Twilight Tuesday Aug. 12 . 08 *SPOILER ALERT*

Anon12378 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

'Twilight' Tuesday: Stephenie Meyer Answers Your Burning 'Breaking Dawn' Questions

Author opens up about vampire-human anatomy, torturing her characters and what's next for the Cullens.

No doubt, many devoted Twilighters are already well into their third read of "Breaking Dawn," now that it's been out for a full week and a half. But no matter how many times you delve into the final installment of the "Twilight" series, there are burning questions left to be answered.

Stephenie Meyer couldn't reveal much when we spoke to her before the book's release, so we cornered her one more time and hit her with the queries you submitted in the MTV Movies Blog.

(Just in case you've been locked in a subterranean hideout, far from any bookstores, SPOILER ALERT!)

Though she's been enduring complaints about "Breaking Dawn" from a very vocal minority, the author said she was relieved to be able to talk about the novel after keeping it a secret for so long. Here, she opens up about the technicalities of Bella's pregnancy, the original "Forever Dawn" version of the story, the future of the "Twilight" universe and more.

Question: Bella feels hesitant about marrying Edward. Is that how you felt when you were proposed to? ' KhmaixLinda

Stephenie Meyer: Actually, I was engaged more than once. I had my runaway-bride moment. Maybe there was some of that, although it's really different, because it wasn't the right person [for me] to marry. With Bella, there's no question in her mind that she's going to end up with Edward. It's all about people's perceptions, which is a really silly thing for her to worry about. ... I knew she was going to be with Edward. I wrote this story before I wrote "New Moon" and "Eclipse," and that relationship [with Jacob] actually went a lot farther than I thought it would.

Question: How was Bella's pregnancy possible? ' Deep

Meyer: One of the longest things about this last year is that I've been reading all these quotes that people have been attributing to me that I never said. I had a rough draft of [this story] by the beginning of 2004, so before I ever did a tour or answered any questions or did an interview, I knew where the story was going. ... When people said, "Hey, can vampires have babies?" I always said no, because female vampires don't change at all, and it takes a lot of change for your body to accommodate a fetus, so it's not possible. But I never said anything about the part that I knew was coming. ... It is true ... there's a whole chromosomal-count difference, but venom works a lot of different ways, so for me, it always worked just fine.

Question: Why did you decide to switch to Jacob's point of view during Bella's pregnancy and delivery, instead of Bella telling us herself? ' Sam

Meyer: In the first rough draft, it was Bella throughout the entire story. There's this section of the story where Bella's pretty much stuck on a couch and is not part of anything that's going on, and she's just hearing about it from the outside, and it's boring! ... So when I went back to do this, I realized that where the action was, was something we can only get through the first-person perspective of Jacob. And once I made that decision, I was really glad I had, because that was the most fun section to write out of the whole story.

Question: Why did you portray pregnancy in the light you did? Was there a meaning behind that, or did you do it for storytelling's sake? ' Chrissy

Meyer: A story has to have an element of danger and hazard. If there isn't a risk, if there isn't something that goes wrong, there's no story. But no, the pregnancy wasn't a punishment. When you're writing characters, one of the things you do to make it interesting is you push them past their limits, and that's when the story gets exciting. Sadly, it's kind of fun to torture your characters.

Question: Why was Bella so controlled as a newborn? ' Natasha

Meyer: Bella's really the only vampire who went into it knowing what to expect, being mentally prepared and on guard for her reactions. And she's a naturally stubborn person, which helps when you make up your mind to do something.

Question: You said once you read "Breaking Dawn," you'll understand the cover of the book. So does it represent Bella and Nessie? ' Chrissy

Meyer: No, it represents Bella and Bella. ... Bella starts out as the weakest player on the board, and she ends up as the one who decides the outcome of the story. She becomes the most powerful player, and I really liked that metaphor. I liked seeing her evolution in one picture.

Question: Why did you decide not to have a battle scene? The Cullens seemed like they had a good chance of winning, didn't they? ' Butane

Meyer: They had a good chance of holding their own, not winning. There wouldn't have been a lot of people walking away from that. And because I'm kind of a happy-ending girl, I didn't want the "Hamlet" ending, where everyone's dead on the floor, and one person's standing there giving their monologue about what they've learned. I wanted it to be something that could be won, so I set it up to be a mental game.

