question

hey could someone tell me what page in hbp talks about hagrid overhearing dumbledore and snape fighting?

Originally posted by: honey1184

so do u think in that arguement, dumbledore was ordering snape to kill him???

Originally posted by: *Rashmi*

Yup! I think Dumbledore was ordering Snape to kill him. I mean, after ALL this trust Dumbledore placed in Snape, he MUST have a reason... therefore, I think Snape is NOT evil... you know.

I feel that way too. Dumbledore never specifically said (right before Snape killed him) "how could you do this" or "I trusted you all this time, and you let me down" etc. There must be something about Snape that Dumbledore trusted in him, and I won't hate Snape until I know what that is.

Maybe Snape is just acting this way now to make Voldemort think that he's on his side, and by the end of the 7th book, he'll explain the truth. Until we hear him actually tell Harry that he betrayed Dumbledore, I think we have something to look forward to...JK Rowling might surprise us all..

(Btw, I just finished reading the 6th book like an hour ago, I'm so excited..yet so disappointed about the ending 😭)

well Maybe Dimbledore told him to kill him, but he has a reason of course,

or he should atleast.

Cuz Idon't think Snape is evil 😊

I'm so looking forward 2 read the book...😉

Cheers,