Firing Employees (layoffs)

Posted: 17 years ago
#1

Hi all,

Just thought I would try a interesting debate. Most of us are in college or work in the real world so it should be interesting. I will state my views after...

(scenario: bad economy, low demand for goods)...

1. Do you think employers have the right to lay-off employees at their will?

2. Who is to blame in these situations?

3. Do you think laying off based on pay, age or working class is reasonable?

Hint: the law is not on the side of the employees as it is on the employer... yes its true..Too many loop holes..😭

(sorry if this was disused, thought it was a nice 1)..

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

583

Users

5

Frequent Posters

apux thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: AsliiGuy

Hi all,

Just thought I would try a interesting debate. Most of us are in college or work in the real world so it should be interesting. I will state my views after...

(scenario: bad economy, low demand for goods)...

1. Do you think employers have the right to lay-off employees at their will? Well yeah, if they don't have the money to pay their employees, how can they keep the employees!

2. Who is to blame in these situations? Could be many factors. The economy, how they run the company and finances, or employees not performing as efficiently as they can...

3. Do you think laying off based on pay, age or working class is reasonable? I don't think you can lay-off anyone based on working class/age. I don't think employers are allowed to discriminate based on things like that (but of course they do). Currently I think employers look at where their company would least suffer without the employees, and cuts are made there.

Hint: the law is not on the side of the employees as it is on the employer... yes its true..Too many loop holes..😭

(sorry if this was disused, thought it was a nice 1)..



The economy in America is really sucking at the moment. So many people are laid off. I think like 3 million jobs were lost last year.
Posted: 17 years ago
#3

1. Do you think employers have the right to lay-off employees at their will?

Yes, if there was a part of the body that was hurting the rest (i.e. a bad department) its best ot get rid of that part so the whole body (company) could survivie.
2. Who is to blame in these situations?
I partly blame the CEO's. They can forsee this information from miles away, and they can adapt to these events. Also the economy does not help, which in some cases can be a lack of demand.

3. Do you think laying off based on pay, age or working class is reasonable?

I think its normal, but it shouldnt be done without business justificaiton from a managerial pt of view, but it happens all the time! Some people do it openly, they say, "because you are old, I will give you a retirement package and you must quit"...Some ppl do it behind cosed doors, "i.e. this work group will allow us to save X amt of dollars, lets cut them"...etc..
I think the worse is letting older ppl go, its hard to get another job, plus your so close to retirement...
return_to_hades thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: AsliiGuy

Hi all,

Just thought I would try a interesting debate. Most of us are in college or work in the real world so it should be interesting. I will state my views after...

(scenario: bad economy, low demand for goods)...

1. Do you think employers have the right to lay-off employees at their will?

It is called at will employment. Companies need to be able to do so. It is the difference between profit and loss.

2. Who is to blame in these situations?

It is hard to put the blame squarely on anyone, especially in economic times. Sometimes it is poor management decisions, poor sales & marketing, poor strategy, sometimes it is ill luck. Sometimes it is excessive demands on behalf of employees and customers.

3. Do you think laying off based on pay, age or working class is reasonable?

The layoff should be based on whatever the company feels reasonable. If a division is not performing well, if a branch is not performing well those issues will be targeted. Sometimes the company just needs to shed excess weight to be lean mean and competitive. If a pay band is not worth its paycheck, chop them. If a group is not dynamic with times chop them. If a blue collar factory is too demanding and they can be easily replaced chop them.

Hint: the law is not on the side of the employees as it is on the employer... yes its true..Too many loop holes..😭

I think the law is quite fair enough at least in United States. Based on their size employers are supposed to give 30 to 90 days notice. Usually at least a two week severance is required. Also the company pays unemployment benefits too.

Last year I was laid off by a big telecommunications company. We received 90 days notice + a month severance. Since they closed us before end of ninety days we got paid for not working. Before closing down they gave us resume training, interview training and held job fairs. They even let us sign up for tuition reimbursement (I signed up for way more courses than I can handle). I found an equitable paying job albeit in a different field even before the 90 days was up.