Question: Are you thinking of writing a novel in Renesmee's perspective when she's older? ' froggyoggy

Meyer: If I were to go ahead with the Cullen universe ' and honestly, I'll do it for myself, whether I publish it or not is questionable at this point ' but the narrators that I would go ahead with ... would be Renesmee and Leah. Leah's the other one whose story doesn't seem resolved to me at this point.

Question: Would you please, please, please tell me who Embry's father is? ' kateurie

Meyer: The problem with that question is ' and this sounds like something crazy people would say ' but I don't know. My characters don't always tell me everything.

Question: If Nessie's not able to have children on her own ...

Meyer: [Interrupts the question.] Here we're going off way into the future. For all intents and purposes, "Breaking Dawn" is the last book. It might easily happen that I quit here. There'd be a lot of good reasons for doing that, so I don't know if we need to get into all the future possibilities and speculations, 'cause I'll just go crazy, and I'm so close already!

Question: Will "Midnight Sun" be all four "Twilight" books told in one? Or will it be the first of several Edward books? ' Ashley

Meyer: Option three ' it will be a standalone retelling of "Twilight." And I've gotten the comments: "Please, please, please, please, please, do all the books." In reality, "New Moon" would be horrible from Edward's perspective. And I really feel like after people have "Midnight Sun," with a very little amount of effort, they'll be able to understand him for all of the books.

Question: Why were the last two pages of "Breaking Dawn" your favorite Edward/Bella moment? ' edwardsheroine

Meyer: This is the moment, after all of these years, that Edward really gets to understand how Bella feels about him, and they're finally, truly seeing eye-to-eye for just that moment. For me, it was like four books of buildup for this moment, and it was great.

* If all you want to do is thank me please you the thank - you button but feel free to discuss your veiws😃*

Edited by .::ANiSHAXx - 17 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1k

Users

10

Likes

4

Frequent Posters

eternal thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
awww thanx for sharing
i loved her answers
but i have to agree there is a chance for her continuation..
leah's story was never resolved....
and she could continue it and make sure whether nessie can have kids or not in the future..
so much that can be continued that was left behind....
sukhi :)
ShadowKisses thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#3

ROFL 😆@ vocal "minority". Obviously, she doesn't know about the Breaking Dawn petition that's going around or the "Don't burn it, Return it" posts about B.D. Delusion and denial. *sighs*

[quote=SMeyer]Question: Would you please, please, please tell me who Embry's father is? ' kateurie

Meyer: The problem with that question is ' and this sounds like something crazy people would say ' but I don't know. My characters don't always tell me everything. [/quote]

*facepalm* She's talking about her characters as if they are real creatures making a decision! Yeah, not crazy at all. This is a really stupid answer. If this is true, then shouldn't the cheques go to Edward Cullen, Isabella Swan and the likes?
*edit*
I love how she interrupted, and sequentially, evaded the comment about Nessie's reproductive capacities xD. Obviously, she hasn't though through that detail - which begs the question what other details doesn't she know about? The audacity of some people to compare her to JKR. If you asked JKR any question about even the most obscure detail about her world, she'd give you at least a paragraph of detailed, rational and thought out explanation. Stephenie doesn't hold a candle to JKR.
According to her, the vampire venom was what impregnated Bella.
[quote=SMeyer]"It is true ... there's a whole chromosomal-count difference, but venom works a lot of different ways, so for me, it always worked just fine. "
[/quote] The fact that she doesn't dwell on the different chromosome count and covers the inconsistencies up with the effects of venom goes to show that she obviously didn't give it enough thought😛. Even if venom acts as sperm (Is that even possible?😕), a banana and an apple can't create a banapple.
P.S. To the posters below, use the thank you button, if you just want to say thanks ;)
Edited by ShadowKisses - 17 years ago
Mini786 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
Interesting, interesting!

Your right, about the whole JKR and Meyers thing, JKR though of every little detail of her world, and Meyers didn't. But that was her c hoice..

I really do hope she publishes Midnigh Sun...Im really looking foward to itt! :]

Thankss
SunriseGreen thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
Thanks Anisha!

