i wish jk rowling hadnt done tht...!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

HeartEmWatson

@HeartEmWatson

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

#11

Agree that Harry & Hermione should've ended together. But you know all the non-book people who watched the movie here thought they were 'secretly in love' 😆... so no complains from movies.

Even from book's pov, I reckon what Harmony shared is way beyond love...something extremely intense & powerful, hard to put in words. Like soulmates... soulmates might not always end up together but they share this soul-connection which keeps em together 😳

Edited by SoEulMate_LoVeR - 14 years ago

Quote

mihi7ka

@mihi7ka

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: cooldude10
about JKR killing off people... let's not forget this is war. This ain't no twi-shit where all the good people get to be perfectly happy. In case it's not noticed, when has life ever been fair? 😆

exactly wen has life been fair..but it had been overtly fair for this five-some.

thts one thing JK overlooked..and honestly..ending the book on a 19 yr leap was a disater..it was like killing all hope for any "hogwarts" book.🤢

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

mihi7ka

@mihi7ka

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: cooldude10
haha, okay. a big disagree.

HARRY AND HERMIONE? Even without having JKR making harry speak aloud the fact that what he felt for hermione was nothing more than brotherly love, it feels like incest.

No offense, just my thoughts.

And on ginny's issue, i think she's an ultimate Bada**. She's always been strong and can put harry in his place. Hermione on the other hand has always been affected by ron since like... the fourth book. LOL.

whoa...okay if she wanted to put up harry-ginny atleast they shud have shared some more space.it was more like strong infatuation rather than love.!😆

they hardly have talked in the books!and they end up getting married??some views!😲

Quote

mihi7ka

@mihi7ka

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: alia

yeah opposites attract ..only in bollywood films!😳

Quote

Janaki

@RamKiSeeta

Achiever

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#15

Ron and Hermione were the best couple in HP, and I can honestly see Hermione with no other character. I always viewed her and Harry as brother/sister, and the love they shared was more familial than romantic. I'm really glad JKR made them end up together and it's stricly a member's personal opinion if they feel otherwise.😊 Also, let's please keep in mind that though we all feel as if Harry is ours, JKR created him and she alone has the right to do what she wants. We cannot criticize her for the relationships she created or the deaths she wrought because it is her series and she is the sole author to it. We can have our hopes and dreams about characters, but when they turn out differently from how we expected, we shouldn't feel as if it's a betrayal or that JKR was foolish. It's her book, her choice.

Personally, I feel Harry and Ginny clicked. They did not share the same chemistry as Ron/Hermione because Harry's life was not about romance. He had too much on his plate already and JKR wanted to give the romantic attention to her next two main characters, Ron and Hermione. Yeah, she did not write much about Ginny in the series, but I do not believe it was infatuation that she and Harry had. How can we say that? They barely showed any scenes between them because Harry was always busy trying to kill Voldemort, he did not have the time to take part in normal teenage romance like his friends. I can see why people don't like Ginny, as sometimes she annoys me too, but in the end I feel she was right for Harry, and Ron and Hermione right for each other even more so.

As for the deaths, I would not change any of them. They were all sad, yes, but necessary for the story. Personally, I don't have the ability to kill off my good characters when I write stories, so I really applaud JKR for her nerve.👏 It's not easy, especially when those characters become so beloved to you, but sometimes it's necessary for the storyline and I wouldn't have DH turning out any other way.

Edited by JanakiRaghunath - 14 years ago

Quote

Janaki

@RamKiSeeta

Achiever

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: mihi7ka
yeah opposites attract ..only in bollywood films!😳

Lols, I agree with this part...I've never held on to the belief that opposites attract, most of the successful relationships I have seen have partners being similar in mentality.

Though I do not believe Ron and Hermione were all that opposite in mentality, they were quite similar if you think about it, especially in their insecurities and fears about being accepted by others. That's why I believe they made such a good couple.

Quote

315925

Hibernated

Posted: 14 years ago

#17

I feel Harry-Hermione has a lot more depth than Ron-Hermione. She needed someone a lot more mature than Ron. I love Ron, but just not with Hermione. I always, always thought Harry-Hermione would be endgame. I ship Draco-Hermione a lot more though, they could have been a Delena-ish couple.

Quote

Ayesha.

@cooldude10

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: mihi7ka
exactly wen has life been fair..but it had been overtly fair for this five-some.
thts one thing JK overlooked..and honestly..ending the book on a 19 yr leap was a disater..it was like killing all hope for any "hogwarts" book.🤢

YEAH, HOW FAIR HARRY'S LIFE HAS BEEN. He spent all his years fighting voldemort. He lost his parents when he was only just a baby. He saw his godfather die, lupin, tonks... he found out the fact that severus was only trying to protect him and saw his death. His horrible, horrible death. HOW FAIR.
Now don't get me started about ron and hermione. 😆

Quote

Ayesha.

@cooldude10

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: mihi7ka

whoa...okay if she wanted to put up harry-ginny atleast they shud have shared some more space.it was more like strong infatuation rather than love.!😆

they hardly have talked in the books!and they end up getting married??some views!😲

It's the author's decision and IT'S BEEN MADE. Now, we don't know when they got married now do we? Harry and Ginny didn't get married RIGHT AFTER THE EFFING BATTLE. They must have spent some time... only, we didn't get to read it. You can't really expect poor JKR to put in every detail of harry's life. For me, I think it was infatuation in the sixth book and a very strong one. It could have blossomed into love in the next years that we didn't get to read about.

Frankly, i love the way JKR ended. And I'm quite satisfied with R/HR and HR/Ginny.