SaReGaMaPa Drama

Hello All

I am one of those people who love good music and love to see really good talent get what they actually deserve. SaReGaMaPa has always been one of my favourite shows because it is very real and mature.But I am utterly shocked about the new developments in the show and am very sorry to say that I am extremely disappointed in the actions of the last three participants.

Right from the begining they said that " It will be Janata's verdict which will select the winner". First of all - in the shows like this - you should not let the Janata decide....there should be a panel of learned judges who really know what is music ( Certanly not people like Daler Mehandi ) . But if you have decided that you will let the Janata vote - then please accept what the Janata is saying -- wheather it is wrong or right !!! All four of them are exteremly talented very very good singers. Things would have been all OK if our dear Magical Mentors would not behave childishly !! All know that one person has to be selected in the end and all know that the public would decide that ....then why do the drama of walking out ....... this shows that how immature they are.... If you want to make Nihira or any other person of your liking a star - then do it - who is stopping you !! but walking out like that is absolutely rediculous on their part. Then what got into those three participants ? this is not right.... ' Khel ko khel kee bhawana sey khelo" - thats what we all learn..... If these so called Magical Mentors are going to behave like this....then what will the kids learn ? I think the whole blame should go to Ismail Darbar - for his immature behaviour....that this drama happened....

The walkout by the last 3 should have been enforced. If I was the decision maker, I would have asked for an explanation and then declared Debojit the winner by default since the walkout constitutes the contest is over. This was all master minded by HR since he wore the cap that fits it.. he argued with Hem's mom about why she accused him... Hem must have told his mom who was behind the walkout.. so truth hurts.. The fact that they waited until Debojit got the highest vote implies fould play. They should have walked out as soon as the welcome song was sung and before they announced the result. Then, it would have made sense. So, Gajendra Singh could have pulled a master stroke and ended the contest on Mondya night itself. Thats how it is done every where else when you walk out. You walk out of your job, you get fired.. u walk out of a tennis match, your opponent is awarded the match.. Bishen Bedi walked India out in West Indies few years back, WI won the test match.. Thanks.

Originally posted by: neenam

Hello All

I am one of those people who love good music and love to see really good talent get what they actually deserve. SaReGaMaPa has always been one of my favourite shows because it is very real and mature.But I am utterly shocked about the new developments in the show and am very sorry to say that I am extremely disappointed in the actions of the last three participants.

Right from the begining they said that " It will be Janata's verdict which will select the winner". First of all - in the shows like this - you should not let the Janata decide....there should be a panel of learned judges who really know what is music ( Certanly not people like Daler Mehandi ) . But if you have decided that you will let the Janata vote - then please accept what the Janata is saying -- wheather it is wrong or right !!! All four of them are exteremly talented very very good singers. Things would have been all OK if our dear Magical Mentors would not behave childishly !! All know that one person has to be selected in the end and all know that the public would decide that ....then why do the drama of walking out ....... this shows that how immature they are.... If you want to make Nihira or any other person of your liking a star - then do it - who is stopping you !! but walking out like that is absolutely rediculous on their part. Then what got into those three participants ? this is not right.... ' Khel ko khel kee bhawana sey khelo" - thats what we all learn..... If these so called Magical Mentors are going to behave like this....then what will the kids learn ? I think the whole blame should go to Ismail Darbar - for his immature behaviour....that this drama happened....

I agree with most of the thing you mentioned. Except for the fact the ID is to be blamed. A clarification: ID did not walk out because of public's decision. He walked out cuz of the lousy scores the other two gave to Debo.