How exactly is Sanam/Jannat an adulterer? - Page 12

Originally posted by: Rein123

I haven't ignored your points but just diagreeing with you over the separation of parents thing. It is the same as abandoning the child may be you have a different point of view but the supposed the child who would come into existence wouldn't think that way. Those who've seen QH1 would know why I'm bringing it up.

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani

Okay, then. Just so that's clear. Thank you for.making that clear.

By the way, there are plenty of children who say the opposite, wondering why the parents just don't divorce. Just saying' since you said definitely that the child would have a certain POV.

And not every child of a separated home feels the same.

But finally, this is clearly said to be the point of contention. Good. People will obvious agree or disagree on this point, and will have different POVs, just glad it's made clear that this is the issue.

Originally posted by: MrDarcyfan

The only acceptable solution is to reunite Sanam with her real husband! SHAJAN is not a real couple as her name is not actually Jannat! So even the name SHAJAN is based on her being Jannat not her real self Sanam! And newsflash they are not "in love!". Shaad dosent love this girl and she doesn't love Shaad! She loves Aahil! The man she is really married to! And if you are expecting that she never gets her memory back is the "Solution?" Well letting a women live in a false situation with a false name for the rest of her life is not acceptable! She is not just a "wife"! She is also a sister and a granddaughter! So would you wish for her to never see her sisters or her grandmother again? All so she can stay hooked up with Shaad? I don't think that is even remotely fair! Also the other part of this equation "Shaad" knows he is not her real husband and that they are not really married? So how can he with any conscience let this situation continue? Especially if he starts to feel something for her, then more reason for him to be honest! "Hoping" that she never gets her memory back is not a solution! It's also extreemly dishonest!

The makers have utterly screwed this premise up! If Sanam was aware she is not Shaad's wife but helping him in turn, by pretending to be, then this situation would be a lot more palatable! (Even with memory loss she has choice!) But the reason it is not, is that she has no clue she is being lied to! This lie is getting bigger by the minute and lots of other people's lives are getting involved and messed up as well! Misbah being one of them!

Also, I will have to say, weather some people on this forum like it or not, Sanam and Aahil were touted as the main OTP of Season 2! They even said that Shaad was to form a love triangle with SAHIL for season 3! Nowhere was it said that Sanam was going to go with Shaad! Also, for Sanam to choose Shaad, she needs to be given a CHOICE? Which in this case she has not been! I know everyone likes to pretend she is someone else and "ship" her with a man who is actually a total stranger! A man who dosent even know her real name! How is this relationship worthy of appreciation? To appreciate something, it has to have some authenticity! But this one has non!

Cuteness is not a good enough reason to root for a couple! This couple is formed in and based on a lie! Also, if Zoya was paired with another man, if ZOYAAN had been shown in a romcom light, people would object and they did! Some of the "semi romantic" scenes they had were highly criticized! They even had a BG! But I don't remember an AT being formed for them? They were married, and knew each other's real names! So that relationship had a lot more validity than this one! Both knew themselves and each other! Here one has no clue of her own name and the man dosent even know it either!

It is quite disheartening to see people "shipping" the pairing of a married women with another man! Especially when said women is being fooled into it! What about this deserves appreciation I don't know? The MODS said that this pairing is promoted by PH! So we're ZOYAAN! In fact when Vikrant M was being cast as Ayaan, GK herself said they wanted to choose an actor that can be paired with Zoya in the future! So they always intended ZOYAAN to be a legitimate pairing! It was always in the synopsis as well! But they never had an AT, and I honestly don't know why this "non couple" does? Making caps for and admiring so called "romantic" scenes of a married women with another man? I am amazed at the blatant disregard here for her marital status!

It is very hypocritical too coz if this was Zoya, NO ONE would make an AT and no one would "ship" her with another man! So to me, people shipping Sanam who is legally wedded wife of Aahil, with a man she met last week, who dosent even know her name? It comes across quite contrived! The motivations don't appear to me as authentic! Most people shipping this couple would Ship a broomstick which is paired with SJ, as long as it is not current male lead! Even if I didn't like it, I would respect this new pairing, if the makers BOTHERED to give this relationship ANY legitimacy! But they have not! So at best all it can be now is an illicit relationship being given respectability through amnesia!