i wish jk rowling hadnt done tht...!

mihi7ka thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
hola frnds!:)
okay lets get to the point..firstly,JK shudnt have killed tonks nd lupin in the last book..just after having their first kid..:(
even so,i always felt tht lupin used to love harry a lot..but sirius was given the utmost attention..lupin too was harry's dad closest frnd..
why kill dobby??!very angry wid tht part.
and ginny??is tth a CHOICE for dear harry!???whoa!
i coundnt just take tht..harry shud have been paired with hermione!really!:)
and lastly..almost 14 ppl die in the last book..but wait..none of harry's frnds!none of ginny,harry,hermoine,ron,neville,luna die!what a co-incidence!!:X
hope u guys reply!

Created

Last reply

Replies

156

Views

12.9k

Users

21

Likes

296

Frequent Posters

-GredForge- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: mihi7ka

hola frnds!:)

okay lets get to the point..firstly,JK shudnt have killed tonks nd lupin in the last book..just after having their first kid..:(
agree with that but its her choice!
even so,i always felt tht lupin used to love harry a lot..but sirius was given the utmost attention..lupin too was harry's dad closest frnd..
i think he too was given equal attention~!
why kill dobby??!very angry wid tht part.
its sumtimes necessary to do that u know!
and ginny??is tth a CHOICE for dear harry!???whoa!
ginny is the best with harry!!!
i coundnt just take tht..harry shud have been paired with hermione!really!:)
no!!!! ron/hermione r the best!!
and lastly..almost 14 ppl die in the last book..but wait..none of harry's frnds!none of ginny,harry,hermoine,ron,neville,luna die!
do u really want them to die?? and incase u forgot fred died!!😭
what a co-incidence!!:X
hope u guys reply!
this is all my opinion ! no offence!

Stark_Wolf thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

No offence bt Harry Hermione pair will b like sis bro nd Gin is perfect for harry nd RHr they are jus perfect for each other atleast i think like that...

Abt Lupin nd Tonks evn i really like them bt if Jo has killed them then thats it...It is a war nd at times like this many unexpected ppl die nd they are one among them!!!!
mihi7ka thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

yup...i noe. HP is the best series buk i have eva read..but at the end of the book wat i felt was tht the story was awesome..with a pathetic ending! :(
Edited by mihi7ka - 14 years ago
mihi7ka thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: lazzz

No offence bt Harry Hermione pair will b like sis bro nd Gin is perfect for harry nd RHr they are jus perfect for each other atleast i think like that...

Abt Lupin nd Tonks evn i really like them bt if Jo has killed them then thats it...It is a war nd at times like this many unexpected ppl die nd they are one among them!!!!

hmm..bro-ssi cuz JK made them to be..otherwise i guess they had superb understanding and respect for each other..ginny.on the other hand..i guess i neva iked tht character..thot she was always a lil stupid . :(
315925 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
She shouldn't have killed Remus & Tonks. 😭 She shouldn't have killed Fred Weasley. 😭 She shouldn't have killed Dobby the free elf. 😭
And yes, I think Hermione should have been with Draco or Harry. 😳
_Jiya_ thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mihi7ka

hmm..bro-ssi cuz JK made them to be..otherwise i guess they had superb understanding and respect for each other..ginny.on the other hand..i guess i neva iked tht character..thot she was always a lil stupid . :(


it was Jkr only who made harry potter...and i think ginny understood harry more thn hermione...hermione was alwys like an older sister always advising him don't do dis nd don't do tht
but Lupin nd Tonks death was really shocking for me
Edited by _Jiya_ - 14 years ago
cooldude10 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: mihi7ka

hmm..bro-ssi cuz JK made them to be..otherwise i guess they had superb understanding and respect for each other..ginny.on the other hand..i guess i neva iked tht character..thot she was always a lil stupid . :(

haha, okay. a big disagree.
HARRY AND HERMIONE? Even without having JKR making harry speak aloud the fact that what he felt for hermione was nothing more than brotherly love, it feels like incest.
No offense, just my thoughts.
And on ginny's issue, i think she's an ultimate Bada**. She's always been strong and can put harry in his place. Hermione on the other hand has always been affected by ron since like... the fourth book. LOL.
cooldude10 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
about JKR killing off people... let's not forget this is war. This ain't no twi-shit where all the good people get to be perfectly happy. In case it's not noticed, when has life ever been fair? 😆
alia thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: cooldude10


</div>haha, okay. a big disagree.
<div>

HARRY AND HERMIONE? Even without having JKR making harry speak aloud the fact that what he felt for hermione was nothing more than brotherly love, it feels like incest.

</strong>


No offense, just my thoughts.


And on ginny's issue, i think she's an ultimate Bada**. She's always been strong and can put harry in his place. Hermione on the other hand has always been affected by ron since like... the fourth book. LOL.
<strong>


totally agree... Harry/Ginny n Ron/hermione just click together n r easy to accept...
specially Ron/hermione -> their case is like opposites attract!

tho for FFs I myself have indulged in Draco/hermione... but as per JKRs books D/Hr just can never be together... :p

as for tonks n remus dying... it's sad... she cud have kept atleast one of them alive for the sake of baby lupin... *

as for dobby... I look tht as a very essential part...
what with whn Harry gives dobby a respectful burial does the goblin really start having a lil trust in Harry...



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".