Right to expression of thought. a sad affair in IF - Page 14

Originally posted by: RickyBahl

@ darcy and medha

buddies i dont hve any issue with ur opinions cause i dont believe in thrusting my opinions on others

i nevr go and give moral lectures on others thoughts and go to their threads...similarly my stand will remain the same

barun is wrong ..

and i am not a crazy person that i am voicing to k eep him on the show.

iam telling just what is wrong in my eyes...and i will voice it ..doesnt matter it s my fav or not

Originally posted by: katman

Barun is wrong from your point of view, wrong compared to your standards, your likes and dislikes, your expectations, your beliefs etc, but not his. You are not Barun Sobti, you do not live his life, don't know how he thinks, feels, what are his priorities. He is not answerable to you or to any other of his fans. And to say that one wouldn't quit school because of health or family reasons...well.. then there's a news for you - school and real job are nothing alike. At work you don't have mid term breaks or holiday after every couple of months and 2-3 months hols in summer (depends what country), you can't skip work and pretend to be sick or simply not go whenever you feel like. Neither does it really affect anyone if you leave school (but it affects your own future), but it affects the family when one quits job.

No one can keep one actor responsible for closing down a show, these decisions are not made overnight and by one person. No matter what message SP shows on screen, it is them who say which shows channel runs and which they don't.

I think that if you open a topic in public forum to express your POV, you pretty much have to be ready for opinions that don't match yours . It's not fair to label them as moral lectures.

Originally posted by: katman

Barun is wrong from your point of view, wrong compared to your standards, your likes and dislikes, your expectations, your beliefs etc, but not his. You are not Barun Sobti, you do not live his life, don't know how he thinks, feels, what are his priorities. He is not answerable to you or to any other of his fans. And to say that one wouldn't quit school because of health or family reasons...well.. then there's a news for you - school and real job are nothing alike. At work you don't have mid term breaks or holiday after every couple of months and 2-3 months hols in summer (depends what country), you can't skip work and pretend to be sick or simply not go whenever you feel like. Neither does it really affect anyone if you leave school (but it affects your own future), but it affects the family when one quits job.

No one can keep one actor responsible for closing down a show, these decisions are not made overnight and by one person. No matter what message SP shows on screen, it is them who say which shows channel runs and which they don't.

I think that if you open a topic in public forum to express your POV, you pretty much have to be ready for opinions that don't match yours . It's not fair to label them as moral lectures.

Originally posted by: jusah

Ricky,
Very nice analysis!!

In one of Gul's interview when she was asked to say one thing about her actors , she had used the words like "superb actor", "very talented" etc., for some (like abhas, sanaya) but when asked about BS she paused and said " he is so unlike the character of ASR, but he has this desire "lets do it" , so he follows his directors cent percent" and that summarises his success story at IPKND,
good script and good direction for a stron acharacter like ASR.
One thing which has happened because of this entire last 1 month fiasco is

It has made IPK an epic love saga which got closed abruptly .
else
It would have died a antural death -- falling trps, no control over the story and more importantly no capability of post confession love story from PH , and steady resignation of the actors ...



BS saved this disaster from happening and made epic with all the fans always wondering what a sweet journey it was and what it could have been ...

Originally posted by: Archana89

Let me add one more thing..
There was a write up from Mr.Gautam Hegde during may-june..
He stated that IPK is a typical starone show and had to add family drama to suit SP.In that article,he had written about only actors appreciated for excellent episodes and CV's bashed for bad episodes..He had also stated that he was not against the actors and their success,..One thing that stood out was he said,"Infact Sanaya is a friend"...Nothing was mentioned about Barun..Ajeeb sa laga that he left Barun from calling a friend..!!Might not be an important thing..But still felt strange at that time..Now after all these drama,I feel that article was almost like a prophecy..!!

Originally posted by: Safi123

GH also wrote for MJHT sanaya previous show. GH and sanaya are friends from a long time. they are very close

Originally posted by: RickyBahl

guys, gals who believe in me ... thanks a lot

Opinions are not formed out of nowwhere they are formed by reasoning, observations,Informations. analysis .

Many ppl think iam a blind fan giving my 2 cents here😆. I find it useless to debate because..i cant be the Media manager of barun sobti and closing eyes and say its already night. What his poplarity he has or not evryone knows..No rocket science needed.

If someone is happy with his decision its oK... when 95 out of 100 are not happyy..there has to be something. From rajan shahi to cinevistaas to big writers like raghuvir shekhawat have expressed a sort of thumbs down to this decision because they know he will be back but ASR wont be back.

i never thrust my opinions...because i know what the ppl outside are reacting to...in real sense.

This post will also fade away with time But what wont fade away is the ultimate thing that a hugely sucessful show was put in national embarrasment by an actors for his filmi dreams.

I dont care if anybody agrees or not...Jisko jo samajhna tha woh already smajh chuka hai..No more Image saving tactics wont work.

some Ppl think i wish ill for him,but i know myself what i have prayed for him..something which is out of all these sucess and failures of life, away from materialistic world..something that wud bring serenity in his life. something very diffrent and spiritual.

How much u attain sucess. U might b at the top ..But if u dont have peace of mind and being on Top if u hv no one to share ur sucess also..then that sucess its useless.

Honestly his career becomes HIT or whatever it doesnt matter..we will move away. daily actors come and Go..not a big deal. Peole climb up-down the ladder of sucess..

His fans are not his fixed deposit.. things are so fragile...

IPKKND was such a huge show whose bad abrupt ending could be avoided if the actor wud have extended his support to the PH to work for the show. But Ok...all wills ee for themselves and this India Forums PR policies to change facts wont work.

I dont care now really...as i said its my Opinion and i stand by it

<font size="4">BARUN HAS TAKEN A VERY WRONG DECISION</font>