conspiracy against prashant in II3

musicmantra thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

😡** the conspiracy against prashant by influencing public and trying to make them beleive that PRASHANT is not as good as Amit was and is seen clearly in tonight final gala**

The very first thing i want to say is that ALISHA is not a kind of person to judge in any kind of competition...a person should not be a judge when he/she can't be fair to the descision...she just speaks for the person she likes...not for the talent. and it was clear when she used to take side of sohit in the begining and it was crystal clear again in tonight's gala when amit forgot his lines and the discuss with Anu mallik.

there is so much conpiracy to make amit paul an india idol and not prashant...

1. when judges gives comment to Amit paul, they r so happy n joyfull and speaks so many good things regarding him, but when its time to comment for Prashant they speak a line or two ( except Anu mallick who sometime do speak for prashant)...and the tone and expression while commenting on Prashant's performance changes so much then in Amit's.

2. when Amit sang his first song in final gala, Anu mallick said," .....dhol bajao, indian idol tu hi banega amit banki sab hatt jaao." How can he say that thing so directly when Prashant was yet to sing...it was all to influence public to vote for amit not to prashant.

3. when Prashant missed a bit in his first song " aashiq banaya aapne"...all 4 judges pointed directly to the mistake by saying he forgot the line...though he only missed a bit but even after then he didn't stop singing...he continued his lines and came back so well in the antara....but when Amit missed the bit he was not even able to catch it up so soon and he missed a whole stanza...

But then that was not that much big mistake for amit according to judges..." har gunah maff"....why should that be...IN MISSING A BIT AND MISSING A WHOLE PARAGRAPH IS A LOT DIFFERENT THING...and how could Javed akhtar say that they both are even now..

those all points were again to influence public to vote for amit not PRASHANT....

4. Most of the time the camera was focused to amit not to PRASHANT. this was again done intentionally so that when public will see amit more than prashant then they will think of him more and vote him more....what a trick huh....

Prashant is always getting more votes than any other constestant and this all thing were said and one just because judges and Sony II3 team wants amit to get the title not the prashant.....

But its PRASHANT who deserves the title....and i hope all the viewers noticed these things. and can see this conpiracy against prashant very cleary...and want to tell them don't get influecne with such things..and KEEP VOTING FOR PRASHANT......

Prashant was so amazing today...and was much better than amit...the song amit sang " hamma..hamma"..listen to the orginal song and u will find the difference...the orginal song is in more high scale than amit sang...he voice not suiting the song so much but still judges gave him so good comments...Javed also said his voice was for this song...crap. listen to orginal u will find the difference....those all comments was also said intentionally to boost up amit's performance....

PRASHANT MUST BE THE INDIAN IDOL 3...vote for him...

________________________________________verma.

Created

Last reply

Replies

77

Views

7k

Users

38

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

x_nepaligurl_x thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2

I agree with u 100%

Edited by x_nepaligurl_x - 18 years ago
chanaa thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: musicmantra

😡** the conspiracy against prashant by influencing public and trying to make them beleive that PRASHANT is not as good as Amit was and is seen clearly in tonight final gala**

The very first thing i want to say is that ALISHA is not a kind of person to judge in any kind of competition...a person should not be a judge when he/she can't be fair to the descision...she just speaks for the person she likes...not for the talent. and it was clear when she used to take side of sohit in the begining and it was crystal clear again in tonight's gala when amit forgot his lines and the discuss with Anu mallik.

there is so much conpiracy to make amit paul an india idol and not prashant...

1. when judges gives comment to Amit paul, they r so happy n joyfull and speaks so many good things regarding him, but when its time to comment for Prashant they speak a line or two ( except Anu mallick who sometime do speak for prashant)...and the tone and expression while commenting on Prashant's performance changes so much then in Amit's.

2. when Amit sang his first song in final gala, Anu mallick said," .....dhol bajao, indian idol tu hi banega amit banki sab hatt jaao." How can he say that thing so directly when Prashant was yet to sing...it was all to influence public to vote for amit not to prashant.

3. when Prashant missed a bit in his first song " aashiq banaya aapne"...all 4 judges pointed directly to the mistake by saying he forgot the line...though he only missed a bit but even after then he didn't stop singing...he continued his lines and came back so well in the antara....but when Amit missed the bit he was not even able to catch it up so soon and he missed a whole stanza...

But then that was not that much big mistake for amit according to judges..." har gunah maff"....why should that be...IN MISSING A BIT AND MISSING A WHOLE PARAGRAPH IS A LOT DIFFERENT THING...and how could Javed akhtar say that they both are even now..

those all points were again to influence public to vote for amit not PRASHANT....

4. Most of the time the camera was focused to amit not to PRASHANT. this was again done intentionally so that when public will see amit more than prashant then they will think of him more and vote him more....what a trick huh....

Prashant is always getting more votes than any other constestant and this all thing were said and one just because judges and Sony II3 team wants amit to get the title not the prashant.....

But its PRASHANT who deserves the title....and i hope all the viewers noticed these things. and can see this conpiracy against prashant very cleary...and want to tell them don't get influecne with such things..and KEEP VOTING FOR PRASHANT......

Prashant was so amazing today...and was much better than amit...the song amit sang " hamma..hamma"..listen to the orginal song and u will find the difference...the orginal song is in more high scale than amit sang...he voice not suiting the song so much but still judges gave him so good comments...Javed also said his voice was for this song...crap. listen to orginal u will find the difference....those all comments was also said intentionally to boost up amit's performance....

