Originally posted by: dreamy.tiara
HišAmazing postš... Even I felt that he was lying about his lady love and he really wanted to hit Sanskar harder. But for a second, let us assume all he said is true. Then I don't find a motivation for Sahil for turning negative and there are lots of contradictions. Right now, Sahil is daydreaming about Swara in spite of knowing that she is somebody's wife; and she deeply loves someone else, but due to her amnesia she doesn't consciously remember. She will eventually recover with proper treatment. Would Sahil be happy snatching another's woman whose heart he may never own? Would his conscience allow him to intentionally cause the same pain to another man that he went through? She is not even his "pehla pyaar"š...Moreover, having a wife is different from having an ice-cream or a chocolate. When you lose your ice-cream, you can take another's. I don't think the same thing is applicable in the former case. If the answers are yes, that would make the character dis-conscientious and lustful (I am talking about the character and not the actor, no offence to anyone). And how can such a man be so deeply moved by his partner's death that he would give up music?... I want them to show all the whys! Otherwise, it would look forcedš. If Sahil is not justified properly, he has potential to ruin SwaSan (and that is where my real concern lies!š). ... Thinking along these lines, I now feel, he may have murdered her with his own hands Then he became psycho, gave up music and now he saw her in Swara.I have another question regarding Sahil. He knows Swara is a Bengali. Did he notice her father is Marwari? Does he know she was born an illegitimate child? Let us assume he had any chance (But he doesn't, my Kissan fruit kick is coming!), would he and his mother still accepted her knowing her family background?Also, I think the current conversation between Sahil and Sanskar is enough to give Sanskar red alert signal, because Sahil saved her from river, Sanskar too saved her from Mohini and then at hospital (and numerous times afterwards); Sahil is saying Swara is his friend, that too a special one; now, who knows better than Sanskar in being Swara's friendš... He had played along the "just-friends" lines for too longš; Sahil hit Sanskar for Swara, and Sanskar fought with Laksh numerous times taking Swara's side... So I think Sanskar is smart enough to figure it out that maybe Sahil likes Swara, unless CVs dumb him down (and I don't want that!)...He may trust Swara, but he should not trust Sahil.š...In spite of everything, Swara still loves Sanskar, so all she needs is a reminder to end n number of Sahils who turn up!For a change we would have a villain with 'S' (Sahil) and hero with 'K (Kissan)'...šSorry for going off-topic and ranting too much... Loved your postš³..Keep posting morešTia