Some views from a Karna lover,thumbs down to Swastik & Sid T

sania_58 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
I am a Lover of Karna
But I am not at all a fan of Suryaputra Karna.
I am new in this forums.
Hii everyone, I am Madhumita.
This is my First topic in the forums.

I was not at all interested in this show because I got my Karna. Its Aham Sharma.I know in Mahabharata also they showed many crap, but its okay, I tolarated & I accepted.I also accepted the DDLG type proposal scene.😉Somehow, I think, in Mahabharata they maintained dignity of Karna.
They launched Suryaputra Karna in a grand way.But I cant stop myself to watch the show.But I was completely disappointed.My mom even asked me, in which book on Karna it is mentioned that Radha hated Karna in childhood???I said to her, no idea mom.May be Sid T follow some unique book.
Then, the story completely get in a fictional way.I left the show.Suddenly today morning, I catched the repeat telecast of Sony's Karna,because one of my friend, tell me to watch today's episode.& What I saw, I left speechless.

I am Sorry to all the fans of this show, But I want Sony to stop the crap.Its a insult to all the Mahabharata characters & Karna also.I am not a scholar of like many others, But I know they are insulting the Epic.

They never understand Karna.They dont need to destroy anybody's character to justify Karna as a HERO.Karna is & will forever be a Hero in my eyes.His struggle, his sufferings,his friendship, his Danveerta, his courage & also his faults, show these things.Your show will be a HIT.Creative teams, please dont show your story, show the original story.I am in a super tensed mood what will they do to Draupadi's character??

I personally think, this is a wrong time, to launch Suryaputra Karna,Already Aham did a great job.But Visesh & Vasant, both of their performances are awesome.But crap script destroying all efforts.Swastik Productions, please stop torture us with your shows.

Thumbs Down to Sid T & Swastik👎🏼

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

2.5k

Users

10

Likes

54

Frequent Posters

AhamyTed thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
MB's fame went into SidT's head nd he thot Dt even if he ruins the whole story , it wudnt matter👎🏼
Shon's death was too brutal ... Cried a lot yesterday !
Jst imagine wt will he do to other important characters now..
Nd in wt new way will he shape up the end of this show...

Nandita_Siddian thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
Nice post 👏 ...totally agreed...i am an hardcore karna lover... I did not loved sidT 's Mb also...but I just hate the show SPK...karna was totally ruined here...in Mb karna was very sweet but still tolerable...particularly aham was just mind blowing... 😳 ..even me too loved his DDLJ type poetic love scene 😛 ...here also all the actors till now have done awesome role play...but I just hate the characterisation of karna by SiDT...for SiDT karna was just an arrogant worrior who was used by others... he never bother to focus on any of his other qualities...honestly speaking I am not at all interested how he would characterised the other characters...becoz every coin has two opposite sides...I am prepared to take that also...but after watching SPk I must say sidT may have a great love for karna which inspired him to produce a whole show on him...but he have no understanding of the character Karna. 🤢
shivvy_24 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Very disappointed in this show, i expected a unique story created by sid t to make up for karna's childhood but what they have done instead is mix the main mahabharat plots and included karna in it.
MB was altered a little bit by sid t but it wasnt too much, in this show however im very disappointed. It has potential to be an amazing show but random nonsense storylines have been added instead.
sania_58 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Nandita_Siddian

Nice post 👏 ...totally agreed...i am an hardcore karna lover... I did not loved sidT 's Mb also...but I just hate the show SPK...karna was totally ruined here...in Mb karna was very sweet but still tolerable...particularly aham was just mind blowing... 😳 ..even me too loved his DDLJ type poetic love scene 😛 ...here also all the actors till now have done awesome role play...but I just hate the characterisation of karna by SiDT...for SiDT karna was just an arrogant worrior who was used by others... he never bother to focus on any of his other qualities...honestly speaking I am not at all interested how he would characterised the other characters...becoz every coin has two opposite sides...I am prepared to take that also...but after watching SPk I must say sidT may have a great love for karna which inspired him to produce a whole show on him...but he have no understanding of the character Karna. 🤢



