Ishita - ruhi scene: one observation today - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

3.2k

Users

12

Likes

68

Frequent Posters

kaa1202 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: pari2015



True and agreed.

But sometimes some actions give you great learning in form of lessons.
Our small mistake can lead to detrimental effect in others life especially who are closely bonded with us.


Ishita didn't even think about her kids before doing this stuff..
That is where it is contradictory when compared to the past happenings in the show..
pari2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: DivanIshraru

I can understand ur POV bt still ruhi will never chose shagun over ishita. when she wl come to knw abt d planning she wl b hurt bt ruhi loves ishita not because ishita loves her bt ruhi's love fr ishita knows no condition.
even today she ws nt saying hr coz she did nt wanted to upset ishita


Its true. I agree. But she is suffering very badly. Not able to perform in a class. One can understand her state of mind. She is worried about Ishima because she loves her. What Ishita is doing. She at least would have not done drama before children. Especially on Kanya pujan when small kids were present.

Actually, it is mistake of cvs that they have to make last minute changes to accommodate somebody which they would have thought even.

I think cvs should end this track immediately. More they try to give justification, more heavy price they have to pay by loosing fans.
I am not talking about trp aunties. I cannot understand their logic of choosing serials






abhilasha_dream thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#23
This track defies the sacrificing Ishita which the CV's are trying to portray coz the lady who thinks about everybody and is supposed to be bearing so much in front of others (repeatedly told by other characters in the serial) is in real torturing others.

1) Emotional Suffering - The whole story was about how a real mother or in fact parents put their kids in such situations where they are going through immense emotional turmoil and a lady who cannot give birth saves them from this ordeal but today the same lady is putting those very kids and everybody in the house through immense emotional turmoil and that too for a reason which is so easy to solve.

The lady who thinks about others pain has actually become immune to everybody's suffering and feels her acts are correct. She has become blind to the fact that her husband is losing his reputation in market due to negligence in work coz of the stress . the kids have gone back to what they were before she entered their lives.


2) Value of Relationship - In order to find the culprit, slowly and steadily she is putting all the relations at stake. False accussations sometimes leads to breakage of relations, specially if they are not blood related. Secondly, this jail act etc. Can cause very serious harm to the careers of ppl.

3) Hiding info from husband - A person who wants all the info from her husband if not given doesn't second in beating him up in front of others is now hiding all the important info from him.

4) Legal aspect - CV's are taking creative liability and absconding this fact but in real u cannot just pick ppl up and interrogate them when there is no official FIR done. Specially if he is a reputed lawyer , they can sue them for harming their goodwill and Abhishek , Ishita can land in lot of trouble due to this.


pari2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: abhilasha_dream

This track defies the sacrificing Ishita which the CV's are trying to portray coz the lady who thinks about everybody and is supposed to be bearing so much in front of others (repeatedly told by other characters in the serial) is in real torturing others.

1) Emotional Suffering - The whole story was about how a real mother or in fact parents put their kids in such situations where they are going through immense emotional turmoil and a lady who cannot give birth saves them from this ordeal but today the same lady is putting those very kids and everybody in the house through immense emotional turmoil and that too for a reason which is so easy to solve.

The lady who thinks about others pain has actually become immune to everybody's suffering and feels her acts are correct. She has become blind to the fact that her husband is losing his reputation in market due to negligence in work coz of the stress . the kids have gone back to what they were before she entered their lives.


2) Value of Relationship - In order to find the culprit, slowly and steadily she is putting all the relations at stake. False accussations sometimes leads to breakage of relations, specially if they are not blood related. Secondly, this jail act etc. Can cause very serious harm to the careers of ppl.

3) Hiding info from husband - A person who wants all the info from her husband if not given doesn't second in beating him up in front of others is now hiding all the important info from him.

4) Legal aspect - CV's are taking creative liability and absconding this fact but in real u cannot just pick ppl up and interrogate them when there is no official FIR done. Specially if he is a reputed lawyer , they can sue them for harming their goodwill and Abhishek , Ishita can land in lot of trouble due to this.




True. I agree with you completely.
It has raised so many issues which need deep analysis, may be justifying one as a mother, wife, daughter or daughter in law. Above all responsible citizen.

