There were too many scenes which had zero logic, its difficult to name one.
For starters, the whole Sheetal-Aarav track was filled with illogical scenes. I did not enjoy watching even a single moment then. The track was useless. It in fact ruined ASR for me.
The Mrs India track was no better, full of inconsistencies.
As standalone scenes, I feel -
1) a major part of the Kidnap sequence - a hot-shot business tycoon getting kidnapped just like that, there was no explanation given as to what those guys told Arnav that he agreed to go with them.
Also, when ASR-Khushi met during the kidnap, after their almost consummation, ASR hits Khushi with a log to 'save' her. I just did not get that scene.
Then after he returns to RM, before entering the house there was a small talk between ASR-Khushi where he asked for proofs. Nothing came out of that scene. It wasn't mentioned again.
After this track everybody like forgot that a kidnap had ever happened. Nobody brought it up again. Nobody cared for ASR, especially Anjali.
Too many inconsistencies.
2) The DKS track. that was torture! Why did Anjali turn so evil suddenly from the sabse pyari Di?
3) Dadi track - how does she appear suddenly? According to her, arnav and Nani had pleaded with her many times to come back to RM. She never listened. But, just one request from 'Damaadji' and she complies?
4) The past - it was resolved so abruptly. All of a sudden, Arnav Singh Raizada becomes the all-too forgiving, perfect hero and forgets everything? Forgives Garima? What was the whole grand buildup during the remarriage for then? It just took him a few flashbacks, an accident, a howl - to forget all his past sorrows? Very illogical.
We missed out on a very powerful separation track due to this.
There are others, which you all have mentioned.
I feel that IPK went downhill when the kidnapping track was introduced. And it couldn't regain its glory again even after Barun returned.
Cricket
63