Hii Nandita,
I am also a hard-core Karna lover.He is my childhood crush.If I can get a chance to chose any man, I will chose Karna without any doubt.
I love him & now, I am shouting please stop insulting my Karna.Please Stop showing fake stories in National Television on a Epic Hero.
Karna's bonding with Radha-maa, Swastik failed to portray this.They casted Mauli Ganguly in Radha's role. She is a brillaint actress, But the crap creatives failed to use her talent.
Little Karna saved Radha maa's life, then Radha Maa started loving him.What a selfish Radha Maa.😲😲😲😲
Not much I knew about his childhood, But Five Pandavas with Karna, My God.😲😲
I dont know how will they show the rejection from Drona.
The most interesting thing in Karna's character is His Acceptance & he moved on in his life.
I loved his Pride.I love his passion for Archery. In my eyes, He is the Best.
I always wonder, Karna , who insulted Draupadi in Dyut Sabha, the same man cut his Kavach-Kundal from body & gave it to Indra, the same man promised Kunti to spare the lives of his 4 sons.
A Karna lover also cant ignore his faults.Without these faults Karna Karna nahin hota.

In Star-Bharat, Karna's portrayal was short.They dont get much time to destroy Karna😉
& also top-notch performance maintained the dignity.
Aham understand Karna's pain, sufferings, pride, faults.
Last scene, Karna death in kunti's lap, with the lori & all.My God, but still I watched it for Aham.
Its over-dramatic.
I already left Suryaputra Karna.Its not possible for me to tolarate.
I dont have any plans to watch, because I got my Karna.
But All the best to Gautam Rode.

sania_58 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: AhamyTed

MB's fame went into SidT's head nd he thot Dt even if he ruins the whole story , it wudnt matter👎🏼

Shon's death was too brutal ... Cried a lot yesterday !
Jst imagine wt will he do to other important characters now..
Nd in wt new way will he shape up the end of this show...



Yes Maha, Swastik is ruining their every shows.
I want Aham to stay away from them.
Karna is not a contemporary character.They cant portray him as per their wish.
& I also discover another fact, Sid T & his team, they are sadistic.
sania_58 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: shivvy_24

Very disappointed in this show, i expected a unique story created by sid t to make up for karna's childhood but what they have done instead is mix the main mahabharat plots and included karna in it.

MB was altered a little bit by sid t but it wasnt too much, in this show however im very disappointed. It has potential to be an amazing show but random nonsense storylines have been added instead.



I am also disappointed.
They are insulting the epic characters.
About Karna's childhood, no need to show too much.
Cant they show the real facts using creativity????
If they portray Karna with real facts, then it will surely be a Hit.But the nonsense.A big sighh😭

Mayavi-26 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
sania, when did sid T ever stick to real history we all know he always played with it , even Starbharat was full of extortion, which was done to pleased star plus karna character was not present well in that also,if he was not rude then he was never cry baby, we all know according to history arjun was never present there where karna give his kavach but spbharat they showed arjun present there ,
karna last rituals was also done by durry and not pandavas karna friendship with durry was never shown properly in spbharat . sid T was never loyal to any of his project he always do things to pleased channel.
so I wont expect much from him either.
Edited by flamenco - 10 years ago
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Welcome to the forum.. which is now a vacant place almost... all thanks to the show.. Well like you all of us were excited for this show.. but it seems that someone in that creative team just hates karna to the core.. and decided to take revenge from him in this way..😳
No Karna lover will be happy seeing this SPK version of his.. I mean I hate to say but can you imagine after watching this version...I feel like StarB version was so good🤔even with manipulation...
Nandita_Siddian thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
And another point I missed out that was karna's kavach...it never appear????I think suryadev gave it to him for his ultimate protection ...even lord Krishna admited that he could not pierce that kavach by his sudarshan chakra...and karna had no restriction to made it appeared...it was totally his out of control and automatically appeared and saved him from any kind of weapons...but here bheeshma is repeatedly tying him with nagpaas others are using weapon on him...but still it is not appearing!!!! whole hastinapur including kunti knew about his kavach from his young age and it was generally a hot topic of discussion of the general ppl of hastinapur...becoz it was a rare case ...but surprisingly in sidT's version hastinapur ppl not even know the kavach of karna... 🤪

Once upon a time I thought that starbharat was the ultimate inpretation of Mb...but after watching SPK my previous opinion was totally changed. 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".