Its amazing how I have never chanced upon a similar post questioning or inviting a sentence on Manik's "right and wrongs".
Obviously because Nandini happens to be people's fav criminal, ahh what a beloved criminal she makes for ❤️
Firstly, love and life is not solely about "learning from every mistake/fall and not repeating them again". Its always more about how we get up and recover or make up for it. Why and where does this law and rule comes from that "she should learn : to trust, to share truths, not hide health hazardous stuff from Manik?" Again this rule always crops up onky when nandini attempts to take on to something solely? Is it that she cannot be the hero for herself abd her love or that she Shouldn't be one or she doesn't look nice to be one?
MaNan are not keeping a "scorecard" but for those who are, the factual scorecard below -
Manik welcomed Soha just to irk Nandu, Nandu saw Soha hallucinating about manik and tried to warn him, even told him that soha will hijack him from the party for alone time but Manik took it lightly, hence came the farmhouse, where Nandini's persistent guarding outside Manik's door saved him from falling into Soha's despo clutches.
Finally Manik discovered the tapes in which Soha releatedly talked about killing nandini to get to manik. Manik had "resources" as someone very nicely pointed in this thread, he blackmailed khurrana convincingly and decided to "hide" the facts about soha from nandu and Everyone. Like we exoect or constantly question nandu on not teaming up with fab5, did Manik ever think of teaming up with Nandu's friend navya to keep nandini safe and have "back up". No, right? Because he had enough faith in himself and his strategy of handling soha through khurrana, he was confident to keep nandu safe on his own. What happened? Soha cane unbeknownst to manik, had Nandu inhale the powder which inturn threw nandu straight into her clutches, all this while manik was right there in the vicinity. He planned with good intent but couldn't succeed.
Nandini tried to keep Manik away from Pandit because of FC and Manik hid about Nyo, his discvery of riddhima and pandit's dirty secret because he thought he is handling it right. On FC nandu got to know the truth, they performed, but manik didn't know that pandit will go to any lengths to keep riddhima from talking. Hence pandit tied riddhima, manik got duped by riddhima's text that she has gone back. They went out freely thinking that pandit is off the scene but nandu ended up kidnapped. Did anyone point a finger brainlessly at manik that he is indirectly, through some compkex equation, the y responsible for nandini's x? No, right? Did we question whether he is right or wrong in his intent or plan? No, because we knew that manik loves nandini and whatever he is doing or planning is the best of his heart and soul because no one loves nandu more than him. Even if soha got nandu, nearly set fire to nandu, even if pandit tied riddhima and sneaked up on manan to kidnap nandini (thanks to nyonika's orders), we knew that its not what manik woukd or could have foreseen.
So if nandu is doing the same, planning something effectively, to her soul and heart's best, to keep manik away from harm's way, thinking to follow her plan on her own, without linking in any back up in the form of fab5, then why or how does that become "wrong" on her part? Why these slogans of "stupid", "never learnig", "liar", "annoying" etc etc always thrown on her face when its MaNan and not Nandu only who works this way?
Just because she is a girl, hence by default "wrong"? Its not me, its the conclusion derived from the posts that find nandu annoying and stupid in her inability to "learn" from mistakes.
Nandu is right in what she is doing, the girl has the guts and brain + actions to match, givee her time.
Edited by -Sahar- - 10 years ago