Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 41 - Page 61

They’re probably heading down the route of DK & Mannat wedding. As per spoilers, Mannat & DK win the court case where Mannat will recount all that happened on the day of ManVik wedding and judge will obviously side with her and the fact that she isn’t married to DK

Apparently the judge also asks Mannat who’d she like to stay with and she chooses DK. I feel while she isn’t in love with him, in order to cement DK’s position as Dua’s dad she and avoid further such shenanigans by Neetu/Vik she might go ahead and decide to marry DK and even Ronnie will be in support of it! He as is wants Mannat to move on, who better than DK!

Yes , I am questioning the biased writing to ww fl though they haven't learnt anything from last mistakes. Mannat continues to repeat the same mistakes now with much more confidence than pre-leap.

Pre-leap she was scared of lying, now she questions Neetu why she didn't continue the lie per the promise she made. Infact she didn't even reveal she believed she told Vikrant about Dua and he rejected her. She let him believe he didn't let her speak and it was all his fault. This is blatant biased writing to WW fl (unless there is a BTS where she does tell him what she actually thought)

Going back out original discussion, let's see if Mannat likes Neetu taking decisions on her behalf for the benefit of DuVik and if she infact holds her end of the deal which she told Vikrant, she will reveal it to Dua calmly or will she get EB again into silence and leaving to Indore.

I am also predicting and writing things that hopefully makers will use, to make sense.

Because nothing they write makes sense. I am thinking that they might compromise mannat too...

Why no one is clarifying me after so many times of asking what DK and mannat spoke about DK's future? Did they talk about it or no? Do you all think it is OK to not discuss about his future? If that is ok then I have nothing to say. Mannat and Vik can become one and ditch DK. Anyways, he will be made worthy of such ditching soon by makers. But what do you think they should both (mannat and vik)do tomorrow? I am just sharing my opinion on that.

Originally posted by: shiro_shinchan

They’re probably heading down the route of DK & Mannat wedding. As per spoilers, Mannat & DK win the court case where Mannat will recount all that happened on the day of ManVik wedding and judge will obviously side with her and the fact that she isn’t married to DK

Apparently the judge also asks Mannat who’d she like to stay with and she chooses DK. I feel while she isn’t in love with him, in order to cement DK’s position as Dua’s dad she and avoid further such shenanigans by Neetu/Vik she might go ahead and decide to marry DK and even Ronnie will be in support of it! He as is wants Mannat to move on, who better than DK!

This seems perfect, realistic. DK will then realize Mannat cannot move on and they divorce. By that time Vik will become a person who earns both Mannat and dua's shared custody.

Originally posted by: Moor278

But then you are questioning the characterization of every character... because each one of them has lied and hidden stuff from one another!!!!

There is not one person who is doodh ka dhula in this entire story!!!!

Not even the so called positive ones like Shruti Maa ... so whats the point going over it again and again???

Because you are never going to be satisfied if thats the idea.

This is where you confuse me moory. You say no one is dhudh ka dhula. But when I say mannat has her own setbacks, you will not agree with me and say morally she is right. I really dont understand.. Main thing being NOT asking DK to find a family.

IT is not right to live with a person like that without bothering about his future...while she anticipates to forgive Vik on one sorry and move with him(I have heard more than 2 monologues of hers where she says she is waiting for just one sorry). Did she think or ask DK what are his future plans. She is sharing her kid with him, who is attached to him. it is a big deal

Originally posted by: sadiltl

I said based on BTS, i have written. Neetu is sick? even dua's secret is revealed, she should not stay. I am just forcasting, predicting based on BTS. not saying it will happen.

Clarify to Dk there is no future with her, go and marry someone and share dua with her. I mean you cant play house house with him all the time right. It is not about woman or man, it is about basic responsibility. I am not sure if they had this conversation. if they had already, i will take back my words. If they didnt, they should

If she loves vik, then let her love for life. Not going to say anything. Do whatever is right for dua.

Thats what I said otherwise. Resolve everything and go. She can even go to vik, but resolve it all.... it is not easy and she should TAKE steps towards the right. She should show the desperation to leave mumbai. Thats all i am saying. Court case is BS. with what confidence Vik is putting it I dont know. but thats the level of the writers. they can make it all legal.

I am not saying this is happening. To me she looks confused.

Neetu is not sick. She did not take medicines so she could fall ill and delay their departure.

Mannat doesnt know Neetus plan of staying back in Mumbai.

Bold ... they have not had this exact conversation or say explicitly they have said this ... but its assumed DK Mannat are in status quo neither of them mind being fake husband wife .. thats why few episodes back Ronnie suggested Mannat to move on in her life.

