I think the same too... it's just another day - but then, I realise that, it's the completion of one revolution of the Earth around the Sun from a certain point we call Jan 1st...
But then, again, when I think more about it... considering how in universe there's never 'fixed' point, even when Earth does keep going around the Sun in a seemingly constant manner, I realise the sillyness of the whole thing...
For me, I take 'new year' (or even birthday) in material sense, in a way to make sense of my own life - it's been 365 days, where am I, what am I doing blah blah blah.
And, I'll be honest, I do feel sentimental about new year, I'm a sentimental person.. because no matter how vague the day might be in the real sense, it is the beginning of an year in the practical functional sense of the world. I do buy sweets for myself on new year's.. and wish everyone.. Maybe it's just an opportunity to give well-wishes to people expressly, we can do that other times too but it's a little different on New Year's because everyone is in almost same mood - either bad/good/excited/nervous/anxious/prayerful/whatever.. I like that we all have similar hopes for getting better in life during those 2-3 days - it's wonderful how everyone across the world more or less feels sentimental or atleast feel something if anything - about new year.
Partying and all, I don't understand it for any occasion tbh.
Also! my dad's birthday is on Jan 2, so, it adds to the sentiment I cannot explain.. :-)