Just imagine!

Namaste,

I was thinking, Haseena Mallik maut ke mooh se nikal aayi, memory loss hua, Karishma Singh ne poora thana aur sabko sambhala, cases akele hi apni Maddam sir jaise hisolve kiye👏. Sabne uska saath bhi diya.

Now, she is back to being immature, impulsive etc. Ab uski itni zaroorat nahin hain, shayad.

Ab socho:

Ek case ko solve karte time, woh bahut injured hoti hain itni ki, coma me chali jati hain. Effectively, Karishma Singh ka Bhaukal rahega nahin Lucknow me. Ab saare cases Jazbaat se solve honge aur niyat aur tareeke ki ladai bhi nahin hogi.

Agar aisa hua toh?!

Originally posted by: Bodhianveshika

Namaste,

I was thinking, Haseena Mallik maut ke mooh se nikal aayi, memory loss hua, Karishma Singh ne poora thana aur sabko sambhala, cases akele hi apni Maddam sir jaise hisolve kiye👏. Sabne uska saath bhi diya.

Now, she is back to being immature, impulsive etc. Ab uski itni zaroorat nahin hain, shayad.

Ab socho:

Ek case ko solve karte time, woh bahut injured hoti hain itni ki, coma me chali jati hain. Effectively, Karishma Singh ka Bhaukal rahega nahin Lucknow me. Ab saare cases Jazbaat se solve honge aur niyat aur tareeke ki ladai bhi nahin hogi.

Agar aisa hua toh?!

Namaste ji,

@bold - you literally stole the thoughts from the deepest darkest corners of my mind.

Ever since HM's return, KS has had very little initiative or input on the resolutions of cases, she just waits for maddam sir's order and obediently follows it. She might say an angry dialogue or two, maybe even grab someone's collar, but she won't resort to physical violence as a solution. Even if she doesn't agree with maddam sir, she'll say it very respectfully and then back off. I don't think she's back to being the same immature or impulsive as before, because now she only dares to make the smallest of errors, and even then she's constantly worried about hurting maddam sir's trust, so no big issue comes of it.

KS has so wholly merged herself into maddam sir that I've been questioning if anything would feel amiss if she were gone. Before atleast she would fight over ideologies or try alternate solutions on her own or what not, but now she barely causes a ripple in MPT's dynamics. HM's death made everyone dysfunctional in their own ways, and ever since then I've wondered what effect KS's accident/injury/coma would have on them, if any. It really feels like they've taken her sacrifice of the last 3 months for granted and they don't need her anymore now that HM is back. I didn't want to voice this out loud because it sounds cruel to wish for KS in pain. Its sadistic to want to see MPT struggle at cases in her absence and a certain few ppl drowing in guilt, regret and despair.

But haan, maine bhi bohot baar socha hai ki aisa hua toh, mujhe bohot sadistic pleasure milega.

Yeh log kar sakte hain air hum soche bhi na?????😆😕.

Not gonna lie, this is a pretty interesting route to go down.

I agree with anee that she isn't exactly the same immature, impulsive or hot-headed person as she was previously. case in point, the latest report they had about the principal vs professor one. she didn't do anything other than listen to instructions and carry out the plan. there was a point in the episode where she told haseena that they needed to act fast before Rahul drops dead- a direct contrast to what she would have said had this been a pre haseena death episode (something along the lines of letting her beat up the principal so he reinstates Rahul). so yes, he has grown and learned to think before acting.

so in a turn of events like you've mentioned, I would want to see just how much her absence would affect the team and cases. Karishma hasn't been given appreciation for all that she has done in the last three months. a wake-up call like this would be a fantastic way to force everyone to reflect on their relationships and how they have been behaving. maybe even be a catalyst to fully process what has happened in the last three months. because the way I see it, they still haven't confronted a giant elephant in the room nor truly moved on/let go especially Karishma who actively tries to express her displeasure be it to Pushpa Ji or dissing haseena. their dynamics are so precariously built right now that a simple wind bears the power to shatter the illusion they live in. okay, maybe a little more than wind but my point is their dynamic feels so superficial that a scenario like this along with deep introspection might just help them realise whats going on.

tbh, Without Karishma, Haseena will not be able to even run the thana, forget about catching criminals and get them to change through Jazbaat.

I am not questioning Haseena's credibility as a cop here but we have seen time and again the difference in response of the MPT members when instructions are given by Haseena and Karishma. Haseena is taken too lightly while Karishma just needs to give a look and the work starts.

Now coming to criminals, again not all understand the language of jazbaat, do they? 😆

The point being Karishma's absence will be felt by Haseena. Haseena already knows that her jazbaat doesn't work all the time and that sometimes the language of laat is important but she might not admit it ever because she might be worried about promoting violence than eradicating it (I am assuming). 😆

So basically yeah, Karishma's absence, in any case, will to some extent halt the working of the MPT and Haseena will feel the brunt of it fully.

True. Absolutely true. But, the writers do not seem to get it through their thick skin. Hence, it would be an interesting challenge to the writers to write episodes respectfully acknowledging the character of Karishma Singh.

Point being simple, if one of mainthe characters (in this case, the parallel lead) is only used for mocking purposes, might as well remove the character. Be rest assured that it will eliminate logic and virtue as well and be no different from a daily soap with an ALL consuming, ALL sacrificing, ALL virtuous female lead, around whom the world revolves.