hai.

And LMAO why am I "no one to ask whether nupur is forgettable or not?"...actually cut that.Why do I need to be someone to ask that?Its a forum,people ask,people discuss and mine was a simple question!Answer it if you can/want to...
And umm NO nupur is NOT the one who started the 'history of bubbly characters on Indian television'.One must not talk about history if he/she is unaware about it...like I know Muskaan chaddha(another bubbly character from the show dmg) made her entry on Indian TV before nupur did.But I won't say she is the one to start the history of bubbly characters,may be it was someone else.I am not that aware about Indian television and its history.

And when one has to say how strong,realistic or 'relatable' Indira as a character is then MJHT forum is the right place to say all this but when its about criticizing her actions then it should be discussed in the HD forum?Am I the only one who finds this funny?

Originally posted by: Ipepe

yeah ok I'll be honest,I have a hard time trusting RP's fans and their intentions,not that you guys would care, I know...just saying that when ramya says comparing or demeaning was NOT her intention its kinds hard to believe that.I have come across many RP fans who indirectly say many things and then when you quote them they just take their words back or deny saying anything bad...like in some other thread(when SI said something like popularity diminishes but talent remains forever) one of the RP fans indirectly said that may be this is true in SI's case but not others like RP...its like India's politicians and other religious babas,say all kinds of crap you want to and when questioned deny it.
May be that was not ramya's intention but many have had that intention in the past and continue to do so.As they say in hindi - doodh ka jala chaach bhi fuk fuk kar peeta hai.

And LMAO why am I "no one to ask whether nupur is forgettable or not?"...actually cut that.Why do I need to be someone to ask that?Its a forum,people ask,people discuss and mine was a simple question!Answer it if you can/want to...
And umm NO nupur is NOT the one who started the 'history of bubbly characters on Indian television'.One must not talk about history if he/she is unaware about it...like I know Muskaan chaddha(another bubbly character from the show dmg) made her entry on Indian TV before nupur did.But I won't say she is the one to start the history of bubbly characters,may be it was someone else.I am not that aware about Indian television and its history.

And when one has to say how strong,realistic or 'relatable' Indira as a character is then MJHT forum is the right place to say all this but when its about criticizing her actions then it should be discussed in the HD forum?Am I the only one who finds this funny?

God i genuinely thought you forgot that incident. ipepe ...its so strange that all those comments where i supported sanaya goes all unnoticed...recently even in is pyaar ko forum...i have supported her...and i feel mostly on this forum very well know that i am not against sanaya in any way...ok that's what i felt...simple...i din't like the way sanaya mentioned...that they are forgotten...i can't forget rati di till my last breadth...and its natural that we can have disagreements...i feel connected to rati di...i know if she will be there on television or not...she will rule my heart ...always ...but genuinely i dint wrote it for hurting others...i never wanted that...i remember how sorry was i for writing it...and eventually begged you to forgive me...but then...you are still with that comment...once again ...i am sorry for hurting you...please don't judge rati fan's intentions in that way...it is nothing like that...

regarding nupur who set the history - Surely she wasn't the first fun loving one...but she surely was a trend setter...before mjht ...it was ridhima who got popular...and her character was different...so yup she was the first bubbly character which touched heights of popularity . She has ruled . Regarding comparing the two...i feel both rati and sanaya had talent...that's the reason... they got shows after mjht...with a lead role...shows which run above one year...with those many guest appearances , dance performances...i am proud saying that both the actresses in mjht rocked...are ruling the industry...if you feel rati di isn't talented...than its your opinion . But that doesn't mean you will try to pull her down .

edited - one question ...i want to put...if i have all the rights to support sanaya.whenever i want ...don't i have any right to disagree with her ? And sorry to say to say...even you did wrote wrong about dhrashti. Remember ?