Karan,SLB,Ash's comments on Black & Rani - Page 3

WOW!! i agree with alot of you...

AISH only has the AURA... but NO ACTING SKILLS!!

RANI is an amazing actress.. and i think she is gorgeous..

i prefer the warm friendly rani .. rather than the arrogant (too much aura) aish..

I DONT LIKE AISH!!! i hope ABHI never marries her..

him and rani all the way!!

wow this topic has been open since march and im replying in may but oh well. lets see the first thing that was wrong was that SLB criticized Rani on a show that was being watch by millions. he said taht the actress he picked to do the acting of a blind and deaf michelle doesnt have the aura to b a star. well the thing is Rani's best acting ever was in taht film i saw how difficult it can b to act as a blind and deaf girl. the thing with SLB is if he wanted someone with aura in his films why didnt he pick Ash to do the film? well Rani is much better actress then Ash. somehow i dislike Ash i think she is too arrogant. i dont like the way she talks and the way she acts like she is supirior to others. she acts as if she the queen. i donno wats wrong with people who think that Ash is beautiful she is preety but beautiful is Susmita Sen. she is the most gorgeous woman in india rihgt now. she is really nice looking and also her acting in some movies are good as well.

All is in all Ash is nothing compared to otehr bollywood and hollywood stars. she just has the looks but she doesnt know that looks arent the only thing for a great carrier in acting.

I LIKE ASH BUT SHE AIN'T DAT PRETTY DRE'S PRETIER GRLS DEN HER SHE'S TURNING INTO A OLD BUDDY NOW I THINK SNEHAL ULLAL'S MORE PRETTIER AND A YOUNGER VERSION OF ASH WAT DO U GUYS THINK???

Originally posted by: Jas_ishq

I very much hate ash so much. I think it was a little rude of SLB when he said what he said about rani on the show. It's not very smart to diss the star of your movie, seeing that she was the one to make it one of the top ten in Time's magazine!

Also ash is just trying to hard in films. Like she was okay in bollywood, but she should have waited to be on the very top to do hollywood movies. At let me tell you she wasn't on top! And seeing that she crashed and burned in hollywood, she's coming back to bollywood? Also all of the hollwood movies, she is doing are indian based!! Like seriously if she wan't to get known, get out of that genre!!! If she wants to get really known, she should do a deepa mehta, look how it helped john's career!

She isn't even the most beautiful, in india's eyes. The last indian countdown for the hotest female in india was Bipasha (with john being the hottest male!)

Rani is surprising everyone right know, and shes beating ash out of the water!! With pyrianka coming in second, and bipasha in third! Ash has a long way to go to be that "star" she thinks she is!~

I agree!! It seems more people are obsessed over Ash's beauty than her actual acting abilities, her fans easily jump to the conclusion that people are just jealous of her. There is nothing to be jealous about, Ash is not the only beauty in Bollywood, there are plenty of actresses just as beautiful as Ash. She is an okay actress, but she could have never pulled off the role Rani did in Black. SLB should have never talked about Rani like that, Rani and Amitabh made Black a success with their mindblowing performances. SLB was so wrong to say Rani doesn't have the aura of a star, she does! She is beautiful, talented, and is a warm loving person.

Ash i nowhere near Rani's status...she is number 1 in bollywood now n Ash is 👎🏼 in bollywood right now
Rani's successful and all her films worked not only few with a specific Director but if u check out Ash's hit films then only those worked which SLB had directed so this proves that Ash is not that good actress as compared to Rani
i think SLB should have been more mature and shldnt have said that Rani doenst have the "Aura of a Star"
i think Rani has the "Aura of a Super Star"
also i dont get 1 thing y should have Rani given a call to Ash wen she signed up Chalte Chalte...its film industry n ppl in this faternity dont wait 4 ppl to accept a film they have a lot more ppl to offer the same role...and Ash shouldnt have made a big issue of it that Rani did a film which she had refused to do...even KHNH Kareena refused so Preity did the film..she didnt ask Kareena if she can do it n i think Preity and Rani r both very professional and that is wat is required to be a star in Bollywood

1. doy ou agree with wat SLB said that Rani hasnt got the aura of a star and Ashwariya has. and what do you think abotu the "Problem" between Rani and Ash? i totaly disagree wid him..rani to me is an even bigger star dan aish..jus cause aish is pretty and glamouras dusnt mean she is has da star "aura" and rani dusnt...i find rani a wayy better actress dan aish....aish is too overrated and dat too onli cause of her beauty...as 4 da rani-aish prob i dont realli noe wat happened but frm wat i do noe..i jus think aish was being too..umm...ya..

2. Do you think Ash denied that whole matter in the conversation or she's still saying it happened?ya she did...i dont think she said wat she actualli wanted to..was jus tryin b umm "proffessional" but u cud tell she felt wayy more bout dis whole issue...

I dont think ash has the aura or the acting ability. She is pretty but not that extrodinary. Too me she doesnt even look indian. Does she haven any awards? or been recognized for an outstanding role that she has portrayed?

Rani by far is the best in the industry at this point. She's got great work ethic and seems to be a down to earth woman. I wish her more sucesses.

Originally posted by: scorpion134

Ash i nowhere near Rani's status...she is number 1 in bollywood now n Ash is 👎🏼 in bollywood right now
Rani's successful and all her films worked not only few with a specific Director but if u check out Ash's hit films then only those worked which SLB had directed so this proves that Ash is not that good actress as compared to Rani
i think SLB should have been more mature and shldnt have said that Rani doenst have the "Aura of a Star"
i think Rani has the "Aura of a Super Star"
also i dont get 1 thing y should have Rani given a call to Ash wen she signed up Chalte Chalte...its film industry n ppl in this faternity dont wait 4 ppl to accept a film they have a lot more ppl to offer the same role...and Ash shouldnt have made a big issue of it that Rani did a film which she had refused to do...even KHNH Kareena refused so Preity did the film..she didnt ask Kareena if she can do it n i think Preity and Rani r both very professional and that is wat is required to be a star in Bollywood

I didn't get that either, she got angry at Rani for accepting a role she wasn't able to do. Rani does not need permission from Ash to accept a role, Rani was struggling in the industry, and she was finally getting the break she deserved. Rani saw an opportunity, and took it. Ash is just jealous because Rani has proved her acting abilities and is now more popular than Ash. SLB was a jerk for saying Rani doesn't have the aura of a star, she definately does, she is beautiful, talented and very sweet. I have read responses about Ash on other forums, I was shocked to see what type of person she really is. I read that at one of the award functions, a fan came to meet Ash, she was in a wheelchair and was begging Ash for an autograph. Ash just looked at her and ignored her completely, that is cruel! There is also an article on the web about Ash being rude to an interviewer at this year Cannes Film Festival. Ash is too full of herself and is very rude and ungrateful! Rani has not let fame go to her head.

i think aish is very pretty, and she's a great actress too! rani doesn't match aish in looks but shes a good actress too, i just happen to like aish more. Sometimes it doesn't just matter if a film is hit, the film can be a flop but the actors can be very good in a film, so i think aish has jsut had some bad luck but shes a fabulous actor

Rani is an extremly talented and a gr8 actress,i really like her very much.Ash is good aswell but nothing like Rani.Rani is the queen of bollywood.