Mukthaa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Sudha is not leaving my mind since I saw that scenen were Gayatri injects drugs to make her psychotic...My question is can we blame sudha for choosing the revenge path...her way of taking revenge is not justifiable no doubt..she is harming innocent souls for her revenge which is very unacceptable.she should have fought a fair game(though what happened with her was totally unfair crime) like dheeru n Adhiraj.but all i am asking about is her goal that's revenge.is that wrong because they ruined her life..spoilt her love story.. turned her a psycho .n tortured her son..I think The Lal Mahal wasis whoever are responsible for Sudha n Narottams present state need to be punished severely,they dnt deserve any mercy.
I so wish sudha was also shown as a grey shade...At the same time I destest her as well as sympathize with her...N if she is mentally unstable even now then we can't even blaim her since according to law a psychiatric patient is not liable for the actions done during the period of mental instability.
Edited by TriShakti - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

15

Views

1.9k

Users

11

Likes

81

Frequent Posters

Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
I feel we can blame Sudha for taking the path of revenge and here's my thinking.

She has been wronged by Lal Mahal, but can you really be sure about that? We see one scene from Gayatri's past and assume that she is the one that is wrong, when nothing is as it seems in Lal Mahal. Maybe Gayatri was wrong. But maybe she was right. Maybe Sudha has always been twisted and just appeared to be an innocent in the flashback. But let's assume for a minute that everything is at it seems and Gayatri was wrong. Why is Sudha taking revenge from the kids of Lal Mahal? Why is she using her own son for revenge? Why is she willing to ruin the life of an innocent girl Anami in the process? Why is she fine with taking the life of another innocent life Vatsalya (assuming that she was behind his death)?

Sudha is psychotic for sure, but not in the sense that can be diagnosed. Some people are just born with a twisted mind, with a warped mentality, with no sense of right and wrong. They can be taught all you want, but they don't learn. Sudha, in my view, is one of those people.

Dheeru's revenge is different. If you look at it, he refuses to hurt innocent people. He refuses to use his family. He will willingly back off if any harm comes to Adhiraj or Tania. He won't use Anami to meet his goal. He knows that what he is doing is right and is trying to teach Adhiraj the same thing. Look to his kids. They're upbringing has obviously been good, which means their parents were good and one of their parents is Dheeru.

On the other hand, Sudha was the only influence on Narottam because Lal Mahal obviously hates him, despises him. Sudha could have raised Narottam with love and care. She could have taken him on a similar path as Adhiraj who wants to reach his goal, but doesn't want to hurt innocent people in the process, who has a good sense of justice and truth. But instead Narottam became even more warped. He was hated by Lal Mahal and grown as a weapon by Sudha.

Lal Mahal is at fault for what happened to Sudha, but only she is to blame for the path she has taken.

Pursue some path, however narrow and crooked, in which you can walk with love and reverence. - Henry David Thoreau

I quote this here because it shows where Sudha has gone wrong and why I can never sympthatize with her. She choose the wide path. The easy path. The straight path. It walks through people. It walks over people. It crushes the innocent. And there will be an end to it sometime. On the other hand, Dheeru has chosen exactly this narrow and crooked path. He will encounter Pujan, Kamini, pain, and setbacks. It will not be a straight path. But with his family by his side, he will preserver.
Mukthaa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
@Athene
You are absolutely right about her revenge journey..he path for revenge is very dark..no second thoughts on that..but what I was asking here was the ultimate goal ..that's taking revenge from the People who spoiled her life..let's just keep aside the path she is following aside n concentrate on her goal..N is she wrong in opting that goal?
N we don't have a clear insight to what happened with her in the past..but here I am talking based on what we have been shown so far
Edited by TriShakti - 7 years ago
...Deeksha.... thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
I absolutely agree with shreya here. We don't know what really happen and we cannot jump into conclusions without knowing the complete truth. Every coin has 2 sides and let both the sides are revealed to judge someone.
Mukthaa thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: ...Deeksha...

I absolutely agree with shreya here. We don't know what really happen and we cannot jump into conclusions without knowing the complete truth.[COLIR=red ]Every coin has 2 sides and let both the sides are revealed to judge someone[/COLOR].

