Nandini right or wrong????

hav6587 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
There is set of viewers who actually are positive for Nandini and some who think she is wrong by hiding it from manek about aryaman truth...what I want to know is how many of you are thinking she is right n how many think she is wrong share ur views ...well I have both sides to summarise ...I think the reason she is not telling maybe coz of manek's health condition ,or maybe she might be afraid of manek's anger on knowing aryaman truth,or maybe she doesn't want manek to get into all this she wants t protect manek all alone ...now seeing the other side of coin I think manek's health is improving secondly I think now manek won't react impulsively which he did earlier I mean if noticed even during harshad issue in mangalore he handled the situation calmly without any violence ...he taught harshad a lesson without getting physical ...even harshad admitted to niyonica that manek is not that angry man anymore he reacts to situation wisely now ...so I think knowing this Nandini should not have fear of manek reacting impulsively to aryaman ...lastly if Nandini wants to keep manek safe and away from all this mess she has to be very sharp and by now aryaman has already targeted manek twice once for inserting the chip and today also he almost succeeded in his plans ...Nandini was told by aryaman that u r too innocent and trusted me again very easily and she very well knows aryaman is surely upto something then she has to do something to analyse things n soon take some action...keeping aryaman in her group is not enough she has to think otherwise and stop that creepy brother of that psycho soha...she can't stay calm and wait for aryaman to keep in her group and keep him away from manek...the only thing which is keeping my mere hopes is maybe she is waiting for the right time to tell about it to manek or any other fab5 member about aryaman or maybe she will think about today's incident and think that maybe something is wrong...

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.4k

Users

9

Likes

11

Frequent Posters

BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Well said 👍🏼 I understand why she is doing all that but somewhere deep down it seems illogical to me. I understand she does not want to tell Manik because of his impulsive nature but at the same time she knows Cabir is a cool headed guy and she is a good friend of his. Then why not take him into confidence and tell him? When you make a plan you need to have back up. There were times when Manik handled things on his own but then he had the resources with which he could control a situation. But Nandini is naive. Does she really think she can handle Aryamann alone? I know to prove their point CVs will defo show Nandini as the winner however illogical it will seem coz love apparently overcomes all hurdles etc etc The scene where Nandini talks to Aryamann outside the recording room and cries in front of him was sort of silly. For her, her love for Manik is her greatest strength but does she honestly think her love is greater than every other form of love? She was talking to a guy who had lost his sister and he loved her dearly. Her only explanation was more along the lines of the pain she felt for Manik. Really? Is that enough to convince Aryaman that he should give her a chance? Instead she could have tried to gather evidence for what happened and told Aryamann the full truth. Yeah she got her doubts later as to how Aryaman agreed to give her a chance but the scene still looked illogical to me.

I still hope she confides in Fab 4 about Aryaman because more than anything they deserve to know that Aryaman is a threat to Manik's life. They have their doubts on him already and if they get to know about this, they can help Nandini in protecting Manik without letting him know.
Edited by FieryHeart - 10 years ago
-QueenlyChitra- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
i agree with @hav @fieryheart u guys are right Nandini really needs someone to help her out in protecting manik from that psycho aryaman whom she cant handle on her own his sis soha almost killed her and now aryaman is doing the same with manik i hope she tells manik life danger truth to atleast someone from fab5 and kabir is the best option🤔
shibz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
I understand why Nandini wouldn't share Aryamann's truth with Manik yet.. simple reason - Manik's health. I don't see a reason why Manik would be angry learning about Aryamann. Aryamann is after Manik for revenge not any of his loved ones. Manik takes on his aggressive mode only when his loved ones are targeted. Besides, he listens to Nandini so Nandini can easily calm him down if/when he is angry. I believe she is buying time. However, her reason for not sharing the news with Fab5 isn't strong enough, given that Manik's life is at stake. She wants to protect Manik but she isn't being able to. She thought he'd be safe at home but the guy couldn't stay at home. Manik knows there's something cooking in her mind so I think she should alert him soon for his own good.
hav6587 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
Thank you guys fur ur reply...
-Sahar- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Its amazing how I have never chanced upon a similar post questioning or inviting a sentence on Manik's "right and wrongs".

Obviously because Nandini happens to be people's fav criminal, ahh what a beloved criminal she makes for ❤️

Firstly, love and life is not solely about "learning from every mistake/fall and not repeating them again". Its always more about how we get up and recover or make up for it. Why and where does this law and rule comes from that "she should learn : to trust, to share truths, not hide health hazardous stuff from Manik?" Again this rule always crops up onky when nandini attempts to take on to something solely? Is it that she cannot be the hero for herself abd her love or that she Shouldn't be one or she doesn't look nice to be one?

