Bad Music 'HAMPERS' VEER !!!

Ultimate_Shadow thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
Bad music hampers Veer
The music of the film Veer starring Salman Khan hasn't taken off at all. And the makers are very upset about that. Even if the film is a big film about fights and wars, good romantic songs are the order of the day and can help a lot in the promotion as well. This is a lesson that Anil Sharma and Co did not learn from Ashutosh Gowariker who made Jodhaa Akbar and got AR Rahman to compose some wonderful tunes for the film. Even the Legend of Bhagat Singh had some good music. Or for that matter, Anil Sharma's own film Gadar had music that one could relate to and it was a hit as well. But the film which hits the box office this week is clearly handicapped by bad music and will find it difficult to recover its money as this is the first big film of the year and it does not seem that the Salman magic will work again like it did with Wanted.

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

1.6k

Users

6

Likes

3

Frequent Posters

Ultimate_Shadow thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
lol...at the end of the article...thy r actually saying...tht it will be flopped..gosh
ISano thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
hmm well who says it has bad music..
havent they heard salaam aaya surili ankhionn wali
and mehrbaniya
-Aladin- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
VEER MUSIC REVIEW
By Joginder Tuteja, December 21, 2009 - 12:43 IST

EXPECTATIONS

Honestly, expectations aren't mammoth from the music of Veer. Yes, the film stars Salman Khan but Veer is a departure for him when it comes to his on-screen image. Yes, the film has music by Sajid-Wajid but this was clearly a setting that brought them out of their comfort zone. In fact, presence of Gulzar as the lyricist further makes one wonder how this unique combination will actually click. Moreover, since the film is a historical, there is always a 'what if' factor involved.

MUSIC

Write your own music review of Veer
However, there is a surprise in store from the very first note of Veer with a grand feel with which 'Taali' arrives. An uncharacteristic beginning to the album due to the fact that it is not really a love song that kick starts the proceedings, 'Taali' is a spirited track that boasts of great energy. A truly Indian number which has Sukhwinder Singh at his boisterous best (who later returns to do a 'solo version' of the song), 'Taali' boasts of some fine arrangements with a variety of instruments coming into play. In fact if not for Sajid-Wajid on the credits, one may have well imagined A.R. Rahman to be at the helm of affairs here. With Sonu Nigam joining the show and Wajid along with Neuman Pinto providing added support, 'Taali' takes a couple of listenings to settle down but once that happens, one looks forward to how director Anil Sharma has got the kind of grandeur that the song deserves. A good start.

From here on the album takes a turn for something even better with 'Surili Akhiyon Wale' coming next. A melodic romantic number that boasts of some heartfelt and never heard before lyrics (has anyone ever heard of 'ankhiyan' being 'surili'?), it is further elevated due to silky vocals of Rahat Fateh Ali Khan. He sings 'Surili Akhiyon Wale' at a low pitch and in the process of doing so comes up with a rendition that would certainly make a mark for months to come. Sajid-Wajid take a complete departure from the kind of score they have made for films like Wanted and get into a classy scheme of things.

The song also includes an English portion (obviously created for a Brit woman who is in love) and singer Suzanne D'mello pretty much justifies her inclusion. In fact it's not just the 'mukhda' but even the 'antara' that works so very well that one finds it difficult to move on to the next track in the offing. A brilliant track that also appears in a much deserving duet which also features Sunidhi Chauhan. If the film is successful at the box office, it would be hard to ignore 'Surili Akhiyon Wale' which is as pure as it gets.

It is the same purity that can be evidenced in 'Salaam Aaya' and by the time the song is one minute through, one is convinced that Sajid-Wajid had some of their best compositions reserved for Veer. In fact the song makes one wonder that why had they been choosing a different route for most of their masala outings when they had so much to offer. A soothing track that sees the coming together of Roop Kumar Rathod and Shreya Goshal, 'Salaam Aaya' is a moderately paced love song which is a complete shift from the high-on-beats club tracks that are in vogue today. This one has a truly Indian appeal to it and though one doesn't quite hum around such songs on road, it does make a good impact on audio.

For Salman Khan fans through there is 'Meherbaniyan'. A Sonu Nigam solo, this one has an elaborate beginning to it and while there is a definite old world feel to 'Meherbaniyan', one can't deny the fact that Salman will have his fans asking for more once the track plays on screen. The beginning of the track doesn't quite indicate where it is heading but the moment the word 'Meherbaniyan' is heard for the first time (after about 60 seconds), it is obvious that there won't be any looking back. A dance number that could well have been placed in a movie belonging to today's time, 'Meherbaniyan' may not carry the same appeal as the opening three tracks but would go down reasonably well with the masses.

However, for class lovers there is a 'thumri' - 'Kanha' which establishes once again that Sajid-Wajid do come with a good enough classical background. They may be making a Paying Guest on and off but listening to 'Kanha' brings an entirely different facet of their composing skills. They also rope in the best in the business with Rekha Bhardwaj leading the charge. Even though the track has a strong classical base to it, the accompanying vocals of Shabab Sabri, Toshi & Sharib ensure that it doesn't just restrict itself to the class audiences. A very good piece musically, it should add value to the film's narrative.