That makes sense..agree.
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: TriShakti

@Athene

You are absolutely right about her revenge journey..he path for revenge is very dark..no second thoughts on that..but what I was asking here was the ultimate goal ..that's taking revenge from the People who spoiled her life..let's just keep aside the path she is following aside n concentrate on her goal..N is she wrong in opting that goal?
N we don't have a clear insight to what happened with her in the past..but here I am talking based on what we have been shown so far



If we talk about the goal only, then no she isn't wrong. But again we're basing that on what we're seeing so far. The same can be said for Dheeru. What we've been shown so far is that Lal Mahal wronged them.

But with Sudha I see a full other story. Because everything she's said and done so far talks to revenge for power, for money, for position. She wants the position that Satrupa is in. Maybe she wanted to just be the bahu of Lal Mahal at one time, but now she wants that money, power, and position that comes with it. She wants to destroy everyone so she can get Royal Steels. And that I feel is wrong. Because if you've been wronged, your revenge should be about that "wrong". She was wronged because she was deceived and taken away from being the bahu of Lal Mahal. She should aim for that goal. To be recognized as Baldev's first wife. But instead her goal has changed.
mira thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
I got a very different picture from days episode. I dont think they injected something and made her unstable. Rather that was just tranquilizer. She really looked like a psychotic person obsessed with Baldev. The way she said "I know NT is our son but Sudha is Sudha and did Baldev asked about me" when Gayatri was trying to convince her about Baldev's concern... I felt like Sudha was delusional to begin with...

I dont think it was a black and white case of Sudha being wronged. I got the feeling that Baldev might have had an affair with her but she too might have tried to trap him ... both might have been selfish.

I dont feel much sympathy for Sudha or Baldev. Both sounds selfish and self centered.

NT is someone I can see as a grey character ... he still has some good in him.
gaushiv13 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: mira

I got a very different picture from days episode. I dont think they injected something and made her unstable. Rather that was just tranquilizer. She really looked like a psychotic person obsessed with Baldev. The way she said "I know NT is our son but Sudha is Sudha and did Baldev asked about me" when Gayatri was trying to convince her about Baldev's concern... I felt like Sudha was delusional to begin with...

I dont think it was a black and white case of Sudha being wronged. I got the feeling that Baldev might have had an affair with her but she too might have tried to trap him ... both might have been selfish.

I dont feel much sympathy for Sudha or Baldev. Both sounds selfish and self centered.

NT is someone I can see as a grey character ... he still has some good in him.

got the same feeling that shudha is not white from starting
the way she said and was not happy with baldev asking about narottam only
Niti_21 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
After seeing 2days epi, we got another dimension to Sudha...
Every epi just brings twist nd get us back to square 1 as to who was wrong nd who was wronged.

Of course everyone is grey here only their degree varies.

But somehow inspite of intriguing epis i feel the story is stalled.

there is no progress seen be it Vatsalya Murder case, or Anami's equation with members of LM except with Gayatri.
The story needs progress., we can't hv Pujan planning nd failing or hv random Satrupa- Anami tashan scenes or Narottam fooling Anami.

What is Adhiraj exactly doing? He is CBI nd there is no progress in case he is handling nor he is making any effort.

At this point we need some pace and progress to sustain viewers otherwise it wud just get boring.
Edited by Niyati_21 - 7 years ago
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: mira

I got a very different picture from days episode. I dont think they injected something and made her unstable. Rather that was just tranquilizer. She really looked like a psychotic person obsessed with Baldev. The way she said "I know NT is our son but Sudha is Sudha and did Baldev asked about me" when Gayatri was trying to convince her about Baldev's concern... I felt like Sudha was delusional to begin with...

I dont think it was a black and white case of Sudha being wronged. I got the feeling that Baldev might have had an affair with her but she too might have tried to trap him ... both might have been selfish.

I dont feel much sympathy for Sudha or Baldev. Both sounds selfish and self centered.

NT is someone I can see as a grey character ... he still has some good in him.



I agree with you here. Today's episode opened up a whole new dimension into Sudha's personality.

I may have felt some sympathy for her for the first few minutes, but she was selfish and didn't talk about Narottam as if he was her own. Not only that, after she was injected, anyone's first intention would be to try to fight and run after realizing they've been deceived. What does she do? She tries to kill Gayatri.

Both of these things have cemented my thoughts that her path and goal are both wrong.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".