Karan,SLB,Ash's comments on Black & Rani - Page 4

i love ash.. but that does not degrading others like all nasty things all rani's fan does. i agree with sanjay ash has that aura, i think ash is directors actor, given a good director she does well in her role, check our her sanjay film's, choker bali raincoat, and forthcoming PROVOKED.

i agree with you guys, u like rani, but do respect others feeling and just dont say watever you feel about aishwarya...its really low level to talk about aishwarya's personal life about vivek, salman and abhishek.its there life, and i think abhishek is grown up and he knows what to do. if u go on making chaos over here, he is not going to change his decision whom he should marry and whom he should not.

so all behave little practical, and do respect others and dont talk nasty things generally her personal lives..it only shows how bad u can think of others .


though rani's fan say she is downto earth her fans dont take that quality and behave like her, and be down to earth and respect others.

rani is the best actress ever.

i dont know what u guys are talking about cause ash is a great actress, if she wasn't then why would she get movies like devdas and hddcs?? and now she has umrao jaan and dhoom coming out. she's a brilliant actress and she does different roles. she has the aura and the acting ability. 😛

Originally posted by: bollywoodcrazed

I didn't get that either, she got angry at Rani for accepting a role she wasn't able to do. Rani does not need permission from Ash to accept a role, Rani was struggling in the industry, and she was finally getting the break she deserved. Rani saw an opportunity, and took it. Ash is just jealous because Rani has proved her acting abilities and is now more popular than Ash. SLB was a jerk for saying Rani doesn't have the aura of a star, she definately does, she is beautiful, talented and very sweet. I have read responses about Ash on other forums, I was shocked to see what type of person she really is. I read that at one of the award functions, a fan came to meet Ash, she was in a wheelchair and was begging Ash for an autograph. Ash just looked at her and ignored her completely, that is cruel! There is also an article on the web about Ash being rude to an interviewer at this year Cannes Film Festival. Ash is too full of herself and is very rude and ungrateful! Rani has not let fame go to her head.

i heard about that wheel chair incident as well, i dont know if its true so won't commet on that

btw this cannes film festival, is it the one where SRK and Karan went as well?

Originally posted by: *vishal*

i love ash.. but that does not degrading others like all nasty things all rani's fan does. i agree with sanjay ash has that aura, i think ash is directors actor, given a good director she does well in her role, check our her sanjay film's, choker bali raincoat, and forthcoming PROVOKED.

i agree with you guys, u like rani, but do respect others feeling and just dont say watever you feel about aishwarya...its really low level to talk about aishwarya's personal life about vivek, salman and abhishek.its there life, and i think abhishek is grown up and he knows what to do. if u go on making chaos over here, he is not going to change his decision whom he should marry and whom he should not.

so all behave little practical, and do respect others and dont talk nasty things generally her personal lives..it only shows how bad u can think of others .


though rani's fan say she is downto earth her fans dont take that quality and behave like her, and be down to earth and respect others.

well i agree with you here that people should not say or refuse bad language, as far as Ash's or Abhi's personal life is concerned, everyone has their opinion and we all are here to discuss what we want to BUT within the limits and rules and regulations of India-Forums.

anyways people lets get back to topic and discuss Ash's and SLB's comments in KWK😃

Originally posted by: Hailey

I think SLB was right, Aish has an aura of a star and massive screen presence...Rani, despite her wonderful acting skills and gorgeous looks, lacks that aura...and of course SLB is a director...he has a broader and a much mature viewpoint for he has worked with many ppl and for many years...

and abt that whole Aish-Rani fight thing, I do agree with Aish that its been overblown, only because when she got kicked out of chalte chalte...Rani stepped in...and that was okay with her but what bothered her was that she and rani were the best of friends and Rani couldn't make one phone call letter her know that, "hey aish...is it okay with u..." I mean just a courtesy call...not actually asking for permission..

but I did see the pics of Black's premiere...and AIshwarywa was there...so there u have it...both of them are still in touch, they might not be as close as they used to be, but they still are very much cordial towards each other..

off hand I'd say..Aishwarya handled this question abt her and Rani very diplomatically whereas Rani in her KWK episode played the blame game...that was very immature of her..

o well...all is well with them..

COmpletely agree👏

Originally posted by: gul_fam

. she is in good terms with everybody in industry which is very uncommen thing in bollywood. .