I still do not, at all, understand how Edward was able to impregnate Bella. How can a male vampire have a sperm? 😕

@ShadowKisses- I totally agree with you on what you said about people comparing JKR to SM. They are two different authors with two different ways of writing. Just because their success levels compare with each other does not mean they, as authors, can be compared.
Kim_ thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
Thanks Anisha 😳

Originally posted by: ShadowKisses

ROFL 😆@ vocal "minority". Obviously, she doesn't know about the Breaking Dawn petition that's going around or the "Don't burn it, Return it" posts about B.D. Delusion and denial. *sighs*

[quote=SMeyer]Question: Would you please, please, please tell me who Embry's father is? ' kateurie

Meyer: The problem with that question is ' and this sounds like something crazy people would say ' but I don't know. My characters don't always tell me everything. [/quote]

*facepalm* She's talking about her characters as if they are real creatures making a decision! Yeah, not crazy at all. This is a really stupid answer. If this is true, then shouldn't the cheques go to Edward Cullen, Isabella Swan and the likes?
*edit*
I love how she interrupted, and sequentially, evaded the comment about Nessie's reproductive capacities xD. Obviously, she hasn't though through that detail - which begs the question what other details doesn't she know about? The audacity of some people to compare her to JKR. If you asked JKR any question about even the most obscure detail about her world, she'd give you at least a paragraph of detailed, rational and thought out explanation. Stephenie doesn't hold a candle to JKR.
According to her, the vampire venom was what impregnated Bella.
[quote=SMeyer]"It is true ... there's a whole chromosomal-count difference, but venom works a lot of different ways, so for me, it always worked just fine. "
[/quote] The fact that she doesn't dwell on the different chromosome count and covers the inconsistencies up with the effects of venom goes to show that she obviously didn't give it enough thought😛. Even if venom acts as sperm (Is that even possible?😕), a banana and an apple can't create a banapple.
P.S. To the posters below, use the thank you button, if you just want to say thanks ;)

I liked what you've said ShadowKisses, I would wanna know your name, you are a very interesting person, it takes me hard time to write Shadow Kisses 😉
I agree with you at the pregnancy part...
well twilight was the best book she had and I think it was stolen from L Jane Smith's books edward was mixture of Damon and Stefan of vampire diaries which was actully published in 90s and now republished on public demand😳
but BD is only a story of a married woman with a child and edward turned into stephenie meyer's own husband🤢, she just loved sharing her experience of preganancy with her readers but she forgot that her book was suppose to be for teens 😡
I don't agree on bella having a child🤢 and then jacob telling that all that time Bella and Jacob met was because Renesme was going to be born, how come he didn't feel the same lust for Edward Cullen after all he is Renesme's father😛 so it's a big blooper... just an attempt to cover your two timing heroine the critisizm she recieved after the release of Eclipse, well it didn't go too well, and I don't buy it🤢
well, she should know about embry's father if she is writing it, even if she doesn't mention it in the book.
and the minority, if it was minority she wouldn't have been answering the questions she would have just ignored it but obviously it's not minority who's complaining😆
*~Kaynaat~* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
thnx for sharing!
i already posted an article about stephenie meyer saying that breaking dawn should be 2 movies.
i luved the book!
cant wait for Midnight Sun!!!!!!
Asha004 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

Thank U so so so so much!!Was waiting 4 her interview **hugs and kisses**

I'm really disapooointed that Stephenie is being so argghh (meant to be taken lightly...no offense to Stephenie...as I really do respect her as a writer and as a person in general) about not declaring if she has made up her mind 2 continue writing further books in the Twilight series....I really wish she did....that would totally make my life right there🥳

I'm really looking forward 2 Midnight Sun....Edward,Edward,Edward....just can't get enough of his "perfection".....(everyone has their own views of what "perfection" is)....and I agree with Stephenie in that writing the remaining books in Edward's perspective would just be tedious...because we all obviously don't want to see him heartbrokern in NM and she can't skip one whole part of his life (one of the most important moments of this immortal life),and go 2 Eclipse....so writing one book in his perspective will definitely go a long way in that we will better understand how he must have felt in the remaining books😳
SabeenSmiles thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9
Thnx for the article Anisha!!!
I liked Stephenie's answers!!!😊
I sooooooo can't wait till Midnight Sun releases!!!!!!!!!!!😃😳


ShadowKisses thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: SVlover

Thanks Anisha!

