The play being used to justify swarna's so-called sacrifice - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

33

Views

8.5k

Users

9

Likes

147

Frequent Posters

ShadowImbue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#21
Yes Suwarna Mata's tyag wasn't a tyag in true sense she was highly insensitive to do that to her own flesh and blood regarding Kaira being glorified. Kaira, Karthik or Naira don't NEED any glorification to be very honest. They are the most loved characters even after being flawed, even after making mistakes because they rectified their mistakes they were fighters in their own respective ways. Self pity was far away from them. Yes they were away by their own choice but circumstances played greater part in compelling their decisions. Karthik couldn't see his mother's supposed killers roaming around him all the time and Naira couldn't see her mother sending her jail in order to prove herself a righteous woman. Naksh too lectured Naira previously on misbehaving with Akshara though he himself misunderstood Naitik previously. If u misunderstood ur parents that doesn't mean u can't lecture others not to make same mistake. Here the situation is different as Suwarna mata is still not understanding her mistake. She is still indifferent towards Shubam which is making me dislike her even more. When Parul was going to play Karthik's step mom I already had an idea that she will be given major role maybe her character will be shown even more positive than Naira (FL with flaws). In their attempt to show Suwarna mata goddess they are conveniently forgetting her accepting her flaw, her mistake of abandoning Shubam. Whatever happened was for Glorification of Suwana's character whereas Kaira were only being used for the purpose of glorification of cliche filmy tyag that is being shown several times before too. Also I already predicted such kind of overly emotional and dramatic Swarna-Karthik milan but never thought Swarna mata will forget Shubam completely.
Edited by ShadowImbue - 7 years ago
Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: ShadowImbue

Yes Suwarna Mata's tyag wasn't a tyag in true sense she was highly insensitive to do that to her own flesh and blood regarding Kaira being glorified. Kaira, Karthik or Naira don't NEED any glorification to be very honest. They are the most loved characters even after being flawed, even after making mistakes because they rectified their mistakes they were fighters in their own respective ways. Self pity was far away from them. Yes they were away by their own choice but circumstances played greater part in compelling their decisions. Karthik couldn't see his mother's supposed killers roaming around him all the time and Naira couldn't see her mother sending her jail in order to prove herself a righteous woman. Naksh too lectured Naira previously on misbehaving with Akshara though he himself misunderstood Naitik previously. If u misunderstood ur parents that doesn't mean u can't lecture others not to make same mistake. Here the situation is different as Suwarna mata is still not understanding her mistake. She is still indifferent towards Shubam which is making me dislike her even more. When Parul was going to play Karthik's step mom I already had an idea that she will be given major role maybe her character will be shown even more positive than Naira (FL with flaws). In their attempt to show Suwarna mata goddess they are conveniently forgetting her accepting her flaw, her mistake of abandoning Shubam. Whatever happened was for Glorification of Suwana's character whereas Kaira were only being used for the purpose of glorification of cliche filmy tyag that is being shown several times before too. Also I already predicted such kind of overly emotional and dramatic Swarna-Karthik milan but never thought Swarna mata will forget Shubam completely.


In all this, do you know what I feel, that in order to be a good mother to her step-son, uss ne sagge ko sautela, aur sautela ko sagga bana diya. 🤢
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#23
@sammy very true ..This is evident in Wednesdays episode where goenka didn't introduce aryan to anybody..As if they are ashamed to do so..everyone including the so called loving parents manish and suvarna...And what reasoning did naira have for it? Itne dino mein blah blah...After all this build up if something bad happens , they will just discuss "humse galti ho gayi, aryan ki feelings nai dekhi" and make some more plans to bring him close ..Yuck! There is no need for a party when they knew they will have to introduce aryan and they don't want to..Manish could have taken the puppy avtar in private too..

If someone is reading , yesterday's episode was horrible with intermixing of manish suvarna aryan, raghav, kartik threatening raghav and table romance ?🤢 kartik and naira have an on off switch for romance ? Koi marr bhi jaye but they can get into the mood in a second ..I liked yr post leap only due to the good star cast which was introduced ..Best being sachin tyagi and the leads..But they have wasted it all..Until kaira wedding everything was perfect ..sad
Edited by _charu_ - 7 years ago
Samaina12 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: _charu_

@sammy very true ..This is evident in Wednesdays episode where goenka didn't introduce aryan to anybody..As if they are ashamed to do so..everyone including the so called loving parents manish and suvarna...And what reasoning did naira have for it? Itne dino mein blah blah...After all this build up if something bad happens , they will just discuss "humse galti ho gayi, aryan ki feelings nai dekhi" and make some more plans to bring him close ..Yuck! There is no need for a party when they knew they will have to introduce aryan and they don't want to..Manish could have taken the puppy avtar in private too..