😆 😆 😆 Meaning to say,she sucks up to everyone right😉

Originally posted by: navpun

No doubt Rani is a very good actress.....only she could have done justice to the role of Mitchelle in Black. She is also very pretty but again....when u look at her...she looks girl next door......but Ash looks very extra ordinary. I hate Ash but still I will be honest in saying tht Ash does have tht Star aura but no acting skills. But in Bollywood what is more imp??? Acting which Rani has....so who cared abt tht aura thing.

I would refute by saying that It took Rani Mukherjee,the all time great actress 7 whole years to deliver a single solo hit(Saathiya)...7 years,whereas it took Ash just 2 years to win awards left right and centre for HDDCS.....You might say she had a good director in SLB,but then SO did rani have good directors in Shaad Ali,Kunal Kohli(both working under Adi Chopra who wields the power),Yash Chopra,SLB etc...

She debuted in 1996,and her first solo hit was in 2002 december(saathiya)..Rani hanst delivered powerhouse performances with a C grade director,even she needed good directors

Thus you see,Even Rani was pathetic in movies where she didnt have good directors...After 2002,she was fortunate enough to get A list co-stars,and A list directors,and thus she unraveled the petals of her histrionics.......Compare the kind of Movies Rani and Ash have done,compare the kind of directors they worked with before sitting judgmental....😊😊

Originally posted by: glamourous

u tell me, ash has gained proper COmmerical success in just 3 movies. Taal, HDDCS and Devdas. She acted superb in Choker Baali but other than tht, she is no where close to Rani when it comes to the competition in Bollywood.

Well,Agreed Ash was superb only in the abovemntioned movies which incidentally had good directors....[

But what about RAni...She too was superb only in certain movies like Saathiya,Chalte Chalte,Hum tum,Veer Zaara,Black and Bunty(perhaps)..But you're forgetting that RAni was fortunate to having got to work with A list directors....4 out of the 6 abovementioned movies were under the YAsh Chopra Banner,and most of YRF movies are sureshot hits...

Ash and RAni,both have worked with mediocre directors too,and both havent been all that great...Rani was pathetic in RAja ki aayegi baarat,bas itna sa khwab hai,chori chori,calcutta mail,Pyaar deewana hota hai,chalo ishq ladaye,hadh kar di aapne,bicchhoo,kahin pyaar na ho jaaye,baadal,naayak etc.....9 flops which all rani fans conviniently forget about....😛

It took Rani 7 years,and the chopra connection to get her first solo hit....Ash was as good as rani in movies like devdas,chokker bali,raincoat,HDDCS,Taal etc.....

Originally posted by: scorpion134

in bollywood right now
Rani's successful and all her films worked not only few with a specific Director but if u check out Ash's hit films then only those worked which SLB had directed so this proves that Ash is not that good actress as compared to Rani

hehehehehehehehehehe😆....Which movie of Rani's ,which wasnt produced by Aditya Chopra/SLB/Had SRK has worked...May I remind you about Raja Ki Aayegi Baarat,,Hello Brother,Baadal,Hadh KAr DI Aapne,Bichcho,Kahin Pyaar na ho jaaye,chori chori chupke chupke,BAs itna sa khwab hai,naayak,Pyaar deewana hota hai,chalo ishq ladaye,calcutta mail,chori chori etc....Yeah right,All these movies were super hits😆

Originally posted by: scorpion

also i dont get 1 thing y should have Rani given a call to Ash wen she signed up Chalte Chalte

..

basic courtsey..Rani and Ash were very close,and When SRk wanted to cast another heroine,rani voluntarily proffered to do the role,and Ash was replaced...

Now being Ash's friend,it becomes RAni's basic courtsey to call her up and tell her...Imagine your friend taking your place,and your getting to know that from a third person..Ash had every right to be offended,RAni just cashed in on Ash's predicament with Salman,and didnt have the courtsey to tell Ash about the latest development....With friends like these,who needs enemies

Originally posted by: scorpion

.she didnt ask Kareena if she can do it n i think Preity and Rani r both very professional and that is wat is required to be a star in Bollywood

Kareena and priety arent friends,so it doesnt matter..and KHNH was a different story alltogether..Kareena refused to do the role,whereas here Ash was thrown out....In KHNH,it was kareena's call not to do the movie,thus is it obvious that she would be replaced and she would have known it the day she refused...But here Ash was signed,and she had even started shooting,shot some scenes,when SRK threw her out,and replaced her with RAni....Now all this,without Ash's knowledge....thus it looked as though Ash was fooled by everyone,including someone who was supposed to be her friend..if this explains how the Chalte Chalte case cannot be compared to the KHNH situation....