Kirti Shukla's analysis

Coming to Kirti Madam and her doubtful moves

1) She doesnt likes the idea of marriage

Does she not like the idea of marriage, because of Dev's abuse to her or she might have seen bad marriage of her parents. She talked that her father used the magic lens concept. This is still an acceptable point to me. Because not liking the institution of marriage is a personal choice.

2) Non judgmental

Being non judgmental is a wonderful quality. It was clearly visible when she was the only one to understand Neha's kleptomania. She understands the quality of mental health needed to lead a happy life. She tried to save Jagdale because of his kids and next day she was ready to forgive him. I am getting a vibe that her non judgmental side will help Sarkar a lot. Sarkar is also suffering from mental health problems, something might have stuck in his mind, as he said he is taking revenge of something. As Sarkar said that, all the girls were selfish in the relationships but not Kirti. I believe that the person who does a lot of mistakes becomes non judgmental with time. Or is she is a writer so she can think from all perspectives?

3) Book

She wrote a romance murder mystery book and gave it to read to Sarkar. Her book didn't make a great opening in the market, in the first episode itself she didn't allow that person to send the book scrap. Who knows it might be her story with Dev.

4) Friendship

She was invited by Anjali to Panchghati. How was Anjali as a person? Who knows, only Sarkar knows. Sarkar has the best people identifying skills till now. Anjali was definitely fishy, there are millions of girls, then why those twelve girls? Kirti might have shared everything to Anjali. She was her worry tree and friends do know such dark secrets. She said to Bappa mein zindagi ke khadde mein hi rahungi agar Anjali ko insaaf nahi mila to

5) Approaching the police

Sorry people might say that she is selfless, she might be but she is brave but it seems that she has a selfish motive too. Why she didn't approach the police when she was abused? People will say that she is kind, she keeps herself after others. Ok Right. But only a person who can help himself can help others. She immediately went to the police for Anjali, when she discovered the file, but not when she was abused both the times by Dev and Jagdale. She is repetitively talking to the police about Bittu's partner then why not during the time when she needed it the most. She also told that she doesn't trusts the police after giving the file to police.

6) Bravery

She is brave enough, she fought with Bittu by herself. Means she has definitely fought with Dev to escape, her mind is sharp enough. She is thinking it in the right way, she immediately thought about the forest she went to save Sarkar. She saved Sarkar, even Bittu failed to save him, but Kirti managed to save him. She was slipping because of the mud, it means she has fought a lot in her life.

7) The title of the series

Keh Doon Tumhe means both have certain information to share with each other. It is nothing but being each other's worry tree Sarkar's mask is clearly visible to the audience, but Kirti's mask? Sarkar isn't able to tell that he is the killer, but Kirti also has something which she feels might be judged by Sarkar. She sat in the darkness while the temple celebration and talked philosophical things.

8) Her relationship with Sarkar

When the nurse Kirti about Sarkar's relationship with her. She could have told that they are friends, but why a mere tenant?

9) Desperate nature

Her nature crossed the limits when she wanted certain information from Bittu. If she was a bit selfless then she would have waited for Bittu to get well. Even the police didn't talk to him. Then why she is much desperate. I understand she wants justice for Anjali quickly, even I want to Sarkar to be punished but how can she trust a person like Bittu? Jo khud Bhagwaan ka nahi hua, tumhara kaise hoga. She knows that Bittu wanted to kill her because he blamed her for Bhagwaan's death, but then he himself is revealing the name of his Bhagwaan. Why Kirti you missed this point? Bittu might change the name of his partner just to trouble her

11) Thinking capacities

She says that she uses the magic lens concept in every situation. Ok accepted. But I dont understand is she really sharp in her thinking? Whenever it comes to the case, she thinks in a perfect manner. She even remembered that Sarkar said that Mirajkar talked to Anjali the most. She remembers the smallest details. Then why she judged Sarkar wrongly, something is wrong. Sarkar ko to puri duniya galat samjhati hai, but Kirti writer hai use thoda bahut idea to hona hi chahiye tha. May be here I am thinking a lot.

12) Manipulative?

She even judged police correctly, she also knows that Bittu is a great reactor, means he doesn't thinks a lot while reacting. When she got emotional with Bittu, he cried. When she got angry Bittu got angry. When Sarkar manipulated Bittu, he felt guilty. When Kirti forced him to speak the truth about the partner, he was just above to speak but Sarkar overruled that game. She knows well that how a person will react and therefore she triggered him. When Sarkar talked about Puru she understood him, but again she was busy in cracking the case.

13) That first nod

I dont know how many of you noticed it, but in the first episode when Sarkar and Kirti saw each other for the first during Fufaji's accident, they both nodded at each other a bit. That nod is bothered me then, but I didn't discuss it earlier. I thought that both of them knew each other before.

14) As per the live session

Mudit said that Kirti is the serial killer. Was he kidding or not, only the cast knows

15) New beginning

Kirti said that woh Khadde mein hi rahegi to Bappa, means her new life has not begun yet. Either she is an angel in disguise or a devil in disguise.