Last to come is a one minute instrumental piece 'Spirit Of Veer' which has a 'Meherbaniyan' feel to it while being laced with fun and humour.

OVERALL

Veer throws a pleasant surprise. There were apprehensions galore (as explained eariler) but a couple of listening pretty much facilitates their dilution. Sajid-Wajid have indeed given their best three soundtracks ever in Veer and though they may have had managed chartbusters earlier, Veer is the kind of album that would fetch them a much deserving respect. Along with Gulzar they have created the kind of tunes that may not necessarily turn out to be the hugest chartbusters of the year but would certainly be remembered for time to come.

OUR PICK(S)

'Surili Akhiyon Wale', 'Salaam Aaya', 'Taali' [Play Songs]

-Aladin- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
Veer Music Review: Veer (2010) Music Album Review:-

1. Taali
Begins with soulful wordings sung by Sukhwinder Singh. Then transits to a Gujarati themed song. Preferably meant for regional listeners only.

2. Surili Akhiyon Wale
Rahat Fateh Ali Khan's songs now seems to sound very similar. He uses the same flow and the same pitch for this song similar to 'Zindagi' from Dil Kabaddi. It also means that the song is equally good.

3. Salaam Aaya
Suits perfect for depicting the old King Rule era. Sweet lyrics with light music, a melody.

4. Meherbaniyan
The song only gets better when there is chorus singing of Meherbaniyan. Not the best from Sonu Nigam for sure.

5. Kanha – Thumri
Sensational song! Although much of the song features some other Indian Language then Hindi. So, there will be disparity between listeners but the two beginning lines you hear will leave you spellbound.

6. Spirit Of Veer – Instrumental
This is only the theme music of the film. Sounded childish to me.

Remixes
There are no typical remixes but a duet and solo version of the earlier songs. Offers variety and are equally good.

Overall Music Review of Veer

Veer Music Album suits the theme of the film well and cleverly recreates pre-historic era through its music. One of the best works by music duo Sajid – Wajid in recent times. Lyricist Gulzar delivers adequately with his expertize lyrics. Choice of the singers for each song is remarkable, almost feels like that these songs were made by keeping them in mind.

Favorite Soundtrack: Kanha – Thumri

Worst Soundtrack: None

Verdict: Music matches the theme of the film

-Aladin- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
Veer Music Review: Chest thumping good!

Frankly speaking, I was not keen on reviewing the music of Veer, but the minute I read that Gulzar saab is the lyricist, my ears shot up. Did I hear that right? Gulzar for Sajid-Wajid! Has it come to this?

Two years ago when Javed Akhtar wrote for Himesh Reshammiya's tunes in Namastey London, there was catharsis, this time I was armoured for cardiac arrest.

Veer kickstarts with a Taali- the first track, and am going to say this right away, that given the period form of this film, the track is a throwback to Takkey Takkey from Mangal Pandey in rhythm, or so I thought. But that is doing dis-service to Sajid-Wajid's talent and Gulzar's poetry. How do they even make music together? Grr, get over it with Taali. At forty-five seconds past three minutes the song has an interlude which borrows both from Jodhaa-Akbar's Azeem-o-Shaan and Lagaan's Chale-Chalo. Just when I thought they are original. Corblimey! "Jeeya ka katora dard se bhar gayi" – that's Gulzar saab on Taali.

Rahat Fateh Ali Khan eulogizes in Surili Akhiyon Wale from where 'needein behti hai'. It's a bend in the river for starry dreams till Suzanne D'Mello yodels in doing what the English rose did in 'Ori Chori' from Lagaan 'My heart- it speaks a thousand words, it speaks eternal bliss…' Here Suzanne writhes in ecstasy, 'Every time I look into your eyes, I see my paradise…' It's a western shtick in a desi beat, but it works for all. The song is mighty pleasant on the eardrums. Your heart might beat to this da dum drum drum. There's an extended version with Sunidhi Chauhan responding to Rahat where she sounds like she's milking honey in her voice if such a thing can be achieved in a cloyingly feverish pitch.

Salaam Aaya has a pretty ordinary dhol beat where Shreya Ghoshal cascades with a 'khanak' to accompany Roop Kumar Rathod in this lovey-dovey duet. The orchestration could have been broken to introduce an element of surprise, to upset the metre and return back to groove, but let's leave that to Rahman. Why am I complaining so much, this is Sajid-Wajid – the 'oh keinde pump pump pump up' people.

Sonu Nigam, who has been missing from the playback scene, comes up with Meherbaniyaan – Scottish bagpipes to announce his arrival. This track is a jolly cheers to the tippled fighting spirit of the Veer sena and will look good on-screen when Salman takes to the stage in his disco act, doing what he does best – shaking his tush, displaying his roguish charm. If he wears a kilt and performs, catcalls galore!