PRASHANT MUST BE THE INDIAN IDOL 3...vote for him...

________________________________________verma.



Good point.
Applicant thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
Whole world who is watching Indian Idol knows that racism is going on. No matter how great Prashant sings, Judges never compliment from heart. On the otherhand when other contestants sings good, judges are never tired of praising them. We as a viewer have eyes and ears to listen and figure it out what is going on. Judges are the bias ones, hypocrits and they blame the public to behave properly and blame people to listen the muisc from ears instead of eyes. Open your eyes and ears widely judges, you will see what we as a viewer are seeing? Otherwise judges are not fit to be judges especially Alisha.
bluffz thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
totally agree wid u.
prashant has been singing fabulous.
even in the mumbai concert ,he was better than amit in everyway.even today,except he missed a beat in the 1st song ,the other songs were g8.
prashant's 'badi mushkil'was really fantastic,why didn't they gave a standing ovation???
i also think its all conspiracy.
when amit missed his song,nobody said anything.even javed saab was like ,its bara bari now.and alisha,just hate her..
these judges r so biased .n after seein todays gala ,i think racism do exist in indain idol!!shame on the biased judges.

musicmantra thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6
thanks to all of you....i really appreciate your comments...
don't know what to say now...no matter who wins we all know that it was and is PRASHANT who deserves the title...
and somewhere this discrimination is coz he is from darjelling...and indians and even indian govt don't treat the people around there as true indians...the place belonged to nepal before and thats the reason people around there still speaks nepali and so does Prashant and that one of the reasons he had to go throught all those dominations thoughout the contest...anyway
and plus something that doesn't relate to all these but i feel...in first place the title of the contest is not correct... it should not be INDIAN IDOL...if they are only searching for a singer then it should be somewhat like "sa re ga ma...voice of india ..." or something specific to singing...as it is INDIAN IDOL then they should search for a person who could be an idol to others...and all these qualities are in PRASHANT NOT AMIT...
Prashant belongs to a family of poor financial background, in the age he should be studying and living his life fully he is working in the place of his father, working hard for his family, he is the only one to take care of his family. and going through all these ups and down he is still holding on to himself...and working hard and hard for the title with hope and dream to give a better life to his family...he is the true idol in a sense...
when they selected the titile INDIAN IDOL, they should look for person like PRASHANT in various field who are truely and IDOL and should praise and help them...
this all was out of the matter of competition, i just felt so i shared it here. hope u agree....
......i have been watching this season from very begining and after this final gala it became totally uncontrolable for me by seeing all these discriminations going on and didn't get a place to pour all those anger and just started the topic.....and after reading your comments...i feel relaxed that there are many others who felt the same...thanks again
-------------------------------------verma.
musicmantra thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
Truth is always bitter mam....guess u haven't been following indian idol...keep both your eyes and ears open while watching...u will know the truth.
r_tvfan thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: musicmantra

Truth is always bitter mam....guess u haven't been following indian idol...keep both your eyes and ears open while watching...u will know the truth.

I only keep my ears open while watching the show. I don't keep my heart open and look at who is poor, or who has gone through hardships. I don't think this is charity show. Based on purely singing, Amit deserves to win. Amit sang 2 songs well out of the 3 while Prashant sang just one well, so Amit should win.

musicmantra thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
wait a minute mam.......
i m not saying prashant should win coz he went though hardships...guess u didn't read the post carefully, that was my personal view regarding the title of contest and i wrote it had nothing to do with the competition...read before u reply....
and are u deaf, amit sang the pujabi well but hamma hamma was okay, not the best...though judges praised him but listen to the original track u will find out the fact that he was not in the true scale in which the orginal song is...listen and compare and then judge it...why judges praised him i have written in first post read it....and amits "tanhayee" was totally ruined, he missed a beat and could't sing a whole paragraph...but prashant's " badi muskil hain" was amazing and tanhayee was superb...and about " aashiq banaya aapne", he missed a beat but still he didn't stop and cameback so quick and sang the rest whole song wonderfully...so in all way prashant was better than amit.....
and if u can't see these facts then i guess u r also deaf like judges and discriminating like the judges. and like Anu mallik said, have some guts to say the truth....
----------------------------------------verma.
Edited by musicmantra - 18 years ago
abru07 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: musicmantra

wait a minute mam.......
i m not saying prashant should win coz he went though hardships...guess u didn't read the post carefully, that was my personal view regarding the title of contest and i wrote it had nothing to do with the competition...read before u reply....
and are u deaf, amit sang the pujabi well but hamma hamma was okay, not the best...though judges praised him but listen to the original track u will find out the fact that he was not in the true scale in which the orginal song is...listen and compare and then judge it...why judges praised him i have written in first post read it....and amits "tanhayee" was totally ruined, he missed a beat and could't sing a whole paragraph...but prashant's " badi muskil hain" was amazing and tanhayee was superb...and about " aashiq banaya aapne", he missed a beat but still he didn't stop and cameback so quick and sang the rest whole song wonderfully...so in all way prashant was better than amit.....
and if u can't see these facts then i guess u r also deaf like judges and discriminating like the judges. and like Anu mallik said, have some guts to say the truth....
----------------------------------------verma.



sorry! but who takes out ten minutes to read a short story..😆😆😆
By the way! that's not the way! how would you feel if someone calls you deaf or blind just because you had a diff opinion.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".