Sonakshi and benefit of doubt

ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Yes. They both go so well with each other..together they can be called a unit.
I think Sonakshi is the most fortunate female lead who got this advantage of utilising " benefit of doubt " whenever she faltered or became the object of criticism,this great armour called benefit of doubt saved her like a devastating weapon or an armour that can not be pierced.

My colleague who is an obsessive Sonakshi loyalist entered the staff room much to my discomfort. Already I am in a very bad mood seeing the previous episode that left no hopes for me or crushed all my hopes of Sonakshi informing Dev about Vicky's misdeed seven years ago.

As such I don't want to interact with her and spoil my already spoilt mood." I have a class right after the break..I said indirectly hinting her that I am done with Sonakshi and any argument reg.last night's episode. My friend brushed off my pretence and directly entered the war Jone. " Saw the episode? How soft Sonakshi is at heart? Won't you agree?" She looked at me anticipating nice reaction from me.

I kept silent. Still I don't want to indulge in verbal fight but I know it is inevitable. Every day during the lunch break it became a habit for both of us to dissect the show and the ch.s.why would she hold back now? Aadat se majbur, I muttered under my breath.

" See Sonakshi can bring change even in RadhaRani How heart wrenching their scene was! " My friend had a smile of appreciation on her face. I started losing patience. I saw my watch. Till thirty minutes left for attending the class.

" Dont you think it is sheer injustice on part of Sonakshi not to tell Dev about Vicky? I shot my question at her already knowing what answer she will give. She may say Dev is short tempered and throw Vicky out. So to maintain peace in family she held back. But my friend made me dumbfounded with her defence." Don't you see how busy he is? He is too much involved in his soft ware launch. Poor Sona. She must have thought of telling him. Give her benefit of doubt. She went to his room no?"

I lost my patience." I did not sense any intention to tell him the truth. But Sonakshi is against keeping secrets among family members. Don't you remember Mrs.Mandal issue? Now she is doing what Dev did then. Why?"

My question met with a look of pity directed straight towards me. She tried to explain." You know Boses are sorted out people. They can handle any mess and swallow any truth. But Dixits? They are weak,vulnerable,unorganised...

I felt desparate. By now I know by heart all the adjectives that she use for Dev and his family.

I drank cool water from my bottle to calm myself. I said in a composed tone." What she did yesterday I can never digest. Even Elena looked distressed and swayed by emotions. But Sonakshi? Not a glimpse of repentance on her face. She is so cool and doing her work as if nothing had happened. Isn't it her duty to say sorry Dev? When will your Sonakshi Bose feel guilty and regret for her misconceptions? I doubt the serial will end but I won't hear the golden letters sorry from her mouth. "

I stood and walked to my book shelf to take the book,trying to control myself.

My friend placed her hand on my shoulder and said with a smile." Relax dear. Sonakshi knows everything. She just gave the last chance to Vicky. She warned him. Isn't it enough?

I threw the duster on my table with force." Warning? To Vicky? Will it work? She owes Dev an apology. She should have done that by this time. He is innocent in eviction issue.I argued.

My friend still is undeterred. She said." Sonakshi will set right everything. Give her benefit of doubt."


I nodded my head in desperation and walked towards my class. Benefit of Doubt. Again saved Sonakshi.

God save Dev Dixit...and the saga continues..


Note. Tried to present the scene in my college everyday at lunch break with my coleague's permission.

Thank you Sunanda for being sportive.


Lakshmi

Created

Last reply

Replies

30

Views

3.3k

Users

13

Likes

99

Frequent Posters

sp12 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Hmm... Interesting. Since we are talking about benefit of doubt I have a few questions though.
1. Can we give the benefit of doubt to Ishwari for making Dev sign the pre-nup as she was trying to secure her daughters future.
2. Can we give the benefit of doubt to Dev for hiding Sonakshi's infertility as he was trying to save her from the pain.
3. Can we give benefit of doubt to Dev for slapping Bejoy as it was unintentional.
4. Can we give benefit of doubt to Ishwari for not allowing Sonakshi when she came with a six month old Soha as she wanted to save Dev from the pain.
5. Can we give the benefit of doubt to Sonakshi for hiding Soha's truth from Dev as she was hurt and had to take care of her family.

If the answer for any one of the above is Yes, then i have no issues giving Sonakshi the benefit of doubt in this situation as well. If any one of the answer is No then the discussion on giving benefit of doubt should end there itself.

Just my POV, no offence.
Snehavinaya thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Lakshmi, very few of us only are there I think who cannot digest all this.
I think Vicky may seriously harm soha & then she will realize.
Even if something happens to Dev also , I don't know whether she would be that concerned, seeing her present condition. Sorry to say , now I feel Dev was better off without sonakshi all these years.
Looks like she can't tolerate him!!
Then why the reunion??
But still sonakshi has loads of people justifying her actions.
Even if dev didn't do anything also , they are ready to bash him.

