In defence of sanchi - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

58

Views

4.7k

Users

16

Likes

251

Frequent Posters

mansimat thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#51
"But criticizing a character because you don't see their point is not fair, don't you agree?"

This can be applied to all your criticism of Anandi & here Shiv too.

If I remember correctly, Anandi was criticized for her sweet response to Sanchi.- she cant stand up for herself, she is too docile, she doesn't have self respect, etc. Now suddenly she has become Mature? In this argument, I think this is your first appreciation of Anandi, congrats πŸ˜†

On your arguement - Well it has never been shown that Shiv has agreed to that Sanchi will choose his bride. Sanchi just sang about it herself, I want someone like this for my bhabhi, etc.
She is an adult woman of over 18 years, not a 5 year old kid who can't comprehend that her brother has fallen in love. He didn't tell her probably bcoz it didn't occur to him that its so important to tell her first. That again points out that he was never in agreement that she would choose his bride, if he was, he would have considered it important & called her.
And she was okay with Ashima. So what's exactly left of her point? That her ego wasn't assuaged?

As for how exactly he dealt with Sanchi, well a lot of people here have given credible argument & I agree & have nothing to add.


Originally posted by: Shinya


Dearie, I like your posts, they are very humorous. But criticizing a character because you don't see their point is not fair, don't you agree?πŸ˜†

Why in the first place shiv gave her the right to choose his bride?
Second point, why didn't he tell her that he chose his own bride? It was only after the sagai was fixed that her piece-of-old-furniture kind of mother (as some member called her) told her over the phone. πŸ˜†
I think it was unfair to the teenager, if you understand their psychology.

Now we are not emphasizing here that shiv should break the rishta for the sake of his childish sister. The issue was how he dealt with the whole situation. See, how calmly anandi had behaved. That is called maturity.

Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: YashpalDhavan


Okay, chalo critics. Always fair. But you missed the previous sentence

"Some one please teach me logic, I am so confused"

Critics also need to have logic or no?


I have replied to Ankit111's post. I hope you will be able to see some logic in that or no?
πŸ˜†πŸ˜†
mansimat thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#53
Couldn't agree more that Shiv's treatment was the most effective, not at all ruthless. This is a great answer to anyone who asks about Shiv's "handling" of the situation.

QUOTE=Crunchie]Aap mistaken hain Ela ji, koi ruthlessness nahi thi.

See first Sanchi said stupidly that he being her role model, she will also marry divorcee. Then, CM shouted at her to shut up. Shiv actually told her to LET her speak. Was he ruthless? Then he said I am good with you marrying a divorcee, provided, he is fit for you & free from his past.
Then he takes hold of her shoulder and says see If you love me, you must understand that when you insult Anandi, you are hurting me too. He is trying to make her understand, through the power of love. Finally he says, see I don't want such behaviour, tomorrow is haldi ceremony. If you are part of it, this behavior is not tolerated. And just asked if he was clear.

He was open in communication & firm, assertive. Standing up for his would-be wife. Which is what he should do. He did it very well with as little hurt as possible. But hurt as a by-product was unavoidable, jo Sanchi ko hui. And haan Sanchi is not 10 year old kid who can't even be scolded lil bit. Yaar she is in college, so over 18, I am assuming. An adult who talks trash about divorcees? Cmon!

Aapko kahan dikhi ruthlessness? And if I remember correctly, members were saying where is the firm, no-nonsense, assertive IAS man, Shiv gone? Arre he is back! πŸ‘ ⭐️



Originally posted by: aparnauma


Ela I know you are not against his decision to select his bride😊

He tried to reason with her she did not listen so he had to egt tough with her.After all she is still teenager(though she doesn't look like one🀣) so hhandled her exactly the way parents handle children who are throwing a tantrum and told her she can not have her ways all the time.
Where does the ruthlessness come from?
Sometimes even teenagers need to be handled in a tough manner if the insist on behaving like a year old.

Alpha_Aakash thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#54
Saanchi is worse than Gauri..i ll wanna give advice to Saanchi .."PLease donot Judge a person bye his/her outer apperance ...U need to check the persons heart also..if u have oneπŸ˜ƒ"
nobodyatnotime thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: elasingh

But Sanchi took it seriously that Shiv will marry girl of her choice.She is a teenager.

Mind you Aparna we are not against Shiv's decision to select his bride but the way he treated Sanchi.
He was very ruthless to his teenage sister . Its also obvious that She loves him very much and is deeply hurt by his behaviour.