I still do not, at all, understand how Edward was able to impregnate Bella. How can a male vampire have a sperm? 😕

@ShadowKisses- I totally agree with you on what you said about people comparing JKR to SM. They are two different authors with two different ways of writing. Just because their success levels compare with each other does not mean they, as authors, can be compared.

From what I gathered from Meyer's interview, the venom - not sperm - in Edward impregnated Bella😕. I've always associated venom with acid and toxins but it seems that in the Twilightverse, venom is a fluid with magical properties >.< David Michelinie must be howling with laughter.
By the way, your Aamir icon is totally adorable xD.

Originally posted by: Kim_

I liked what you've said ShadowKisses, I would wanna know your name, you are a very interesting person, it takes me hard time to write Shadow Kisses 😉
I agree with you at the pregnancy part...
well twilight was the best book she had and I think it was stolen from L Jane Smith's books edward was mixture of Damon and Stefan of vampire diaries which was actully published in 90s and now republished on public demand😳
but BD is only a story of a married woman with a child and edward turned into stephenie meyer's own husband🤢, she just loved sharing her experience of preganancy with her readers but she forgot that her book was suppose to be for teens 😡
I don't agree on bella having a child🤢 and then jacob telling that all that time Bella and Jacob met was because Renesme was going to be born, how come he didn't feel the same lust for Edward Cullen after all he is Renesme's father😛 so it's a big blooper... just an attempt to cover your two timing heroine the critisizm she recieved after the release of Eclipse, well it didn't go too well, and I don't buy it🤢
well, she should know about embry's father if she is writing it, even if she doesn't mention it in the book.
and the minority, if it was minority she wouldn't have been answering the questions she would have just ignored it but obviously it's not minority who's complaining😆

Ah, it's Anu ;) Really short compared to the username xD.
I haven't read Vampire diaries but it sounds really interesting. I'll make sure to get a copy on my next trip to the book store. Have you read Vampire Chronicles by Anne Rice? They're really good ;) I don't think Twilight is, per say, stolen but more like a wishfulfilment book the author whipped up in 20 minutes. I've heard some girls crossed out Bella's name in Twilight and replaced it with their name just so they could fantasize properly which gives further evidence that Twilight is really meant as a wishfulfilment book. Furthermore, the fact that Bella's appearance is never fully explained "to make it easier for girls to step into [her] shoes" goes to add as more proof.
I think Edward is the opposite of what Meyer's husband is :P It's just a theory since I'm not a psychologist but I really think that Edward epitomizes what Meyer wishes her husband would be. I think they call it repressed dreams or something. Not sure. But most definitely, Meyer has inserted parts of herself into Bella and what she wishes was an ideal man in Edward. She made the biggest mistake a newbie author makes. She let her Ego get the best of her and therefore, heavily inserted parts of herself in the text. Ever wondered how close to home her description of Bella is?
[quote=SM Website]Bella is very fair-skinned, with long, straight, dark brown hair and chocolate brown eyes. Her face is heart-shaped?a wide forehead with a widow's peak, large, wide-spaced eyes, prominent cheekbones, and then a thin nose and a narrow jaw with a pointed chin. Her lips are a little out of proportion, a bit too full for her jaw line. Her eyebrows are darker than her hair and more straight than they are arched. She's five foot four inches tall, slender but not at all muscular, and weighs about 115 pounds. She has stubby fingernails because she has a nervous habit of biting them. And there's your very detailed description.
At first glance, it may not seem like much but this description can be applied to Stephenie Meyer's own appearance. Meyer has a striking resemblance to Bella which solidifies as self-insertion.

I loathe the idea of Jacob and Reneesme. It's very pedophilic. Thought we had enough of it with Quil and Claire. 🤢
I agree that she should know who Embry's father is. It's slightly crazy to say her characters keep secrets from her. Makes me question her sanity. It's not a matter of choice. If you created him, you - if not your readers - should know his origins. It would take 15-30 minutes to come up with a name and incorporate that in the plot.
It's not just people who disliked Twilight. Some of the ex-Twilighters were really disappointed by the ending =( Don't burn it, return it ;) I already returned my copy and got a book by Charlotte Bronte instead.
Edited by ShadowKisses - 17 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".