Debate: Umbridge Vs Bellatrix

I like Bellatrix. She had a reason for what she did. She did it all for Voldemort. Her love for Voldemort blinded everything else.

Originally posted by: herms_angel

I dislike both of them, but that's what we are supposed to do I guess going by their characters.Umbridge always had a prejudiced view on those who were part-humans and on humans too (in some case, Harry, Dumbledore etc).And Bellatrix's love for Voldemort blinded everything else.Both loved being 'evil'.I'd like to see them duel, and I have feeling Bellatrix would win, after all she seems more experienced!

BTW, Good to see back Amal.Nice Post! :)

Both are pure evil. I don't think I would ever justify Bellatrix's being "evil" all in the name of love. Yes she loved Voldemort and did it all for him, but she also killed for fun. She just liked and enjoyed torturing people. So I can never forgive her for torturing Neville's parents into insanity, and for killing Sirius Black. Yes I hate Bellatrix. I love Helena Carter, but I hate Bellatrix the character. Her love was overpowered by the desire to be evil.

Now coming to Umbridge. She was stupid, silly actually. She was evil, but I can say Umbridge didn't go around killing people for fun. Although She IS EVIL, and I HATE what she did to Harry. But then, didn't Bellatrix do the same to Hermione? So this makes it scores equal. Both are equally evil, pathetic and take pleasure in being evil, and thus I hate both of them.

Umbridge was ridiculous self centered disgusting n over confident !!! did not like her a bit !!!