Blue... ab Vik ke saath kya resolve karna hai? She wasnt planning to reveal it to him... she was going away... and she has accepted Vik is going to marry Y... phir apna love confession karke kyun use pareshan kare??? She heard him say to Y that he wants to move on.

Originally posted by: Moor278

I have a different take on this and thats why I was looking forward for Duas truth...

This is ITV.. so she will find out too ... afterall drama jo chalana hai...

And thats where Indore gang will realize how it impacts the person whose identity is doubtful. They havent thought of it because what they wanted to show was proven right...

And they are repeating the same mistake with Dua... even if its for her benefit... I agree with Neetu only for this bit...

For them to understand what Vik went through they need to see it through Dua.

I didn't see this post earlier ❤️ this is exactly what I wish to see.

Originally posted by: Moor278

Neetu is not sick. She did not take medicines so she could fall ill and delay their departure.

Mannat doesnt know Neetus plan of staying back in Mumbai.

Bold ... they have not had this exact conversation or say explicitly they have said this ... but its assumed DK Mannat are in status quo neither of them mind being fake husband wife .. thats why few episodes back Ronnie suggested Mannat to move on in her life.

Blue... ab Vik ke saath kya resolve karna hai? She wasnt planning to reveal it to him... she was going away... and she has accepted Vik is going to marry Y... phir apna love confession karke kyun use pareshan kare??? She heard him say to Y that he wants to move on.

bold. then why the monologues of her wanting to get back to him on single sorry. I have heard it multiple times. I am just saying writers are confused and making her look confused. If they want to take that route, it is okay, get audience convinced because it is morally not the right decision. If they can convince us, then well and good

Originally posted by: sadiltl

@bold because they are useless. DK is being butchered too.

Morality is expected from Mannat not because she is woman, she is the only one who is raised well. And only one writers are little consistent.

Morality cannot be expected from anyone just bcz their character has been written somewhat okay or raised well..also there is no guarantee 100 percent that people who are raised well are going to be nice, full of morals in the future...thats setting unrealistic expectations..

Also majority of us have agreed here that none of the actions of the character are 100 percent positive, all have grey shades including Mannat so there is really no point in setting any expectations..

Also to add, just bcs we individually feel that what person A or person B did is wrong doesn’t automatically translate as wrong...from situation point of view if that character feels he/she did right then they will proceed accordingly...

Originally posted by: sadiltl

This is where you confuse me moory. You say no one is dhudh ka dhula. But when I say mannat has her own setbacks, you will not agree with me and say morally she is right. I really dont understand.. Main thing being NOT asking DK to find a family.

IT is not right to live with a person like that without bothering about his future...while she anticipates to forgive Vik on one sorry and move with him(I have heard more than 2 monologues of hers where she says she is waiting for just one sorry). Did she think or ask DK what are his future plans. She is sharing her kid with him, who is attached to him. it is a big deal

You didn't get me when I said doodh ka dhula... each character has lied at some point not just Mannat... even Vik has.. maine sirf uss reason se bola...

This is in context of mannat hiding Aman truth from Vik... she was ready to tell him, was pleading with RoTu to reveal it to him till they find out Vish was even worse and Neetu silenced her with suicide threat.

I see it as Mannat protecting Vik because of her own experience with her birth trauma RD sees it as lying. We have been disagreeing over this since months now.

Its a morally debatable question whether to hide such a shocking truth from your partner. And there are 2 clear teams in FD over this.

Now the question about DK is... they ... meaning Mannat Ronnie and DK have mutually agreed to pretend to be Duas parents... and DK Mannat are not revealing it to anybody. Neetu knows but hasnt said anything to Vik either.

Ronnie knows Mannat is holding on to Vik... but after he sees Vik about to marry Y, he has asked Mannat to move on in her life too... hinted as DK...

DK wonders whats Mannats answer gonna be... so its a clear hint he wants a future with her. Not just Dua. But he hasnt voiced it to Mannat yet. As per her he is good friend who has consented for this pretense.

Mannat hasnt thought on that suggestion from Ronnie, though she is keeping distance from Vik. Neither is she able to move on from Vik. She still loves Vik which DK knows too... yet he waits for an answer from her.

Yahi Mona was telling you... why his motives are not pure as they were early in the leap.

The VOs are her thoughts... but she is not acting on it.

As of today, there are no plans of getting back with Vik. Even in the bts she is asking Vik to not reveal it to Dua and he agrees ki soch samjh ke karenge kuch bhi.