So in my opinion those who complain about layoffs are those at the bottom of the food chain, and they choose to be there.

(sorry if this was disused, thought it was a nice 1)..



Jeez after all that would you believe that I am a bleeding heart liberal?
raj5000 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: AsliiGuy

Hi all,

Just thought I would try a interesting debate. Most of us are in college or work in the real world so it should be interesting. I will state my views after...

(scenario: bad economy, low demand for goods)...

1. Do you think employers have the right to lay-off employees at their will?

If not voilating any contract then why not? Also if then can sustain and be profitable without them then why hire in first place.
2. Who is to blame in these situations?
Whole company, specially the think tanks and risk management employees.

3. Do you think laying off based on pay, age or working class is reasonable?

Yes, whatever it takes to get back in business.

Hint: the law is not on the side of the employees as it is on the employer... yes its true..Too many loop holes..😭

(sorry if this was disused, thought it was a nice 1)..

qwertyesque thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: AsliiGuy

Hi all,

Just thought I would try a interesting debate. Most of us are in college or work in the real world so it should be interesting. I will state my views after...

(scenario: bad economy, low demand for goods)...

1. Do you think employers have the right to lay-off employees at their will?

Ok since you are in college learn the lesson.. be in could books of the boss who precolates that good will upwards and you will never be laid off...Layoffs are a nice way of saying "you are useless, now get teh f*ck out of here"😆

2. Who is to blame in these situations? yourself... dont piss off your boss and more importantly stay behind him and around... as long as he protects you... no tornado can lay you off your cube/office etc..😆

3. Do you think laying off based on pay, age or working class is reasonable?No.. but thats capitalism... u need to keep running to survive.. you want a free lunch after 50 or what?😆

Hint: the law is not on the side of the employees as it is on the employer... yes its true..Too many loop holes..😭 See nothing to do with the law... its human skills... be an apple polisher to your boss and like i sadi earlier i repeat u will never be laid off...

PS: dont forget to offer to get the boss groceries for him once in a while. or pick his kids from teh school etc.. good deeds go a long way. and lay-offs will never occur..😆

(sorry if this was disused, thought it was a nice 1)..

Ok.. just a synopsis on the psychology of layoffs... see except for teh 5% of the companies who layoff for survival reasons... most others take this as a legal opportunity at restructuring.(read, cover up badly run business, eg. GM, ATT, homedepot, for) and to achieve politically motivated objectives..(the war of hatred and favoratism and race for superiority). all departments are sent a list to recommend people to be laid off. from their dept.. when it comes to your boss ensure you are not at the top of his mind......😊 Remember laying off any individual and corelating any event to his dismissal is illogical.. and mostly meaningless
So rollup your sleeves and be the true Asliguy....😊
Edited by qwertyesque - 17 years ago
Posted: 17 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: qwertyesque

Ok.. just a synopsis on the psychology of layoffs... see except for teh 5% of the companies who layoff for survival reasons... most others take this as a legal opportunity at restructuring.(read, cover up badly run business, eg. GM, ATT, homedepot, for) and to achieve politically motivated objectives..(the war of hatred and favoratism and race for superiority). all departments are sent a list to recommend people to be laid off. from their dept.. when it comes to your boss ensure you are not at the top of his mind......😊 Remember laying off any individual and corelating any event to his dismissal is illogical.. and mostly meaningless
So rollup your sleeves and be the true Asliguy....😊



haha you make a valid point!

Layoffs are a great opportunity to restructure for harder waves to come so to say. Sometimes its hard to get rid of the "bad ones" and a good time to do this is with a massive layoff.

I know someone who had to do this for his company, management talked with HR and they advised him to only layoff those with bad records, then bad performances, etc.. It was a criteria based upon reviews....

I like the last sentence..😊

Survival of the fittest these days..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".