Now the good part, a thumri in a Sajid-Wajid score. Ha, ha, ha. A chorus actually ha-ha huffs and pa-pa pants to open the song for the woman of the dunes – Rekha Bhardwaj who pleads with Kanha to play the flute. Eminently likeable track though.

Sukhwinder Singh gets to reprise Taali in a solo version, its infectious lilt tap-tap tapping for encore. Come to think of it, a taali on taal, what could go wrong? No claptrap this!

Veer ends with the instrumental Spirit of Veer – a Scottish country dance track out of place in the film's score.

Pick up Veer for the New Year and start on a classical note – away from the techno sounds of Pritam's muzak.

Music:
Sajid Wajid

Lyrics: Gulzar

Singers:
Sukhwinder Singh, Sunidhi Chauhan, Sonu Nigam, Shreya Ghoshal, Rahat Fateh Ali Khan

Label: Eros

Stars:
3

http://www.starboxoffice.com/movie/musicreview.aspx?bid=2008/November/reviews_20081103_3
-Aladin- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

In any case, I am not going to bother posting more and more reviews of Veer's music. Considering it has two chartbuster songs, Salaam Aaya and Surili Ankhion, I hardly see it as a 'bad' music album.

Whatever. People have their own taste in music.
They are already writing off the movie when it has not even released yet. 🤢 How do they know whether Salman's magic would work or not. 🤔
How can Salman like the media when they show him such attitude. 😡
Ultimate_Shadow thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
Music of Salman Khan's Veer disappoints
Music Review: Veer (2010)

Artist: Sonu Niigaam, Wajid, Neuman Pinto, Rahat Fateh Ali Khan, Suzanne D'Mello, Rekha Bhardwaj, Sharib Sabri, Toshi Sabri, Shabaab Sabri, Sukhwinder Singh, Sunidhi Chauhan, Roop Kumar Rathod, Shreya Ghoshal

Music Director: Sajid-Wajid

Lyricist: Gulzar

Label: Eros Music

Genre: Bollywood

Rating: 2.5/5

When one listens to the Veer album, they know right away that Sajid-Wajid have clearly tried to make music different from their usual kind. Now, how far it will impress audiences is yet to be seen'

The album opens with Taali, sung by Sukhwinder Singh, Rahat Ali Khan, Wajid and Neuman Pinto. A track about warriors and victory, it sounds like an AR Rahman composition. But it suits the film and makes for a good listen. It also has another version; a solo by Sukhwinder that is only a lot more dramatic.

The next track, Surili Akhiyon Waali is one of the most romantic songs one could come across these days. Complete with beautiful lyrics and perfectly sung by Rahat Fateh Ali Khan, the song couldn't have been any better. While it is somewhat tragic, it is nonetheless one of the album's best songs. It also has a duet version, with Sunidhi Chauhan, which sounds slightly better than the original.

Salaam Aya, the next song, has some good vocals by Roop Kumar Rathod and Shreya Ghoshal. While it is not quite on the same level as the earlier track, it has a place of its own.

Meherbaniyan, a dance number, sung by Sonu Niigaam comes next. It is probably one of those tracks on the album that will attract masses. While it is a misfit for a period film, audiences may still enjoy it.

Then comes Kanha, a Thumri number, by Rekha Bhardwaj and Toshi-Sharib. A nice classical music piece, which will hopefully do some good for the film, Kanha makes sure that it's not just the classical music lovers who enjoy it.

The closing track of the album is an instrumental track, The Spirit of Veer, which is the theme of the film. It is somewhat average and it leaves one wondering why it isn't as dramatic as the film's story goes.

In short, it is a refreshing change to see Sajid-Wajid shift from their usual style of music and try something new. Gulzar's lyrics also do wonders. The album would probably get noticed a lot more if the film does well. As of now, all we can say is it's good for a try. But if you're looking for chartbusters, this might not be your cup of tea.

-Preity Punjabi/ Real Bollywood

https://www.realbollywood.com/news/2009/12/music-salman-khans-veer-disappoints.html
Edited by Human_Torch - 16 years ago
135923 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
🤣 Competition of finding good reviews and bad reviews.. between Aladin and Varun ji.. 😆 Till now Aladinji is wayyy ahed.. with the positive reviews.. come on Varun ji.. buck up..

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche · 1 months ago

https://x.com/filmfare/status/2009304013976842365?s=20

https://x.com/filmfare/status/2009304013976842365
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Sparkle_Soul · 2 months ago

https://x.com/alreadysad__/status/2005201545684771216 https://x.com/amanprabhat9/status/2005196199599771658...

https://x.com/alreadysad__/status/2005201545684771216
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 7 months ago

...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 2 months ago

https://x.com/i/status/2004772863405162568

https://x.com/i/status/2004772863405162568
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 3 months ago

21 years of Veer Zaara I loved this movie all 3 main leads and the music https://x.com/aavishhkar/status/1988582449782349830?s=46...

https://x.com/aavishhkar/status/1988582449782349830?s=46
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".