aa07 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
I know this forum is about II6...but have to express these thoughts of II6 based on the past history

I was thinking II6 is no match for past seasons like II5 which got us Sreeram. Today mng, just for curiosity, I went back on you tube to see the past 4 seasons before II5 which I had never seen. I was really impressed with Abhijeet Sawant and even Sourabhee...Prashant Tamang was iffy for me...but I was simply blown away out of the water when I saw Karunya's videos.

Man...what was that!!!!!!...If that guy couldn't win Idol, then there is no meaning to this show...What didnt he do? And then seeing Sreeram in II5...was like Wow...what would have happened if these two faced off against each other in a finale...That would be one for the ages!!!!!!!! What do they put in the water in Hyderabad?

And then to come back to II6...what has this show come down to? This level now? I know you can't get a singer like Sreeram or Karunya every season but where did the judges go so horribly wrong this season? Can anyone in the top 4 in II6 hold a candle to either Karunya or Sreeram or even Sourabhee? After all we have now the supposed cream of II6? Poorvi in top 4? What does one say?
I was miffed when they sent Juhi Rai and Rajni Bala out in the second round and had a bad feeling from then on but didn't expect such a pathetic season at all. I think Ritika said it best last night...the judges didnt know what hit them and Anu Malik had to offer some lame limpish comment to save face...

Frankly this is it ...to borrow a line from Remo. Lost all interest to watch the remaining 4 epi's,,,,,who cares who wins now? This season has to be the biggest farce...
Edited by aa07 - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

2.6k

Users

7

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

..ashu thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Refuse collectors discovered hidden detritus.
Edited by ..ashu - 13 years ago
..ashu thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
TOP MOST DETRITUS IS POORVI.
..AnushaGeet.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
Brilliantly said..!!! 👏


Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: aa07

I know this forum is about II6...but have to express these thoughts of II6 based on the past history

I was thinking II6 is no match for past seasons like II5 which got us Sreeram. Today mng, just for curiosity, I went back on you tube to see the past 4 seasons before II5 which I had never seen. I was really impressed with Abhijeet Sawant and even Sourabhee...Prashant Tamang was iffy for me...but I was simply blown away out of the water when I saw Karunya's videos.

Man...what was that!!!!!!...If that guy couldn't win Idol, then there is no meaning to this show...What didnt he do? And then seeing Sreeram in II5...was like Wow...what would have happened if these two faced off against each other in a finale...That would be one for the ages!!!!!!!! What do they put in the water in Hyderabad?

And then to come back to II6...what has this show come down to? This level now? I know you can't get a singer like Sreeram or Karunya every season but where did the judges go so horribly wrong this season? Can anyone in the top 4 in II6 hold a candle to either Karunya or Sreeram or even Sourabhee? After all we have now the supposed cream of II6? Poorvi in top 4? What does one say?
I was miffed when they sent Juhi Rai and Rajni Bala out in the second round and had a bad feeling from then on but didn't expect such a pathetic season at all. I think Ritika said it best last night...the judges didnt know what hit them and Anu Malik had to offer some lame limpish comment to save face...

Frankly this is it ...to borrow a line from Remo. Lost all interest to watch the remaining 4 epi's,,,,,who cares who wins now? This season has to be the biggest farce...

I had started watching from season 3 so had no idea about the prev seasons. I had heard some of Abhijeet S in Jo Jeeta Wohi Superstar and thought he was pretty good. But after reading this thread, i decided to investigate Karunya. Wowww! 😲 😲 He's so talented!I had read his name on forums before but hadn't checked him out. He is such a great singer. I feel Sreeram has more nuance in his voice and is more polished than Karunya but it's so sad Karunya didn't win. 😔 Does anyone know what he's up to these days (career wise?) 😊
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
My 2 telugu biddas have been the highlights of Indian idol..
Karunya from season 2 who did not win & lost to "The wonna bee Uditji" 😆
Thank god Sreeram from Season 5 won..
Yes Abhijit S was good and has kept improving over the time..
aa07 I agree with your post..
Pls do go back and watch all Karunya's II videos and you will love them..
Edited by Dabulls23 - 13 years ago
Blossom5 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

My 2 telugu biddas have been the highlights of Indian idol..

Karunya from season 2 who did not win & lost to "The wonna bee Uditji" 😆
Thank god Sreeram from Season 5 won..
Yes Abhijit S was good and has kept improving over the time..
aa07 I agree with your post..
Pls do go back and watch all Karunya's II videos and you will love them..

Discovering the wonder that is Karunya made my day today. 😃 Although, the more i listen to his singing, the sadder i get that he didn't win. Truthfully though, winning doesn't guarantee much for his future but it would have been great for him to become Indian Idol2. Bless him, what a gem!
Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: LuckyJade

Discovering the wonder that is Karunya made my day today. 😃 Although, the more i listen to his singing, the sadder i get that he didn't win. Truthfully though, winning doesn't guarantee much for his future but it would have been great for him to become Indian Idol2. Bless him, what a gem!

Yep it was sad to see Hemu than Karu not winning although being such a good trained singers due to channel and politics..😡
I am so glad you listened to some of his songs...I am listening to his songs while watching Olympic closing ceremony..These kids Hemachandra, Karunya, Sreeram have given us some superb renderings and performances..
One of my favs of Karunya "are jaare hatt natkhat" has been taken off YT 😭
Shayu. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
@TM..excellent post 👏
Padmajaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: aa07

I know this forum is about II6...but have to express these thoughts of II6 based on the past history

I was thinking II6 is no match for past seasons like II5 which got us Sreeram. Today mng, just for curiosity, I went back on you tube to see the past 4 seasons before II5 which I had never seen. I was really impressed with Abhijeet Sawant and even Sourabhee...Prashant Tamang was iffy for me...but I was simply blown away out of the water when I saw Karunya's videos.

Man...what was that!!!!!!...If that guy couldn't win Idol, then there is no meaning to this show...What didnt he do? And then seeing Sreeram in II5...was like Wow...what would have happened if these two faced off against each other in a finale...That would be one for the ages!!!!!!!! What do they put in the water in Hyderabad?

And then to come back to II6...what has this show come down to? This level now? I know you can't get a singer like Sreeram or Karunya every season but where did the judges go so horribly wrong this season? Can anyone in the top 4 in II6 hold a candle to either Karunya or Sreeram or even Sourabhee? After all we have now the supposed cream of II6? Poorvi in top 4? What does one say?
I was miffed when they sent Juhi Rai and Rajni Bala out in the second round and had a bad feeling from then on but didn't expect such a pathetic season at all. I think Ritika said it best last night...the judges didnt know what hit them and Anu Malik had to offer some lame limpish comment to save face...

Frankly this is it ...to borrow a line from Remo. Lost all interest to watch the remaining 4 epi's,,,,,who cares who wins now? This season has to be the biggest farce...

I completely agree with you.
it has been a most uninspiring season this time around with not a single truly fully formed singer forget about versatility!!
There is not one contestant this time that you hear without bated breath crossing your fingers that they do not slip on surs and so on and so forth. Really pathetic choice of finalists and what a letdown!!
And not one who can confidentally hold the stage and just let himself or herself go since he or she is so sure of his or her singing prowess!!
Very lacklustre, very amateurish and too too young and immature both attitudinaly and as far as the voice goes. Not one effortless seamless singer.
Very very sad.
Hoping for a far superior show in saregamapa.
One lives on hope, doesn't one hehe

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".