MaNan are not keeping a "scorecard" but for those who are, the factual scorecard below -

Manik welcomed Soha just to irk Nandu, Nandu saw Soha hallucinating about manik and tried to warn him, even told him that soha will hijack him from the party for alone time but Manik took it lightly, hence came the farmhouse, where Nandini's persistent guarding outside Manik's door saved him from falling into Soha's despo clutches.
Finally Manik discovered the tapes in which Soha releatedly talked about killing nandini to get to manik. Manik had "resources" as someone very nicely pointed in this thread, he blackmailed khurrana convincingly and decided to "hide" the facts about soha from nandu and Everyone. Like we exoect or constantly question nandu on not teaming up with fab5, did Manik ever think of teaming up with Nandu's friend navya to keep nandini safe and have "back up". No, right? Because he had enough faith in himself and his strategy of handling soha through khurrana, he was confident to keep nandu safe on his own. What happened? Soha cane unbeknownst to manik, had Nandu inhale the powder which inturn threw nandu straight into her clutches, all this while manik was right there in the vicinity. He planned with good intent but couldn't succeed.
Nandini tried to keep Manik away from Pandit because of FC and Manik hid about Nyo, his discvery of riddhima and pandit's dirty secret because he thought he is handling it right. On FC nandu got to know the truth, they performed, but manik didn't know that pandit will go to any lengths to keep riddhima from talking. Hence pandit tied riddhima, manik got duped by riddhima's text that she has gone back. They went out freely thinking that pandit is off the scene but nandu ended up kidnapped. Did anyone point a finger brainlessly at manik that he is indirectly, through some compkex equation, the y responsible for nandini's x? No, right? Did we question whether he is right or wrong in his intent or plan? No, because we knew that manik loves nandini and whatever he is doing or planning is the best of his heart and soul because no one loves nandu more than him. Even if soha got nandu, nearly set fire to nandu, even if pandit tied riddhima and sneaked up on manan to kidnap nandini (thanks to nyonika's orders), we knew that its not what manik woukd or could have foreseen.

So if nandu is doing the same, planning something effectively, to her soul and heart's best, to keep manik away from harm's way, thinking to follow her plan on her own, without linking in any back up in the form of fab5, then why or how does that become "wrong" on her part? Why these slogans of "stupid", "never learnig", "liar", "annoying" etc etc always thrown on her face when its MaNan and not Nandu only who works this way?
Just because she is a girl, hence by default "wrong"? Its not me, its the conclusion derived from the posts that find nandu annoying and stupid in her inability to "learn" from mistakes.

Nandu is right in what she is doing, the girl has the guts and brain + actions to match, givee her time.

Edited by -Sahar- - 10 years ago
Riya-111 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#7
Whatever it is, I think sharing and caring are pillars of a relationship. Here caring is present. But sharing is absent. Nandini should share this thing with someone from fab4 if she doesn't want to share it with Manik. Now see, she has become target of Aryamaan. Aryamaan wants to keep Nandini away from Manik. That pathetic disgusting jerk will do anything for keeping Nandini away from Manik. I don't know what is this, but it is not giving positive vibes. Storm is coming and this time a silly mistake of Nandini will become sufficient to finish everything. So before too late, Nandini should share this information with someone especially if Cabeer, then it's better.
cute-aly thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#8
yaar y all these type of discussions. kitni tension he Ky2 Forum pe

nandini is right or wrong

yaar soha and aryamaan's both tracks are similar

similarities

1. at soha's time khurrana ka album ... now radio offer to make album
2. psycho soha ... aryamaan is becoming psycho day by day

refresh your memory for this point

3. manik on his own protect nandini in that track. He didnt mention about the threat to nandini ( Am I Right). guys yaad karo kya manik ne os time FAB 5 ko bataya tha ? They were friends ... aur kisi ko na sahi cabir ko bata deta coz baqi sub ko manan k bare me nahi pata tha but cabir knows everything at that time . Manik ne nandini ko khud protect karne ki koshish ki na


to agar nandini esa kuch karti he to wrong kyo ?

so discussion ki baat yeh he k

soha to fully psycho ho chuki thi but aryamaan is sensible and with full proofs agar os ko convince kiya jae to kya wo samajh jae ga ?

and soha to zinda he na to as a brotheraryamaan ko yeh nahi pata ?

u can read the update of that day for proof http://kaisi-yeh-yaariaan-written-updates.blogspot.com/2015/02/yaariyan-episode-145-13th-february-2015-written-update.html

but is sub me 1 cheez jo mujhe yaad nahi a rahe kisi ko yaad he to plz share
in soha's track wo storage device jo manik k pass thi jis me soha k psycho hone k proofs the kya wo manik k pass he ya police k pass



Edited by cute-aly - 10 years ago
simidi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
WRONG
its simple in relationship its wrong to hide/lie manik was right lies tear you apart . and in nandani case her logic is stupid come on manik is not seriously ill or in icu and in fab 4 case she is basically thinking album deal is more important for them then brother like friend? she knows them long enough now to know they are not just friends they are family and in family family matters more then anything else.
PrettyAaShuu thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#10
I think Nandini is wrong...she should tell somebody tou...she cant handle that aryamaan alone..!!
People are saying that Manik also didnt tell Nandini too..but all see that what happen then..!! Secrets always lead to misunderstanding... But she is not telling Manik just because of his condition..!! So i must say that she should tell Cabir..!! But there is a request..dont call her stupid..she is just only 18 years..will take time to understand..!! But i hope soon..!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".