The play being used to justify swarna's so-called sacrifice - Page 4

Originally posted by: janvi0513

Good to see you back in the forum Geethu. 🤗

@bold you are right kaira have misunderstood their parents, they know that feeling you get when you think your parents have done wrong with you. At the same time this isn't the entire truth, the other part of the story is that they had been proved wrong and were / are guilty for their faults.

Think about Cinderella, imagine hearing the story the first time, you will be unhappy listening to the hardships the girl face but at the end content she got her happily ever after. When we think about any fairytale we think about happiness even though in the beginning there are problems that is because the end of the story is happy.

Similar in kaira's case the story which they considered about their parents having hurt them turned out to have a twisted end with them realizing that had been seeing things the wrong way, so the strongest emotion of theirs is the regret. That is why when Shubham behaves the way he does Karthik stops him as he sees his own image and then feels that regret he is going through.

Hope to see you more often in the forum.😊

Originally posted by: CaptiveFreedom

@misaki I understand ur point...drawback of this track is glorification of Suwarna's sacrifice be it by Kaira or later on by Manish...poor execution...poor writing...no remorse by Suwarna...all these factors complemented each other to form the worst track...I wouldn't mind seeing flashback scenes with scenario like child Karthik feeling neglected...Manish and entire Goenka family's attention being entirely shifted towards Suwarna as she was expecting...Karthik already having misconception that Swarnish's extra marital affair caused his mother's death...them being happy in their own small world and Karthik being alone...these kind of flashback scenes...were needed...though they can't justify Suwarna's actions...but still...it would have given some insight to viewers regarding situation that time...child's psyche is very sensitive it leaves lifetime impact and scars...Karthik already lived with the pain of losing his mother...with the grief that his mother gave up her life and committed suicide...whereas on other hand...Shubham lived without mother's love...without education...without luxuries...his life wasn't also easy...I can't expect him to forgive Suwarna or to understand her greatly unfair sacrifice better say selfishness...but I do expect him to stop self-sympathizing and try to show Goenkas that he is worth being acknowledged infront of other people...I want transformation in his character...in his dressing...maybe they can send him somewhere to get higher education...without saying "they did this" or now I will show them by my negative approach...he should be like now I will show them that I'm better without them...without their surname, money ...without their attention...now regarding Kaira being on Suwarna's side...once I heard dialogue from Naira it was like "maa apne galat kiya" but that was overpowered by the monologue "tyag" over and over again...Kaira in their attempt to tone down Shubam's reaction towards Suwarna...have neglected what he must be going through completely...they consider her their mother only...without understanding the fact that she is Shubham's biological mother too ...he has every right to be angry at her...if they were proven wrong in misunderstanding their parents that doesn't mean Shubam is also completely wrong...not letting Shubam misbehave with Suwarna or to create chaos isn't wrong move by Kaira...but they should have strictly acknowledged, considered or declared Suwarna's sacrifice wrong...that could've been a better approach...emphasis shouldn't be on "tyag" but on how "wrong" and "unfair" the tyag was...I think now CVs will show Suwarna's brother being the main villain in this situation...he might be spending money on his own expenses which Suwarna use to send for Shubam...depriving him of essential necessities like education...

Originally posted by: misaki

@ Bold - Exactly! Firstly, it was a 'bali' not 'tyag'. Call a spade, a spade. Secondly, they should quit harping on and on about how wrong Shubham is and instead concentrate on how to get him closer to the family. Asking him to stay away if he's not happy about a celebration is not the way to go!👎🏼 All they are doing now is antagonize him over everything he does. Not gonna help anyone. They really are instead making the whole situation worse by staying on Swarna's side.