Elimination *spoiler*

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Nikita Lakhe

@nikitagmc

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#71

Originally posted by: indiandoll89
People need to stop blaming Ankita or Mahi for Ragini's elimination. I'm not a fan of either of those girls but I am a fan of Ragini's and so I'm hurt about this elimination but since the first week it's been clear that Ragini's fan base is completely low; something I don't understand since SGP is such a great show and she's been getting so much praise for it.

I believe Mahi should've gone out before Ragini and Ankita shouldn't have come back but that doesn't mean I'm going to blame either of them for this...I just have my hopes pinned on the fact that the top three are people who have showed excellence in DANCE. Not in nautanki or being all cute and giggly through their comments 😊

I agree.😊

I'm a fan of Ragini too, and even though I'm not happy that she has been eliminated, its not fair to blame any contestant. Its not the contestant's fault if the audience is voting for her/him.

Edited by nikitagmc - 14 years ago

Quote

blahblahs

@blahblahs

Navigator

Posted: 14 years ago

#72

NOOOOOOOOOOOO! I LIKEDHER...she was always smiling and stuff...she was a good entertainer...ankita or mahi should've gone...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

prettywomen22

@prettywomen22

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#73

Originally posted by: CuteCherry

i respect ur opinion but y would judges have to do justice to get ankita out ??when she was the third highest scorer last week and is dancing so well and her performance are always great. and by da way they are doing justice by giving the scores she deserves😃 and she is a great dancer so don't see why judges would want her out. and fyi it all depends on the audience vote.😊

no problem cutecherry, but I am just curious,, didn't Ragini score more than others last week? and no, I kind of do not beleive audience vote matters etc., I couldn't figure out how the entire marks make up to. If audience vote are to be major criteria, then probably Daya Sir wouldn't have gone so early. Anywayzzz, my opinion was that Ragz shouldn't have gone this week. I am disappointed with this and accordingly to me it is Ankita. Many here buy in this and most others don't. 😉

Quote

abhi

@abhi786

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 14 years ago

#74

I didn't understand the concept of JDJ 4..

The elimination depends on the votes. so why the judges give them marks? Why comments?? Just the celebs come and dance and the judge don't give their marks, as they are not taken into account...

Now Ragini is the top 2nd scorer .. She was in the last 2 on voting bases..

Before that Salman/Yana and Ankitha eliminated in the show, so that means voters really not voted for them?????

If the judges take into account the voters choice so why there is wildcard entries ???????

Shekar Suman got more votes and didn't once in the last 2, he got face off only for not performing well once aqnd droping in the middle, so that's how was in the face-off..

If JDJ is on voters base.. so the TOP 5 would have been according to voters choice .. as they are saying ... sushant, change, mahi, shekar suman and ragini and 6th one will be daya sir as there will be no wildcard entries..........

Quote

rinkyyy.

@-Rinki-

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#75

Oh god, JDJ 4 has been so complicated when it comes to elimination and votes :|

According to the performances, Mahi should have been out today. Even though I like both Mahi and Ragini, Ragini has improved A LOT. Ragini has the potential in her!
I'm not saying that Mahi is a bad dancer but its Top5..people need to get eliminated -.-

I will miss Ragini's presence in JDJ. & Yana in Danger Zone? WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH PEOPLE?!
Anyway, I've lost hope. I hate the whole voting system :|

Quote

Rana

@hamzanuha

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

#76

Hi,

Since the past few weeks, I've been reading how people feel that JDJ4 is scripted or the format is getting changed from what it was in the past 3 seasons, etc. etc. I'd like to add my two cents on this.

Yes, it's sad that good dancers are getting eliminated before weak ones. Yes, it's bewildering that a performer who had one of the top scores in the previous week is found to be in the bottom two the very next week. Crazy, isn't it?

I think the answer lies in Madhuri's interview, wherein she states how much the organisers went out to convince her to say yes. She says they took her to LA to see the original, how "they promised me to do something at that level and treat it differently from what they've been doing so far". Read it here https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/jhalak-dikhhla-jaa-4-dancing-with-the-stars/1614052/looking-for-positives-madhuri

There's another article which states how original contestants were dropped to bring the show upto Madhuri's expectations. Find it here https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/jhalak-dikhhla-jaa-4-dancing-with-the-stars/1609648/contestants-dropped-for-madhuri

Could it be due to all the changes that JDJ is losing it's charm & interest? Anyone agrees with me?

Rana

Quote

CuteCherry

@CuteCherry

Voyager

Posted: 14 years ago

#77

Originally posted by: prettywomen22

no problem cutecherry, but I am just curious,, didn't Ragini score more than others last week? and no, I kind of do not beleive audience vote matters etc., I couldn't figure out how the entire marks make up to. If audience vote are to be major criteria, then probably Daya Sir wouldn't have gone so early. Anywayzzz, my opinion was that Ragz shouldn't have gone this week. I am disappointed with this and accordingly to me it is Ankita. Many here buy in this and most others don't. 😉

yeah ragini did score more but i haven't said anything like ragini deserved to go or anything??well even i was sad of her leaving. i was just asking u on what bases Ankita should have gone out??? but oh well u didn't answer me that question.😕u just stated that it would have been justice?? like what justice?? actually it would have been injustice if she was out.she has been getting good scores and her performance has always been very good. so in ur opinion ankita should have gone before mahi😕i see something here🤔and i think audience votes does matter maybe daya's voters decreased because he was bad at dancing.simple as that. did u expect da audience to vote for him even after he didn't perform da week before😕

well SOME here don't buy it and it's always the same "SOME" which includes u too and MOST people don't😃