Originally posted by: abhishah
That's news to me... All the reviews that I read said it was Kajol through & through...
</div>
<div>
I suppose this article is for those that worship Bebo and who unfortunately haven't seen the film in muliti plex...
</div>
<div>Excellent PR work KJO
than what is this? Apparently some critics thought they were both good. Here is a boxoffice review and what they thought about the performance.
Performance-wise, who scores over whom? Now that's a debatable debate! If Kajol is brilliant in one scene, Kareena has the upper-hand in the next. If Kajol scores ten on ten in the emotional scenes, Kareena speaks volumes with her expressions. If Kajol gives her best at being a strict mother, the kids will love Kareena, a new-age, friendly mom. There's no telling who's better but one thing's certain – only these two actresses could have made this film what it is. Perfect casting!Movie Review: We Are Family
By Dipali Turakhia, Team iDiva
Movie Review: We Are Family
Kajol may get a thumbs-up for her heart-breaking portrayal of a dying woman but the winner is...
Kajol and Kareena Kapoors willtheyorwontthey live cordially banter is enjoyable.
What's not:
Director Siddharth Malhotra turning the movie into one big Balaji soap. Every scene is overlydramatic sans the triple pan shots and slowmotion crying. They even have a 20year leap No Kidding.
iDiva verdict:
Kajol gets a thumbsup but sorry to say its Kareena Kapoor who gives a clear standout performance EDITOR'S RATING:
Another one that thought Kareena was betterWe Are Family - Movie review
By: Sarita Tanwar Date: 2010-09-04 Place: Mumbai
Kajol is at her natural best. She captures the helplessness and anguish of Maya flawlessly. Arjun Rampal scores again after Raajneeti. It's not easy to hold your own in a women-oriented script but Arjun manages to surpass all expectations.
The scene-stealer of WAF is Kareena Kapoor -- probably in her most restrained portrayal to date. She matches Kajol's cracking prowess in every confrontational scene. And she makes Shreya's character far more endearing than the script intended to. Supremely in command as a young girl having a family and children thrust upon her, Kareena is a delight on screen. I think I made my point now. Not all thought kajol stole the show. :)
Edited by lensahunte08 - 15 years ago
6