There might be number of things I wanna add but this is something which I can think as of now. I might be wrong somewhere, please correct me if I am wrong

Thank you for tagging me. Will read and give my two points

Originally posted by: Naya_31

Thank you for tagging me. Will read and give me two points

If you find more reasons she is fishy then plz add

Kirti's behaviour has been fishy. The fact they have not disclosed about her life before divorce.

Plus she even told her bua that she has blocked Dev's number so that Puru cant talk to him is so mysterious .

But this is ITV and i know they gonna eventually turn her as an innocent soul. I wish they experiment with some new twists.

I actually want Kirti to be Grey shaded. They both can try to hide their pasts and true nature while living together as a couple.Both singing Keh Du Tumhe ya Chup rahu

It would be something fresh rather than seeing the female lead crying over her footi kismat everytime

Originally posted by: Niyashi

Kirti's behaviour has been fishy. The fact they have not disclose about her life before divorce.

Plus she even told her bua that she has blocked Dev's number so that Puru cant talk to him is so mysterious .

But this is ITV and i know they gonna eventually turn her as an innocent soul. I wish they experiment with some new twists.

I actually want Kirti to be Grey shaded. They both can try to hide their pasts and true nature while living together as a couple.Both singing Keh Du Tumhe ya Chup rahu

It would be something fresh rather than seeing the female lead crying over her footi kismat everytime

Kirti has to be grey shaded, I dont feel they will turn her into an innocent soul, because Vikrant is equally powerful and they havent shown Kirti to be a Bichaari.

Yeah I forgot she blocked Dev. Thanks for reminding that. She said that Dev wont be able to find her.

Kirti ki book Sarkar ne padhi hogi kya? What if Sarkar took inspirations from her book

But miss their romantic scenes I wish Kirti turns out into a killer and they both live peacefully in jail together

Yup both being shown as killers would be so nice to see.

Finally Sarkar ko woh jaisa h waise accept karne wali mil jayegi.

If you need new points then i would say

She never talks about her mother and her words. It seems she wasnt close to her.

She felt peace in that old room of Vikrant 's mother .Maybe something is connected.

She is too smart to be caught in an abusive marriage for so many years. She doesn't seem to be that submissive or maybe the experience transformed her.

Originally posted by: Niyashi

Yup both being shown as killers would be so nice to see.

Finally Sarkar ko woh jaisa h waise accept karne wali mil jayegi.

If you need new points then i would say

She never talks about her mother and her words. It seems she wasnt close to her.

She felt peace in that old room of Vikrant 's mother .Maybe something is connected.

She is too smart to be caught in an abusive marriage for so many years. She doesn't seem to be that submissive or maybe the experience transformed her.

Yes man really these points are amazing

But the Blue coloured lines was the best point: She fought with Bittu bravely, then how was she stuck in this abusive marriage?

Yes usko kaise shaanti mili Sarkar ke room mein?

With the first point I can say that seeing Vikrant's mother, she didn't talk about her mother.

It will be very interesting to watch tables turn on Vikrant, and to see someone threating him.. let's say : Kirti

It would be fun to see Sarkar being trapped like he did with the girls.

Honestly if this was a webseries I would be totally on board with this idea, but I don't have such high hopes from ITV. But skipping that, here's what I'm thinking if this show actually will be a proper murder mystery romantic show. I have a few theories.

Theory 1 - Kirti is the Murderer and Knows It

Kirti was in an abusive relationship with Dev. It seems she was young when she married Dev. So she probably had a big imprint made from that abusive relationship. She could be the serial killer or she could have manipulated Vikrant into committing murders for her of anyone who tries to manipulate him because in her view that girl is Dev.

In her mental state, she has written her own story of being a murderer. They keep mentioning she's an author and that her first book didn't do well. Many authors start off by mirroring their own life or a facet of their life in their first story. I know that when I took a novel writing class in undergrad, that's exactly what our prof made us do.

Now Kirti found Vikrant maybe through Dev and realized that his mother's death, his friend's death (maybe), being in a hostel, and having so much responsibility on him (as Sarkar) has broken Vikrant and she primed Vikrant into a cold-blooded killer. When Vikrant killed Anjali, she came in, pretending to be the worried best friend so that no one suspects her. I'm not being able to make out the rest of her plan yet, but either she'll get Vikrant arrested and find someone new to manipulate or the blame will fall on Bittu.

Theory 2 - Kirti is the Murderer but Doesn't Realize It

Basically the same as above except Kirti has dissociative identity disorder. So this Kirti doesn't realize she is the murderer or the manipulator, but she has another identity who is the true manipulator and every once in a while it comes out.

Theory 3 - Vikrant is the Murderer but is Mentally Ill

We keep hearing Vikrant talking to himself in his mind almost as if he has 2 personalities. One is falling in love with Kirti, but the other is cautioning him and telling him to kill Kirti. I have a feeling that second personality is Rohit's. Now let's be clear, he doesn't have dissociative identity disorder. This second personality is a part of him.

Maybe Rohit was deceived by a girl and killed himself. Vikrant, at a young age, couldn't bear the death of his mother and Rohit and decided that any girl who tries to control him is like that girl who pushed Rohit to suicide. So whenever he sees another girl like that, he thinks he is Rohit and kills that girl. Vikrant is more simple and loves Kirti and just wants to keep her safe, but the Rohit in him is ruining that feeling as well.