when husband goes missing...

rajh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
when husband goes missing---
wife's sorrow and loneliness if shown properly will become surefire hit.
in HD--cvs completely failed to show this loneliness and pain of wife .
and viewers are disappointed.

so much scope was in this track but cvs instead on concentrating on indira and her pain...


here just an example-- how much this husband missing scenes can be heart touching...
just see this song and you able to feel the pain of girl immediately.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wwqec5ZIcZs&feature=related

however--you ever able to feel the indira pain in this present track??

cvs should have added one strong BG song for indiras pain in this track.
that would have conveyed indiras pain to viewers.

cvs failed in very very promising track.
trps are just showing this failure of cvs.
Edited by 100raj - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

61

Views

4.6k

Users

21

Likes

173

Frequent Posters

-Rinky- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
i think you never saw the track from indira's point of view...she misses her husband but she also has a Huge fixture on her family...her father plays a huge role in her life...and she is sort of weak when it comes to him...so maybe for her the father plays a priority most of the time...It is not a failure on the side of the Cvs...it is indira's nature...she is human after all and bound to have her issues 😛
Edited by -Rinky- - 13 years ago
ashish.sachi thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Hi 100raj.

Good to see you back here.😛

Don't worry , this track will get over soon.
rajh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: -Rinky-

i think you never saw the track from indira's point of view...she misses her husband but she also has a Huge fixture on her family...her father plays a huge role in her life...and she is sort of weak when it comes to him...so maybe for her the father plays a priority most of the time...It is not a failure on the side of the Cvs...it is indira's nature...she is human after all and bound to have her issues 😛



i see serial in totality always.

nobody's pov --works for any serial.

serial should click in totality with viewers.

i am posting as a viewer--you are posting as indira fan.

so our views clearly differs.




rajh thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: ashish.sachi

Hi 100raj.


Good to see you back here.😛

Don't worry , this track will get over soon.



mujhe iss track khatam hona yaa naa hona --mayane nahin rakhtha.

but
this track was golden opportunity for cvs to get good amount of trp.

but cvs failed to utilize it.

and now see the result.--just opposite happening.
Edited by 100raj - 13 years ago
AnkitalovesHD thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: 100raj



i see serial in totality always.

nobody's pov --works for any serial.

serial should click in totality with viewers.

i am posting as a viewer--you are posting as indira fan.

so our views clearly differs.





Arent you an Indira fan? 😊 I dont think you wud have been so concerned abt how Indira was being portrayed in such a heart wrenching track if you did not sympathize with her. You feel its unjust of the writers part not to pen pertinent scenes for Indira inorder for her to lament more beautifully.
I think you are absolutely correct Raj. We see what the Cvs want to show us. We cannot persuade ourselves to see something out of context esp if its not being poetically represented on the screen rite! It is a major failure in this track. Indira's moral dilemma is over riding the other emotion now. There shud have been numerous scenes (like the one in the temple of her house) to show how much Indira misses Rishi and is desperate for his safety.
Edited by AnkitalovesHD - 13 years ago
Mithila_22 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
you are absolutely right raj bhai..i am happy to see your post..😊
i couldn't see indira's pain for her husband but yes i could definitley see her love for her family when Rishi is missing..strange...i actually tried to keep myself at her position..tried to understand her..but failed to understand because if anyone's husband is missing, she would only and only think of her husband..thinking about family will be at rest for sometime..
and one more thing after marriage i think husband is the family..i do understand she has devoted herself to her family but all girls do and believe me they are more attached to their families because they get the love back from their families..yaha indira hasn't got anything in return..she should have only thought about Rishi i think...

we can take examples of girls in real lives who truly loved their husband/bf but they are missing or far apart..they forget everything..
the scenes in which we could see indira's restlessness and her love for Rishi after the kidnapping track lasted only for some days..i think those lasted till she handed over the case to sumer..after that it was not shown..and believe me i loved those scenes in which her restlessness was shown..i had made a VM also on that..just loved those scenes..

see the example of Hum Tumhare Hai Sanam
didn't madhuri's character loved her family more than anything still she couldn't think of anyone when she was away from her husband..
so restless she was..world had come to an end for her..

this is the reaction of a woman i feel when she is away from her husband..

yaha toh her husband is lost..what should have been her situation..CVs failed so is indira's character..

just my POV..no offence to anyone..
Edited by mithsi_22 - 13 years ago
AnkitalovesHD thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: mithsi_22

you are absolutely right raj bhai..i am happy to see your post..😊
i couldn't see indira's pain for her husband but yes i could definitley see her love for her family when Rishi is missing..strange...i actually tried to keep myself at her position..tried to understand her..but failed to understand because if anyone's husband is missing, she would only and only think of her husband..thinking about family will be at rest for sometime..
and one more thing after marriage i think husband is the family..i do understand she has devoted herself to her family but all girls do and believe me they are more attached to their families because they get the love back from their families..yaha indira hasn't got anything in return..she should have only thought about Rishi i think...

we can take examples of girls in real lives who truly loved their husband/bf but they are missing or far apart..they forget everything..
the scenes in which we could see indira's restlessness and her love for Rishi after the kidnapping track lasted only for some days..i think those lasted till she handed over the case to sumer..after that it was not shown..

see the example of Hum Tumhare Hai Sanam
didn't madhuri's character loved her family more than anything still she couldn't think of anyone when she was away from her husband..
so restless she was..world had come to an end for her..

this is the reaction of a woman i feel when she is away from her husband..

yaha toh her husband is lost..what should have been her situation..CVs failed so is indira's character..

just my POV..no offence to anyone..


Hi Mithsi. 😊 I loved what you said just one little delineation from your post wud be that i dont think that her love for her family has doubled over the period Rishi went missing. She could have been detached from her family only if she did not come face to face with the reality that her family is directly responsible. That moral dilemma is crushing her and the cvs have wonderfully woven things like guriyas birth in such a scenario or Indiras weakness for her father to purposely throw unnecessary obstacles in her path. 😆
Like all of you I would wish for this track to end. Sumit ji ab to holiday se wapas aao. Dekho tumhari absesne ko justify karne ke liye kaisa behuda tracks introduce kiya hai HD ki Cvs ne!😆
aadk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

i verry bdly wntd to c d scns whch cud reflect the pain n lonelinessns of indira in d absenc of rishi..yes dr wr sm scenes lyk wr indira prays to d goddess and tells dt sh had sent a messiah in r life who taght hr to smile and made hr relise wt it is like to b a girl,d scene wr indira s in hr room and thkns dt sh neva knew hw mch rishi matterd in hr life until he wnt missin and d scen wr she tells hr boss dt ntng wud mattr to hr more thn rishi...

bt i defntly agrree dt der cud hv been a lot morr scens concntrtng on indira' feelings for rishi...mny tyms i ws not able to relate to indira' chrctr esp wn sh stops sumer frm tkng munna to jail,but after reading a post by ankitaloveshd i feel dt wt sh did ws ryt...bt dis trk cud hv defntly been usedd in a lot morr bttr way...
nywys nyc post bhaiyya..
Edited by aadk - 13 years ago
-Rinky- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: 100raj



i see serial in totality always.

nobody's pov --works for any serial.

serial should click in totality with viewers.

i am posting as a viewer--you are posting as indira fan.

so our views clearly differs.



how sad you cant be see it as an Indira fan too Raj bro...

I thought the show was about Indira...how sad...her POV cannot be accepted as the POV of the show...

anyway welcome back raj bhai...we missed your negative posts...😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".