If someone is reading , yesterday's episode was horrible with intermixing of manish suvarna aryan, raghav, kartik threatening raghav and table romance ?🤢 kartik and naira have an on off switch for romance ? Koi marr bhi jaye but they can get into the mood in a second ..I liked yr post leap only due to the good star cast which was introduced ..Best being sachin tyagi and the leads..But they have wasted it all..Until kaira wedding everything was perfect ..sad

bold: true. Last week too they were romancing when it was a real tense situation at home. Greece track, kartikk got arrested and released instead of going back to India and getting things clearer they were dancing and romancing. Looks like writers have lost their belief on story henc relying only on irrelevant romance to keep the show stay afloat.

Shivangi mohsin have a good chemistry that reflects in kaira but that doesn't mean the writers add romance everywhere irrespective of the situation in the story. 😆
Sometimes it gets borderline annoying.🥱
Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Meherya123

bold: true. Last week too they were romancing when it was a real tense situation at home. Greece track, kartikk got arrested and released instead of going back to India and getting things clearer they were dancing and romancing. Looks like writers have lost their belief on story henc relying only on irrelevant romance to keep the show stay afloat.

Shivangi mohsin have a good chemistry that reflects in kaira but that doesn't mean the writers add romance everywhere irrespective of the situation in the story. 😆
Sometimes it gets borderline annoying.🥱


I don't even know what to say about kaira romance anymore. The writers come up with the most odd and inappropriate timings/ situations to make them romance. Since their marriage, the writers have been slowly and steadily ruining the magic of kaira's chemistry. The overdose of song sequences are an example. When they had those cutesy sequences before marriage I was fine, but now it irritates me knowing they are intentionally using song sequences to fill the air time. Even naitik and akshara I only liked in the initial days until they milked their chemistry dry with the longevity of the show, now they are ruining kaira too by making them romance during situations where it is completely unnecessary and inappropriate.
Samaina12 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: sammy17


I don't even know what to say about kaira romance anymore. The writers come up with the most odd and inappropriate timings/ situations to make them romance. Since their marriage, the writers have been slowly and steadily ruining the magic of kaira's chemistry. The overdose of song sequences are an example. When they had those cutesy sequences before marriage I was fine, but now it irritates me knowing they are intentionally using song sequences to fill the air time. Even naitik and akshara I only liked in the initial days until they milked their chemistry dry with the longevity of the show, now they are ruining kaira too by making them romance during situations where it is completely unnecessary and inappropriate.

exactly. Not even their acting is going to save the show now. Only good actors in the show are shivin, sachin and k dadi. Now by ruining their characters one by one that is kaira romance overdose, manish being a pendulum mostly, dadi getting the pathetic dialogues I don't know what they want to prove. It's doing injustice to the actor's talent.

I won't even comment about what they made keesh into. What could have been a good story turned into filler scenes that absolutely make no sense whatsoever.
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: Meherya123

bold: true. Last week too they were romancing when it was a real tense situation at home. Greece track, kartikk got arrested and released instead of going back to India and getting things clearer they were dancing and romancing. Looks like writers have lost their belief on story henc relying only on irrelevant romance to keep the show stay afloat.

Shivangi mohsin have a good chemistry that reflects in kaira but that doesn't mean the writers add romance everywhere irrespective of the situation in the story. 😆
Sometimes it gets borderline annoying.🥱


Exactly ..Cmon guys you want to romance , find a room , it's your house it's your time ..In an hour the party will get over , you will have the full night ..And all the nights after that ..Why would they want to romance below the table now ? N that too when kartik is tensed about raghav and aryan the makhi is annoyed
misaki thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#28
I know this post is about Swarna but the part that irks me the most about this track is how the creatives have decided to get Kaira involved in it.
The two people in that entire show who know all too well how it feels when a parent betrays you, albeit a misunderstanding when it came to them unlike Shubam's case , were Kartik and Naira.

I'm absolutely appalled at how they have made these two behave in this particular track! Seriously writers, should we remind you why Naira continued to disrespect and carried all that anger towards her mom only because she thought Akshara had decided to hand her over to the police?! The same girl who stayed away from her family for that one reason? How can that girl not remember how it feels when your own mother, the one who should fight the entire world for you, instead decides to give you up? Kartik is no stranger when it comes to experiencing that feeling either. This is the very guy who refused to even acknowledge his own father for almost his entire life since he believed him to have wronged his mother. Are you telling me that he wouldn't be the first one to stand by his newly discovered and horribly wronged younger brother?😳

I mean, of course I get why he would apologize to Swarna for hating her all these years and pitying her for losing both her sons. Having compassion for her is completely understandable. What I don't understand is instead of making them help her see how wrong she was to have done what she has and repeatedly try to get Shubham closer to the family, they are instead glorifying her sacrifice ( before people say otherwise, yes they are since they haven't made her understand or acknowledge the fact that, the first person she should apologize to is not them or even her husband but her very own son.)and lecturing Shubham about her mahaanta! Dafaq?!😡I can't for the life of me understand why MY KAIRA would ever take her side instead of the son. Makes absolutely NO SENSE! 🤔

I get that the writers wanted to make Shubham "the baddy " who created problems for the leads. I know they have a show to run and for that they have to pit the good guys against the bad guys but they probably forgot that you don't always have to put them on opposite sides in order to do that. This track is by far the worse track after Kaira's marriage and that's saying something after all the disasters we have got since then😵.

