Khuda ke liye: funds. vs.liberal muslimz

Daisy!! thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

what are your personal views on the movie "khuda ke liye"..it shows the comparison between the liberalz and fundamentalists muslims...
Religioun is suppose to comfort people, and Islam religion is not at all that strict, the way those "extremists" make it,,we need to follw our religion beliefs in the modern world,based on the modern circumstances...
do u think, the mullaz in khuda ke liye, were doing the right thing??if NO then WHY are they doing all that??
and y do u think they are turning all the young onez into jihadiz...
and they were persuading them to pick up the gunz and establishing the guts in them to murder human-beings...but nowhere in Koran allows a muslim man to kill another muslim/human being..
guyz do share ur views
thanks
Daisy!!
Edited by Daisy!! - 17 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.1k

Users

8

Frequent Posters

amo_amo_aigoo thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
is tht a new movie. neva heard of it.
Daisy!! thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
yeah its a new movie..
so even if u havent seen it..wat r ur viewz on fundamentalists religious ppl or extremists???
lakshmim_84 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4
never seen that movie... so can't comment... when was it released?
well abt the mullas making people to go n kill themselves n in this process killing others too.... well, i wld say, the person who listened to mullah n did is is more at fault than the mullah....
i mean, if someone tells u to kill yourself... why wld u just blindly follow that order.. can't u think urself... if what u r doing is right or not...
Edited by lakshmim_84 - 17 years ago
Zoe28 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
i havent yet seen khuda ke liye, hopefully i will see it n dvd soon. ive seen many films and shows on terrorisms and so far the majority have always portrayed islam in a negative light and have basically made the stereotypical thing about islam being violent and promoting terrorism seem true. but after sein britz i was pleased as i think britz showed thetrue state of affairs. it showcased that people become terrorists because of circumastances and that the reason why some muslims become terrorists are because they are mistreated by a socity who blame islam for terrrorism, britz brought many other realities forward and showed the miniority who believe all muslims are terrorists that they were wrong. yes terrorism is wrong and inexcusable but it is totally incorrect to think islam is the cause of terrorism when the muslim people who have become terrorists have done that because of them beign labelled as terrorists and the prejudice they face for being a muslim.
240648 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6

hello daisy!

hmmm......first of great post hun! 😃 saw the movie a few months back.......in my opinion, ofcourse the moulvi was NOT right! how can he teach youngsters to fight and become jihadiz? i think the director has tried to show the point of view of different ppl who belong to the same religious group-Islam. He tried to show a contradiction of how two preachers of the same religion think and preach differently through those two moulvis.........it's a shame that such ppl do exist in our society who turn innocent youngsters into heartless and insensitive beings who hv no feelings left!

tc.

ania 😊

Edited by ania_91 - 17 years ago
Daisy!! thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
thanks for replying guyz
totally agreed with u all

now let me point out another question "Why are the molviz doing this to the younger onez only/??"
wud like to kno ur opinion on dat too plz

well...the reason i think the molviz r brainwashing the younger teenz is, simply because they are still struggling to make sense out of what lay around them....and most of them r disturbed, and pressurized frm their life....so they blindly follow the molviz, thinking that is the right pathh...


Ania,thxx for liking the topic 😊
luvv u
240648 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Daisy!!

thanks for replying guyz
totally agreed with u all

now let me point out another question "Why are the molviz doing this to the younger onez only/??"
wud like to kno ur opinion on dat too plz

well...the reason i think the molviz r brainwashing the younger teenz is, simply because they are still struggling to make sense out of what lay around them....and most of them r disturbed, and pressurized frm their life....so they blindly follow the molviz, thinking that is the right pathh...


Ania,thxx for liking the topic 😊
luvv u

no thanks ms. daisy!!

sooooo.............uhum uhum *clearing throat* *fake cough* i think the youngsters are easily led into such things because they are still young! i know it sounds silly..but just think about it ......specially teens who are not mature and they need guidance and maybe in search of that they get misleaded easily by such groups of ppl! whereas if an adult would be forced or "brainwashed" to do something like that.....they would first think if its right or not from their past experiences of life and knowledge about their religion.....and therefore they mite be able to take a better decision..... so i think it's important to have a better understanding and knowledge of the religion in every individual so they might be able to distinguish b/w the right and wrong path.....and don't get misled so easily like fawad (i think thats the character's real name in the movie) did!!

Edited by ania_91 - 17 years ago
corvette thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Zoe28

i havent yet seen khuda ke liye, hopefully i will see it n dvd

I havent seen it either!😊

soon. ive seen many films and shows on terrorisms and so far the majority have always portrayed islam in a negative light and have basically made the stereotypical thing about islam being violent and promoting terrorism seem true. but after sein britz i was pleased as i think britz showed thetrue state of affairs. it showcased that people become terrorists because of circumastances

This is not a new concept to me - many people become lots of things due to circumstances.....the story of the poor boy who stole to eat bread and was labelled a thief.........guy who in defending himself kills another person being labelled a murderer....all victims of circumstance

and that the reason why some muslims become terrorists are because they are mistreated by a socity who blame islam for terrrorism,

Not a good enough reason I'm afraid to justify terrorism in my eyes.

britz brought many other realities forward and showed the miniority who believe all muslims are terrorists that they were wrong.

You said - the MINORITY! Not the majority at all, yet everyone suffers indiscriminately at the hands of terrorism, minorities, majorities, Muslims and non- muslims

yes terrorism is wrong and inexcusable but it is totally incorrect to think islam is the cause of terrorism when the muslim people who have become terrorists have done that because of them beign labelled as terrorists and the prejudice they face for being a muslim.

Your statement above is, with respect, very jubled and incoherent. If some Muslims, practising what they call Islam, propagate hatred towards "kaafirs" and other non-Muslims, issue fatwas and encourage Muslims to become jihaadis, how would the average Joe Bloggs not come to the conclusion that Islam "causes" terrorism??

It is my belief that Islam, like most other religions, would never "cause" terrorism, but those who allege they are Muslims and do so bring Islam into disrepute.

I am confident that there are millions of peace loving Muslims aroud the globe that cringe every time their beloved Islam is defamed in this way.....but that doenst make them terrorists. It just makes them more determined to exonerate thier faith - I would like to think I felt the same if I were a Muslim, and not use it as an excuse to become a "terrorist"

Love and peace to all.

😡M😡

Zoe28 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#10
i was merely suggesting that some of the muslims who are misled into becoming terrorists normally do so because muslims are labeled as terrorists and because they are frustrated , so their response is to become terrorists. i never said that was an excuse i was simply stating that is one of the factors which has cause muslims to become terrorists. as for your comment about muslims preaching jihad and so, if people are aware of that they should also know what jihad is, jihad has ntohing to do with terrorism, also any religion can have extremists that does not mean that people who belong to that religion should be labeled terrorists. also when i said miniority i meant a small number of people, not miniority in the sense of ethnic miniorities.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".