Jagya- an antihero?

stuti.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1

Lately he is rattling more than his usual wont. So how is he trading? As always??...Some thoughts...

So Mr. Jagat, how dare you thrash yourself after a betrayal? What new enterprise of selfishness is guiding you on? Can't you stay loyal to your own choice? Were not you shouting hoarse- you didn't love Anandi? That she was a misfit bother beset on you through an evil custom only? That you found true love of his life in Gauri. Or that, you truly wish his 'childhood friend' a well suited move on?...

Lately, on getting that jolting discolour of his pretty picture of new wife, what were his thoughts? That he had greatly abused his long time companion (A). That he deeply regretted his folly. That she was always a heart of gold and he OWES her a prostrate apology. And how he is showed going about it? Instead of a sensitivity that must follow such 'jolt', all of sudden he has charges/demands as a right! Refused. And now he is on revenge vendetta! Wait, remorse surfaces again. Now 'return' agenda! Oh, wasn't he always selfish? But arre, what is this? One moment penitent, one moment 'family only-not YOU', other moment hatred, scheming, revenge. Now again remorse/ love/ return?! Head is spinning.

As a narration, he is meandering too wildly to ascribe a coherence of fictional writing. The writer is trying to sell a base defective write up. For purchase was made long before they started tossing him as per their 'shock value' whims post 'message' requirements. Boy was bright and spoilt, but not beyond repair. He was sensitive to injustice meted to Anandi and tried to face the unjust as well as a powerless child can. He was indelibly bonded with a peer that fate has thrown them together through a foul custom. The bonds grew intact in adulthood. But then 'message' imperative demanded he be showed cheaply 'upgrading' his avowed affections! Loathsome and disgusting but plausible...But in afterwards, why such incorrigibility- implausible under the influence of a shocking 'realization'? Selfishness cannot explain this later inconsistency.

Now before I might be trounced for such blasphemous 'support', let me clear this. I despise this character post adulthood, for his obnoxious ill usage of his primary relations, his abundant swagger and betrayal to his loyal ally in total. He no longer deserves her. The abuses were enough to keep him at bay. In fact, a fitting reversal was the realization of the 'loss'. A lifelong regret is a poetic punishment- the parable of 'a selfish betrayal well punished in a permanent loss'.

BUT why this 'despise' can not accommodate a pity, if he really realize? Or why can't writers make him 'really realize'? Was he antagonist always? But I thought an evil custom in general and orthodox grandma in particular (pre reform) were the antagonists. Was he less of a victim of these tossing- a part of protagonists- only because he was a male child? Why should he not be given even a 'losing' redemption? Only to make an 'easy' way for new pair? I wish the new pair all the best. But also wish, their 'success' premium is not an avoidable vilification of a foolish loser...Almost a sure thing, just as writer will show him scheming more obnoxiously , sinking deeper...as in a soap!
Edited by stutishah - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

1.1k

Users

2

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

stuti.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
As wrongly surmised sometimes, such reflections are not aimed as 'Jagy- support'...a peeve at writer's illogical handling of the characters- his or hers...
adi2512 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
@stutishah.,
I very well u/stand your POV...but yes., this is a SOAP...and needs DRAMA...
If J realises and redempts so fast...don't U think that will be the almost end of it...šŸ˜†šŸ˜†
H/ever what appeals me most in this one & only soap., that I watch is the way they are depicting the sincerity and purity of LOVE between AnSh.
I do not think., I have found this manner of depicting any love story in a soap till now...
So., for that one and only one reason...I'am ready to o/look the writers follies reg the depiction of J as well as their illogical bloopers they come up with very often ...
I hope they keep up this spirit of potraying AnSh post their wedding too...which may actually aid in J's 'real' realization.
stuti.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
adi2514
Thanks for your kind assessment. For I am sailing against the 'mood', am I not?!😲
And soap it indeed is...with drama its staple. But this one, amidst scores of its genre replete with 'drama' of all kinds, is claiming a difference. So when it starts mimicking those others, some rant...

Coming to the 'irritant', look at the mass inconsistency, it is throwing in the present stance of so many characters. Was it justified? Not 'drama'. It's cost? Too much imbalance all around. Is it necessary? Why can't other two progress on their own? Or on other trials, if at all required towards drama, with out involving an embarrassing ex? That crutch which writers are seemingly taking in form of a suddenly 'covetous', evil Jagya? The new blossom too is somewhat tainted in its freshness- the contention.
In the end, some apology, for I did not intend a 'spanner' in the prevailing mood here.😳

adi2512 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
@stutishah.,
The writers are trying to bring an analogy to The MahaBharata in the present track...
Anjana & myself have made a thread on this...do look at it...if u are interested...
Actually., off late I'am quite impressed in the way show is bringing out this analogy...
you may feel better on the progress...after knowing this...
Infact...this is what is keeping me hooked to the show right now...apart from the depth of AnSh love story ofcourse...😃
stuti.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Thanks adi. I should. Anjana is always a rational to read.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".