Why No Criticism?

Originally posted by: Shaitan-Haiwan

I am just wondering why this show even has judges who act like they've come to see a concert? Every time someone sings they always say yeah it was good - the truth is almost all of them are nowhere near perfection and need improvement.

Yesterday Kunal's rendition of Main Aisa Kyu Hu was TERRIBLE. But they got so happy looking at his getup and dancing the judges seem to have forgotten why they are there😆

Especially for Vibhor/Kunal - they are the weakest singers right now but the way they are celebrated is shocking to me. Even I can notice their mistakes but judges always over look them.

Why not just get rid of the judges and let Maniesh do their wah wah?😆 Ankhush got critcism that keep your eyes open? Yeh kya hai? Ive seen many singers in the STUDIO whose eyes are closed - yes presentation is important but it seems like they are okay with singing being compromised for dancing😆

This show does not feel like a competition at all.

Yeah, they rarely give constructive criticism!

Indian Idol team selects songs generally. Neelanjana has not gone out of her comfort zone yet, but Ankush has tried badan pe sitare, dard e disco, that qawwali track, chappa charkhachle, chahe koi mujhe junglee etc. which are not exactly soft songs. After watching some youtube stuffs I kinda feel, Ankush can do more. Kunal is anyday better than Vibhor.

Originally posted by: KhwaboKeParinde

Yeah, they rarely give constructive criticism!

Indian Idol team selects songs generally. Neelanjana has not gone out of her comfort zone yet, but Ankush has tried badan pe sitare, dard e disco, that qawwali track, chappa charkhachle, chahe koi mujhe junglee etc. which are not exactly soft songs. After watching some youtube stuffs I kinda feel, Ankush can do so much more. Kunal is anyday better than Vibhor.

Originally posted by: KhwaboKeParinde

Yeah, they rarely give constructive criticism!

Indian Idol team selects songs generally. Neelanjana has not gone out of her comfort zone yet, but Ankush has tried badan pe sitare, dard e disco, that qawwali track, chappa charkhachle, chahe koi mujhe junglee etc. which are not exactly soft songs. After watching some youtube stuffs I kinda feel, Ankush can do so much more. Kunal is anyday better than Vibhor.