So our discussion in the forum edt last night,where we discussed multiple theories and probability... wildest imaginations knew no bounds ...and I couldn't help but write it...My first writing on our dearest Prashiv ❤️
It was written over night...I know how imperfect it probably is...yet I hope it is enough to atleast touch you at some place in your heart and make you connect with the Prarthana and Shivansh you all know and love
Also it's an exclusive Shivansh-prarthana ff...I have assumed that no other character exists apart from them .🤣.so please bear with that kindly....🙏🤗
Part 1
“Tell Me You’re Mine” – A Shivansh-Prarthana Story 🖤
The night was heavy. Not with rain or thunder—but with something far more unbearable: silence.
Not the kind that comforts. The kind that lingers between two people who should be speaking, but are drowning instead in everything unsaid.
Prarthana stood by the window of their room, the moonlight kissing the curve of her face. She looked ethereal, unreachable—like a memory slipping through fingers. She remembered her previous encounter with Raunak in his house...his crazy behaviour.. showering her with flowers.. forcing himself on her,then stopping her with yet another bouquet of apology and charm...and not to forget creepy way in which he keeps declaring his love for her even after her repeatedly saying that she is only Shivansh's
She hadn’t done anything wrong. But Shivansh had watched all of it.He had always watched. Every movement, every glance, every politeness she offered as a respectful response to Raunak—and each one felt like a dagger he had no right to name.
He sat in the shadows, his knuckles white around the crystal tumbler in his hand. The liquor burned down his throat, but not half as much as the fire in his chest.
It wasn’t anger.
It was fear, dressed up in fury.
It was love, starved of words.
It was the ache of a boy who had once begged to be chosen and never was.
“Don’t do this,” she said softly, sensing the shift in the air, her voice more plea than reproach.
“Do what?” he asked, voice low, brittle.
“This,” she turned to face him now. “Building walls because you’re afraid I’ll walk out the door.”
Shivansh laughed—a hollow, bitter sound that didn’t reach his eyes.
“Why wouldn’t you?” he said. “It’s what people do. They leave.”
Her breath caught. There it was. The wound. Bleeding. Open. As raw as the day his mother left him behind without a glance. As raw as his father’s cold indifference. As raw as every time he watched someone love someone else while he stood, invisible, in the background.
“You think I would?” she whispered. “After everything?”
Shivansh stood up, the glass abandoned on the table like a ghost of his restraint. He took two steps toward her—then stopped, as if afraid to cross a line.
“I saw the way he looked at you,” he said, his voice trembling under the weight of jealousy he had tried so hard to bury. “And you… you smiled. You always smile at him.”
Prarthana was shocked...not understanding what he is talking about..but however she composed herself..
“I smile at everyone, Shivansh.”
“But not like that.”
“What do you mean?”
“Like you’ve never been hurt.”
The words slipped out before he could stop them. And now they hung between them, brutal and honest.
Prarthana’s eyes glistened, not with anger—but with a sorrow so deep, it threatened to pull them both under.
“Do you know why I smile like that?” she asked, stepping closer now. “Because when I’m with you, I feel everything. The ache, the anger, the love, the fire. But with him… there’s nothing. Nothing at all. That smile? It’s emptiness wearing a mask.”
Shivansh clenched his jaw, looking away. “You deserve more than a man who can’t even trust your smile.”
“No,” she said, gently placing a hand on his chest. “I deserve a man who tells me when he’s hurting.”
His breath hitched. His heart was thundering beneath her palm.
“I hate how he looks at you,” Shivansh confessed, voice barely a whisper. “Not because I think you’ll leave me for him. But because it reminds me of every time I wasn’t enough for someone I loved. Every time I was replaced. Forgotten.”
Her eyes softened.
“And yet you forget,” she whispered, “that I chose you… in every way someone can be chosen. Not by fate. Not by force. But by faith. I walk toward you every single day. Don’t make me beg you to see that.”
Something inside him broke then. The armor. The pride. The carefully constructed illusion that he didn’t care.
He wrapped his arms around her as if anchoring himself to the only truth he had ever known—her. His lips pressed into her hair, his breath ragged.
“I don’t know how to love without breaking things,” he murmured. “I don’t know how to not be afraid.”
Prarthana tilted her face up, her hands cradling his jaw with a tenderness that undid him completely.
“Then break,” she whispered. “Break, Shivansh. And I’ll hold the pieces. All of them. Just… don’t push me away when all I want is to stay.”
And there, in the quiet embrace of midnight, two wounded hearts found a rhythm again. Jealousy hadn’t ruined them. It had revealed them. Unmasked their fears. Stripped their souls bare.
Because sometimes, love isn’t a confession.
It’s not a vow or a kiss under stars.
Sometimes, love is just saying:
“Tell me you’re mine… and I’ll believe you. Even when I don’t believe in myself.”
And that was the kind of love Shivansh and Prarthana had.
Not perfect.
But real.
Fiercely, irrevocably real....
23