What I cannot understand is - in a minute she forgave Vicky but still holding grudge against Dev.
How many times he said sorry?
I don't even feel like watching but still watching because it has become a routine now.
No love left between the couple...
Edited by Snehavinaya - 8 years ago
Suchi_Ejf_fan thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
Nice post di
Agree with u . Pls Don't take this show and each and every character seriously .it's just a serial . Just our part of life.don't spoil ur mood just for it .

Coming to sonakshi yes makers butchered her character badly
Even elena was more affected than her. I don't know why makers want to show her maahan .
How she was so calm yesterday

Just hope sona herself tell dev about it .

Edited by _suchi_ - 8 years ago
WeRockTheWorld thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
Well you all are forgetting something ...this is fiction...hence Sonakshi is a character of someones imagination...hence she is fictional...which means doesn't exist... 😆 🤣

The one who created the character wanted to make all MILs believe that there are characters like Sonakshi who if they try can get as their DIL... 😆

Jokes apart , She looked very cold and calm...her facade has to collapse...I have seen women much stronger than Sonakshi with even better patience...and cool cat image...but these women when they are alone they cry , self talk or get into a shell sometimes...it is imp for CVs to show that part of her...even if she doesn't want to show her emtions to any one...its OK...at least show a scene where we can see her emotional side...even if its self talk and crying alone...its fine...but that out burst have to be there... 😉
RUQAIYA10 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
When giving someone the benefit of the doubt, you are believing what they say and taking their word because you, yourself, have some doubt about what happened. But as viewers of the show we are omniscient, which means there is very little room for doubt so why should we give Sonakshi that benefit?

Bottom line is Dev should not be kept in the dark. The truth about the eviction is not a trivial matter which you can hide to maintain peace in the family . It's a major incident that resulted in breaking two homes, a marriage and many lives. Sonakshi owes it to Dev.
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: RUQAIYA10

When giving someone the benefit of the doubt, you are believing what they say and taking their word because you, yourself, have some doubt about what happened. But as viewers of the show we are omniscient, which means there is very little room for doubt so why should we give Sonakshi that benefit?

Bottom line is Dev should not be kept in the dark. The truth about the eviction is not a trivial matter which you can hide to maintain peace in the family . It's a major incident that resulted in breaking two homes, a marriage and many lives. Sonakshi owes it to Dev.

I am against giving Sonakshi benefit of doubt especially in this issue. My post is an out come of frustration towards the overflowing concern for Sonakshi. Not only my friend but I came across many who just want to give her benefit of doubt and redeem her from every wrong decision she took. I hope you are able to understand my stand now.




Lakshmi
ltelidevara thumbnail
Visit Streak 1000 Thumbnail Visit Streak 750 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 8 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: sp12

Hmm... Interesting. Since we are talking about benefit of doubt I have a few questions though.
1. Can we give the benefit of doubt to Ishwari for making Dev sign the pre-nup as she was trying to secure her daughters future.
2. Can we give the benefit of doubt to Dev for hiding Sonakshi's infertility as he was trying to save her from the pain.
3. Can we give benefit of doubt to Dev for slapping Bejoy as it was unintentional.
4. Can we give benefit of doubt to Ishwari for not allowing Sonakshi when she came with a six month old Soha as she wanted to save Dev from the pain.
5. Can we give the benefit of doubt to Sonakshi for hiding Soha's truth from Dev as she was hurt and had to take care of her family.

If the answer for any one of the above is Yes, then i have no issues giving Sonakshi the benefit of doubt in this situation as well. If any one of the answer is No then the discussion on giving benefit of doubt should end there itself.

Just my POV, no offence.

You know I know in all those above instances no benefit of doubt will be given to any of them. Sonakshi is privileged to have that. If not all but most of the viewers will give her benefit of doubt.
RUQAIYA10 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: ltelidevara

I am against giving Sonakshi benefit of doubt especially in this issue. My post is an out come of frustration towards the overflowing concern for Sonakshi. Not only my friend but I came across many who just want to give her benefit of doubt and redeem her from every wrong decision she took. I hope you are able to understand my stand now.

Lakshmi



Don't worry I understand what you are saying. I was trying to make a point on precisely why we as viewers cannot give Sonakshi the benefit of doubt. I am very much disappointed with heri. The problem is she is considerate to everyone except her husband.
mily_mathew thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: WeRockTheWorld

Well you all are forgetting something ...this is fiction...hence Sonakshi is a character of someones imagination...hence she is fictional...which means doesn't exist... 😆 🤣

The one who created the character wanted to make all MILs believe that there are characters like Sonakshi who if they try can get as their DIL... 😆

Jokes apart , She looked very cold and calm...her facade has to collapse...I have seen women much stronger than Sonakshi with even better patience...and cool cat image...but these women when they are alone they cry , self talk or get into a shell sometimes...it is imp for CVs to show that part of her...even if she doesn't want to show her emtions to any one...its OK...at least show a scene where we can see her emotional side...even if its self talk and crying alone...its fine...but that out burst have to be there... 😉

I agree with u. I have seen much better women in real life who are actually sensible. strong and empathetic. Sonakshi is just a sham. I mean why show her as mahaaan. Show her as selfless but clever and extremely protective of her family. But yesterday she was just dumb for me when they tried to make her mahaaan.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".