Weak spots in Ladies Special

rainabow thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
I want to preface this post by saying I thoroughly enjoy LS and find the story much more interesting and compelling than the usual nonsense I see in most serials, but there have been a couple of unsatisfying resolutions I want to discuss:

1) Geeti's trial outcome. This was a disappointment. Here was a perfect opportunity to showcase the cleverness, determination, and tenacity of a mother and father, but instead it ended with an act of mercy from Jassi's dad. Realistically, even after seeing the tape, it is unlikely that a man like him would do that. And what are we, the viewers, supposed to take away from this? That we should simply hope for mercy when faced with our enemies? I don't like it when stories drag unnecessarily, but I would have preferred this track to be stretched out a little bit more if it meant that there would be a more fulfilling ending. There was obvious evidence that Geeti had been assaulted. She had marks on her body indicative of a struggle. She was drugged. Even if she did kill Jassi, wouldn't it be an obvious act of self defense? Several of her friends knew what a dirtbag Jassi was. There were a lot of witnesses who saw him grabbing her arm and physically dominating her at school. It should have been a fairly straightforward case.

2) Pooja and Kamini's track. Again, I would have preferred this to be sorted by Pooja and perhaps the other LS mainstays rather than introducing this angel of mercy at the last minute. I'm not sure if they even mentioned how she knew about Karan-Pooja's troubles? I assume Pooja's mom told her. But even so, how did she know Karan would take an interest in her? Don't get me wrong, I like Kamini's character, but I found her introduction a little sloppy and again, unsatisfying. What would Pooja have done without her? Is the implication that she would have been helpless? Overall, the Karan-Pooja track is just getting sloppier and sloppier. There are so many ways in which Pooja can come down on Karan, legally speaking. As Koolsadhu mentioned in the other post, her entire office is a witness to his blackmailing and taunting! Not to mention Kamini can testify that he is a philanderer. Why stretch this out unecessarily? While Geeti's track was cut short, this one is growing too long.

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

909

Users

4

Likes

9

Frequent Posters

TheRager thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#2

-i think one of the weakest spots is that the characters thru situations are not well defined. like we know that 4/5 women are nice ppl...but what abt their indivdual traits? well defined characterization helps viewers connect with the show. i think of all characters karan's is prolly the most well defined. also a little background on the characters would help...for instance something abt shubha's maika or bably's maika or karan's family...im not saying we need more characters but we need to know what makes these ppl tick.

-another point is they leave many things unsaid...viewers need to assume it. for instance pooja went to the police after she realized he was the cause of the breakup of her sister's alliance. but then they later have her sister getting married. what happenned in between was not clear. then vasu and trisha couldnt see eye to eye before. what is the dynamics in their realtionship now?
-then i agree with the rest that that geeti's track ended unconvcingingly. i wud have preferred an ongoing court battle going parallel with pooja's track. or atleast a proper court battle where the case is won due to pathare's cross questioning the fake witnesses. jassi's father knew what jassi was up to...so he having a sudden change of heart after seeing tape was not convincing.
-i also agree with isha...we dont see much of babli's family life...but from the preview it looks like the creatives are rectifying that...
-pooja-kamini track also i agree was weak. it was built on the assumption that karan was we so attracted to her that he would sign away the bunglow to bed her. but what was the guarantee that he would get attracted to her in the first place? and then a wily guy like karan was conned too easily. but then karan conned pooja so i guess its fitting that he got conned too. but i wud prefer if pooja would have conned him in some other way.
-i also feel that they delayed pooja's track with vinny a lot. vinny shld have stepped into pooja's life earlier..maybe as soon as she returned to mumbai. i dont understand what was the reason for the delay.
Edited by kshreya2002 - 15 years ago
lovely_lady thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
very well said..
i had a few complaints about this show too..
1. as you said, the Geeti case. i really hoped to see an actual batte between Nanda and Jassi;s dad. like you mentioned before, i wanted to see how far nanda and shivam would go for there child. but truthfully, all i saw was how helpless they felt. i felt that the whole trial was rushed. it was as if the creatives didnt want to dive into the details of the case. as you pointed out, there were many evidences that showed that Geeti had been assulted. yet, the judge did not even consider this piece of info. i atleast wanted to see how the judge would react to when he found out Geeti acted in self defense. doesnt a person get money or something?
2. the kamini case was also a enigma. first of all, in the beginning of the show, it was shown that karan would never chase after a girl. however, after he saw kamini, he goes after her? no offense or anything, but she;s not extraordinarily pretty either. so im really confused to as how pooja knew karan would be infatuated with kamini. and after the whole kamini cover was blown, i expected pooja to get a divorce from karan. however, the creatives continue on the drag their story.
3. babli is also a main lead of the show. well, thats what we were told. however, we have gotten no big storyline on her. the only story we got on her was for her car. and that story only lasted a week or two. all we see of babli is how she helps the other ladies. why dont we see any of her daily life?
anyways, i dont want to offend anyone or anything..but this show has some pretty big flaws. however, its okay i guess cause then again, no other show has tackled issues like this one either.. am i not right?
sunaina02 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
The show of course has flaws and somehow seem to in a hurry. But we must say that the actors are really great !!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".