I really started hating Ishita from bottom of my heart during this present track. I am in no mood to forgive her.

I have no emotional bonding with ishra.
infinity00 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#25
I think Ishita has damaged her relationship with Ruhi long back , her love for her husband has taken over her feelings for Ruhi , it breaks my heart to see such a powerful message of unconditional love is gone down the drain . I do wonder would Ishita be neglecting Ruhi over obsession with Raman if she was her flesh and blood ? I mean she was all ga ga over Ruhi Ruhi , but not anymore , only vaguely she mentioned how bad she feels for Ruhi , but after that no mention , there was Ishra scenes to show the unconditional love of the love birds but Ishita is not just a lovy dovy wife , she is a mother and that too of Ruhi who she claimed that is her angel , her soul etc etc ... CV's have greatly disappointed the audience who witnessed something so pure and inspirational in the beginning now only see "FOOLS IN LOVE " rightly put by the CHIDYA from the sets ! Ishita is now only Mrs Ishita Raman Bhalla and not Ishima ...

Really liked everybody's point of view 👍🏼
-K.13- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#26
it's actually horrible.

Raman and Ishita are rightfully called fools in love because in YHM season 3 they forget morals, relationships, responsibilities, etc.

I don't know or care to think about what this spells for future tracks.

But I wish they had left the kids out of this like other tracks.

Adi was bullied, actually missed Shagun, and had to see Ishita suffer as IshGun. Ruhi was bullied, accidentally took a gun to school, saw her Ishima have a meltdown in front of her friends, and so on. They have suffered the most in the show thanks to the adults in their lives.

It's not fair of Ishita or Shagun to do this to their kids. Is Raman, a grown man, not able to understand that someone is out to kill him?

Idk, it's sad to see this because Ishita, her unbaised love for Ruhi, and her struggles with her sense of self due to her infertility were all the big things that drew me to her and set her apart from other FLs...but they have dismantled all of that since she miraculaously got pregnant & now she doesn't seem very different from any Kkusum, Tulsi, or Gopi.

The last track ruined Raman's sense of morality (even more than the impulsive stupidity of child swap or dafa ho jao x2) - something his character was founded on.

This track is ruining Ishima (even more than the lack of action in child swap which will still understandable) - something her character was founded on.

Edited by -K.13- - 10 years ago
mukta08 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#27
I agree to it completely
I wish we get our old YHM back dying to see the beauty of those relations which were the soul of the serial
The reason of my watching YHM was only and only ISHRU and later ishra
How I wish to see the special bond again but deep down in my heart I know it will never come back again
RIP YHM and RIP CVs
-K.13- thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: infinity00


So so true ! Both Ishita and Shagun has no care for the kids , even now when Ishita is NORMAL she doesn't care about what's going in kids life . CV's are so over obsessed with this CHAPPAR PHAAD TRP , that they forgot everything else . I pity the audience , can't say much as its not my position to question people's choice , but non the less I pity , I pity ...


I wouldn't say Ishita has no care b/c today she wanted to try to get Ruhi to open up per the WU I read. I think like Raman became blind in surrogacy track to have a baby that he threw away his morals...Ishita is blind in this plan to save Raman that she lost her sense of emotional warmth to others.

But idk - the makers write this crap on the fly probably & it's not gonna end anytime soon.
infinity00 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: -K.13-



I wouldn't say Ishita has no care b/c today she wanted to try to get Ruhi to open up per the WU I read. I think like Raman became blind in surrogacy track to have a baby that he threw away his morals...Ishita is blind in this plan to save Raman that she lost her sense of emotional warmth to others.

But idk - the makers write this crap on the fly probably & it's not gonna end anytime soon.



Yes , it's not going to end for next 2/3 months as I guess they will justify to each and every person , just as Telutubbies became power rangers it would become " Hum saath saath hain" as each character would say " you are Mahan Ishita , I am with you in saving Raman " , everyone BUT RAMAN ...
kras thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: momb24

The bonding got lost long back when Ruhi started getting involved in her parent family planning and visiting the hospital on her own. Now they are trying to show in the most pathetic way how Raman is important to Ishita by torturing the family in the name of saving him from being killed

agree

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".