Appreciation vs Criticsm?Why Manish?

Page

Next Last

manzanas_asadas

@manzanas_asadas

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

I am not here to bash anyone or anything or any personality, BUT I need an answer.

Rather than APPRECIATING the fact that Manish calmed the situation down by taking Jai back to his seat [ HE MADE IT BETTER FOR JAI..the more he would speak, the more people would start to hate not only him but team Josh...and the situation was going out of hand ], Siddhesh criticized Manish saying that when someone is speaking the truth, someone else pushes him away from saying so. EVEN MANISH? THE HOST OF THE SHOW?WHY? I kindly want to know the answer.

NO, I am not bashing Siddhesh. I ONLY want to know WHY Manish was involved into this. WASN"T it the SAME Manish who made him FEEL FREE and better and consoled him when he was crying? This is what he gets for entertaining them? NO offence to ANYONE, I just need an answer.

Edited by Priyanka_AAIICH - 14 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Ekta

@-desigirl-

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

i seek an answer tootht is so unfair and a shame too see someone insulting such an amazing human being

why does manish care so much for them when he gets this back :@

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

manzanas_asadas

@manzanas_asadas

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

^ That's what I don't understand..when he entertains them, they enjoy to the fullest, and then he is accused out of NOWHERE..I loved that Remo said "someone tell me what he just said"..and Manish was still so calm..that guy is just too sweet! :)

He was just calming the situation down..when I saw him take Jai, I started laughing that YES at least someone calmed the situation,and then I hear Siddhesh saying this and I was stunned.

Quote

Ekta

@-desigirl-

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

i tried to figure out wht remo said at the end tht made everyone laugh

i think he said "can someone tell me wht should we say to these ppl"

atleast thts wht i understood lol

Quote

tulipbaby53

@tulipbaby53

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Well, it's because he's immature and does not see the situation through. He sees only Manish as interrupting Jai, whereas Manish was helping not bring negativity to Jai and their team. Unfortunately, Siddesh only focused on one aspect of it and became rude to someone who was trying to help them out.

I'm not defending Siddesh at all, but you asked for an answer, and this is what I'm thinking. Again, I'm not saying he was right (I do not think it was right AT ALL.)

Quote

manzanas_asadas

@manzanas_asadas

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: tulipbaby53
Well, it's because he's immature and does not see the situation through. He sees only Manish as interrupting Jai, whereas Manish was helping not bring negativity to Jai and their team. Unfortunately, Siddesh only focused on one aspect of it and became rude to someone who was trying to help them out.

I'm not defending Siddesh at all, but you asked for an answer, and this is what I'm thinking. Again, I'm not saying he was right (I do not think it was right AT ALL.)

😆 I know exactly why you responded in such a way. 😆 don't worry, I am not thinking that you are saying anyone is right or wrong. I actually agree with everything you said. I just don't understand why the Manish was criticized when he was the one trying to help them. Was it just for the sake of turning the topic around?

Quote

hindu4lyf

@hindu4lyf

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

I was one of the people who never really liked to hear Siddesh speak but I've always been a fan of his dance. From what I can make out he's not making a personal attack on Manish but it seems more like him making a general comment about life in general. Or maybe I'm wrong and there's more to it all than what meets the eye? I guess we may never know.

Manish was obviously trying to calm the situation in order to avoid any fights and I hope he didn't take any of the comments to heart cos he seems like a sensible guy. :)

Can I just say though that I loved the confidence that was oozing out of Kunwar and Vandana. Jai may have been right when talking about the technicalities, I'm not sure tbh but it's always great to see an improvement in dance which is what the show is about after all. :) just to add to that..

anyone have any idea who did the group choreography for Josh's bhangra performance? Awesome group choreography..hats off to the choreographer seriously and even the outfits were great! and lastly i'm glad Alisha hasn't lost that x factor even after so long..her confidence and attitude while dancing is great! :) Strangely Avneet stood out a lot more than Vaishnavi for me too. Thanks for the link btw!

Quote

hindu4lyf

@hindu4lyf

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: tulipbaby53
Well, it's because he's immature and does not see the situation through. He sees only Manish as interrupting Jai, whereas Manish was helping not bring negativity to Jai and their team. Unfortunately, Siddesh only focused on one aspect of it and became rude to someone who was trying to help them out.

I'm not defending Siddesh at all, but you asked for an answer, and this is what I'm thinking. Again, I'm not saying he was right (I do not think it was right AT ALL.)

That seems like a likely scenario. From Siddesh's point of view Jai was trying to make a point and he was rudely interrupted and dragged back to his seat by Manish. Looking at it from Siddesh's point of view, he sees his team mate being insulted and that's probably what irked him and plus like I said earlier I think he's speaking from experience and was making a more general comment. :\

Quote

desigirl123

@desigirl123

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

I really applaud the way Amar handled the situation. Instead of getting defensive and aggresive, he calmly and nicely pointed out that Siddhesh did the same last week. I love that he added 'thanks for the suggestion though'. It was the perfect response. Even though DID 1 are great dancers, DID 2 def has more class..

And manish def did not do anything wrong. Props to him for trying to help everyone.

Quote

manzanas_asadas

@manzanas_asadas

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#10

Originally posted by: desigirl123
I really applaud the way Amar handled the situation. Instead of getting defensive and aggresive, he calmly and nicely pointed out that Siddhesh did the same last week. I love that he added 'thanks for the suggestion though'. It was the perfect response. Even though DID 1 are great dancers, DID 2 def has more class..

And manish def did not do anything wrong. Props to him for trying to help everyone.

I couldn't have stated better myself!👏 I respect Amar even more now. He didn't break even or anything, just kept his cool and pointed out what he had to and spoke up for his rights! 😳

Quote

1 2 3

Appreciation vs Criticsm?Why Manish?

Related Topics

Explore Topics