Edited by misaki - 7 years ago
janvi0513 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: misaki

I know this post is about Swarna but the part that irks me the most about this track is how the creatives have decided to get Kaira involved in it.

The two people in that entire show who know all too well how it feels when a parent betrays you, albeit a misunderstanding when it came to them unlike Shubam's case , were Kartik and Naira.

I'm absolutely appalled at how they have made these two behave in this particular track! Seriously writers, should we remind you why Naira continued to disrespect and carried all that anger towards her mom only because she thought Akshara had decided to hand her over to the police?! The same girl who stayed away from her family for that one reason? How can that girl not remember how it feels when your own mother, the one who should fight the entire world for you, instead decides to give you up? Kartik is no stranger when it comes to experiencing that feeling either. This is the very guy who refused to even acknowledge his own father for almost his entire life since he believed him to have wronged his mother. Are you telling me that he wouldn't be the first one to stand by his newly discovered and horribly wronged younger brother?😳

I mean, of course I get why he would apologize to Swarna for hating her all these years and pitying her for losing both her sons. Having compassion for her is completely understandable. What I don't understand is instead of making them help her see how wrong she was to have done what she has and repeatedly try to get Shubham closer to the family, they are instead glorifying her sacrifice ( before people say otherwise, yes they are since they haven't made her understand or acknowledge the fact that, the first person she should apologize to is not them or even her husband but her very own son.)and lecturing Shubham about her mahaanta! Dafaq?!😡I can't for the life of me understand why MY KAIRA would ever take her side instead of the son. Makes absolutely NO SENSE! 🤔

I get that the writers wanted to make Shubham "the baddy " who created problems for the leads. I know they have a show to run and for that they have to pit the good guys against the bad guys but they probably forgot that you don't always have to put them on opposite sides in order to do that. This track is by far the worse track after Kaira's marriage and that's saying something after all the disasters we have got since then😵.


Good to see you back in the forum Geethu. 🤗
@bold you are right kaira have misunderstood their parents, they know that feeling you get when you think your parents have done wrong with you. At the same time this isn't the entire truth, the other part of the story is that they had been proved wrong and were / are guilty for their faults.

Think about Cinderella, imagine hearing the story the first time, you will be unhappy listening to the hardships the girl face but at the end content she got her happily ever after. When we think about any fairytale we think about happiness even though in the beginning there are problems that is because the end of the story is happy.

Similar in kaira's case the story which they considered about their parents having hurt them turned out to have a twisted end with them realizing that had been seeing things the wrong way, so the strongest emotion of theirs is the regret. That is why when Shubham behaves the way he does Karthik stops him as he sees his own image and then feels that regret he is going through.

Hope to see you more often in the forum.😊
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 7 years ago
#30
A layman can also see that naira's parents and kartik's parents were right and kaira were wrong so it's ok if they regret but here suvarna is wrong and shubham is the wronged party but kaira want shubham to forgive and forget everything in a minute ..Worse is suvarnas attitude , she just looks left right and down while naira tries to act like the big mamma of goenkas , trying to discipline the ill-mannered shubham.. cvs can't do anything better than this..Instead of regular ranting it's good if I quit watching it again ..Not that anyone cares ..Even I don't

Related Topics

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01

3 months ago

Swarna and Manish should play Kairav and Muskan

They should not play Great Great Great. Swarna is not aging it looks so fake even Baa from Khunki saas still look realistic

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: MsWhiskerson

4 months ago

Sacrifice of a sister - Star give Nayi soch diamond award to Abhira

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DIh4R4_ikkw/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link igsh=MzRlODBiNWFlZA== 😢😢 Dekhke rona aa gaya How? How can someone make...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: shruthiravi

4 months ago

Let's play the game with number 8 and 9- Ab, ru, Charu, Kiara

Since some people have really problem about religious content and doesn't understand comparison and symbolism, forcing others to stop writing...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Fortnight

5 months ago

Yrkkh Role play (FUN)

Hi guys I'm Armaan @Anashqu - Phuphasa/Roop @Vissz- Daksh/Krish @Ammu- Rohit Poddar @sera-high123- Phupasa ki gf @enigmaticw - Shivani...

Expand ▼
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Thumbnail

Posted by: Maanbhira

6 months ago

Lets play a dialogue baazi game

Do you remember something: Papa ki Ankhon ke Tare: Kairav or Akshu sabse pyare.... This is the dailgoue,I changed from Mumma to Papa... I really...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".