whats wrong with taran adarsh?

Originally posted by: RiyaK09

He's a trade analyst, not a critic. He critiques a movie based on how it might do at the BO. He gives all these masala flicks 4 stars just cuz they have better chances of doing well at the BO compared to some intelligent films. He has given all Vishal Bhardwaj movies like 2 or 1.5 stars, except Kaminey. I think he gave Kaminey 3.5 stars (lowest rating given by any critic for Kaminey) because he wasnt sure how it will do at the BO. He said that its a very well made film, but people might not accept it. So there ya go, he's just a trade analyst.

Originally posted by: Terenaina

I don't like him. He's very bias.

He gave low rating to a masterpiece movie like Lagaan. But I wanted to see he's face when he found that the movie is a big hit and everyone loved it...hehehe

Originally posted by: stewiefreak

he gave kaminey 4 out of 5 stars

and he is not only a trade analyst but also a film critic

Well he says that he's a film critic, but he's actually a trade analyst who is just writing his opinion about the movie.

Ok this is weird. Does he edit his reviews after the movie does well? I always though he gave Kaminey 3.5 stars.😕😆

He is a trade analyst so I sometimes see the point of his ratings. But sometimes, he just comes across as a hypocrite. He gave Dev D 1 star and criticized it to no end.