Sometimes when kids behave like brats, it's time for harsh rebukes. What Shiv did was 100% correct and the rest of the family should have done that before. Being a teenager doesn't excuse her off the behaviour she has been exhibiting in public and private.
While she says her brother doesn't care for her likes and dislikes, it is important that someone tells her that she has shown the least regard for her brother's happiness.
ankit111 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: Shinya


Dearie, I like your posts, they are very humorous. But criticizing a character because you don't see their point is not fair, don't you agree?πŸ˜†

Why in the first place shiv gave her the right to choose his bride?
Second point, why didn't he tell her that he chose his own bride? It was only after the sagai was fixed that her piece-of-old-furniture kind of mother (as some member called her) told her over the phone. πŸ˜†
I think it was unfair to the teenager, if you understand their psychology.

Now we are not emphasizing here that shiv should break the rishta for the sake of his childish sister. The issue was how he dealt with the whole situation. See, how calmly anandi had behaved. That is called maturity.

thanx dear for liking my post, but i hv only two eyes and five senses and cant she or assume wht hs not been shownπŸ˜‰ ur whole logic is based on assumption tht SHIV HS GIVEN SANCHI SOLE RIT TO CHOOSE HER BHABHI, which hs never been shown in normal telecast BV. So i cant based my criticism on hypothetical presumptionπŸ˜† Suchi hs cleared this in her post and want to add only tht Sanchi on the basis WHTEVER HS BEEN SHOWN, tht sanchi was bringing a lot of her friends, photos to CHOOSE, which only show tht she was given only rit to GIVE HER SUGGETIONS AND NOT TO DECIDE. final decision must be ShivπŸ˜† u sometime talk abt AGREEMENT and some time MUTUAL UNDERSTANDING, two very different things. If it was mutual understanding thn there is no sense of discussion, as sanchi is no where showing mutual understanding, so there is no defence for herπŸ˜† if it was Agreement, thn may be i missed some episodes, which i doubtπŸ˜‰ as concern to the teenager psychology, i think i didnt jumped from childhood to adulthood, whithout being teenagerπŸ˜† but never been or seen such stupid things.
As concern to the maturity of handling the situation, its very subjective things. Today u r saying Anandi dealt the situation more mature way, but for the same there were several threads to prove her doormatπŸ˜† For me Shiv behavior was perfect combination of strictness and persuasive. He first tried to convince her and whn it didnt work thn he showed tht she is crossing the limit and she cant dictate. As i know teenager PSYCHOLOGY, sometime they r needed to be told firmly and strictly, otherwise they will draw wrong conclusion, which lead to turn thm real brat. So for me Shiv was perfect and very very mature in tht situationπŸ‘
Edited by ankit111 - 12 years ago
Yash.Pal thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#57
[
Now we are not emphasizing here that shiv should break the rishta for the sake of his childish sister. The issue was how he dealt with the whole situation. See, how calmly anandi had behaved. That is called maturity.


Shinya,

I went out for 2 hours and came back to see a statement from you

"See, how calmly Anandi had behaved. That is called maturity."

What happened friend, amazing statement from you. πŸ˜†πŸ˜†πŸ˜† May be you are wearing my glasses after all. πŸ˜‰ Well done, change happens in small steps, but it happens ! Someone said it or should have said at any rate. πŸ˜‰

Take care in the cold.
Edited by YashpalDhavan - 12 years ago
Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: YashpalDhavan

[

Now we are not emphasizing here that shiv should break the rishta for the sake of his childish sister. The issue was how he dealt with the whole situation. See, how calmly anandi had behaved. That is called maturity.


Shinya,

I went out for 2 hours and came back to see a statement from you

"See, how calmly Anandi had behaved. That is called maturity."

What happened friend, amazing statement from you. πŸ˜†πŸ˜†πŸ˜† May be you are wearing my glasses after all. πŸ˜‰ Well done, change happens in small steps, but it happens ! Someone said it or should have said at any rate. πŸ˜‰

Take care in the cold.
NO, my dear friend, I am wearing my own glasses.πŸ˜†

If I wear your glasses I will not be able to do justice to those characters who need justice.πŸ˜†πŸ˜†

And let me tell you one thing, I am very generous in giving praises as well as criticism. πŸ˜†
Yash.Pal thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: Shinya


Shinya,

I went out for 2 hours and came back to see a statement from you

"See, how calmly Anandi had behaved. That is called maturity."

What happened friend, amazing statement from you. πŸ˜†πŸ˜†πŸ˜† May be you are wearing my glasses after all. πŸ˜‰ Well done, change happens in small steps, but it happens ! Someone said it or should have said at any rate. πŸ˜‰

Take care in the cold.

NO, my dear friend, I am wearing my own glasses.πŸ˜†

If I wear your glasses I will not be able to do justice to those characters who need justice.πŸ˜†πŸ˜†

And let me tell you one thing, I am very generous in giving praises as well as criticism. πŸ˜†

Suddenly a line came back to me from my Bible classes "The Lord be praised ... . Amen"

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".