A shame ful day for Mumbai police?!! - Page 3

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

ah are this same people who said encounter in delhi was correct just because the person was muslim.... geez this hypocrisy.....

when a person is holding gun and holding someone at gunpoint he is bound to be killed anywhere in the world......

Originally posted by: souro

I don't know exactly which encounter of Delhi you are talking about, but even though I opposed Rahul Raj's act in this thread I'll try to clarify something. If people are saying something against the Mumbai police it's because the initial investigation has revealed that most probably Rahul Raj was shot point blank and most probably it was possible to take him alive. I don't think anyone anywhere ever mentioned anything about his religion or region, it was just that he was a good student with a clean previous record, who lost it in a fit of rage but could've been taken alive, that's all.

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

I dont think we can sitting here on web say that he could have been taken alive... here there were only few policemen and a man with a person at gunpoint..... In jamiyanagar encounter, there was a complete police force who had surrounded the area and noone was at gunpoint.... infact it is in the later case that they could have been disarmed.... however that encounter is not fake because a police office lost his life in there.... here noone lost their life so its fake???? we call amar singh names when he called jamiyanagar encounter as fake but we come forward to blame police officer doing encounter of an armed person here.... do u really think it is possible to know about the history of the person in few minutes when the person is holding someone at gunpoint.... yes he was fired at from inside the bus as the video suggests.... but we have to also consider that he had injured a pessanger.... I believe amarsingh is sick in saying that the jamiyanagar encounter was fake.... but so are the people questioning this encounter.... especially because there was no motive of the encounter....